ࡱ> WZV[ }bjbj~~ iHbb} $((((D(+,+++++++$-0+++%%%+%+%%F)6+Ъrb*"++0+,*M1vM1D6+M16+`%++%+,M1 B : WRITING RUBRIC: REFLECTIVE ESSAY A B C D CRITERIAADVANCEDPROFICIENTBASICBELOW BASICOCCASION FOR REFLECTION Why do we view others this way? A reflection on your process of discovery through your chosen novel. Responses show that the writer meets all the criteria listed in Score Point 3. memorably presents the experience for the reflection. uses extended detail from threads, like a writer. uses language to be convincing. shows great depth of thought. is creative and original. reveals ideas through use of comparison and imagery.Responses show that the writer presents the experience through use of concrete, sensory language, quotations, and narrative accounts that effectively use dialogue, action, and pacing. effectively focuses on use of identity wheels, including related experiences and observations.Responses show that the writer does not go deeply enough into the reflection. talks too much about himself/herself instead of the discovery experience. uses concrete detail.Responses show that the writer assumes experience that prompted reflection is implicit in the response. REFLECTION exploring analyzingmeets the criteria listed on Score Point 3 implicitly reveals feelings and thoughts through presentation of the experience for oneself and their other.. makes the reader understand the identities underlying the reflection through use of specific detail. is thoughtful, convincing, insightful, and exploratory. Is firmly grounded in the subject. reveals a strong connection between the other and oneself analyzes the experience by looking at more than one angle. explores the subject in personal and general reflections.is limited to flimsy generalizations.uses only simple, obvious statements.WRITING STRATEGIES - using specific, concrete details - comparing, contrasting - naming, describing - explaining possibilities effectively uses writing strategies to enhance reflection.uses a variety of writing strategies. uses specific, concrete details to make the reflection clear to the reader. uses few purposeful writing strategies. uses some details and sensory language.does not attempt to elaborate ideas or elaborates only through repetition of the initial statement.COHERENCE AND STYLE MLA format Formal essay style (intro-, body, conclusion)consistently uses appropriate language. shows deep insight through a natural flow of ideas and an effective conclusion.achieves unity through a natural progression of ideas. uses precise language. uses only simple, generic language. has lapses in coherence. has the tendency to digress.does not have coherence in writing. is not organized in writing. writes in fragments Rubric: Visual Aid for Identity and Otherness Project CriteriaABCDOccasion for Visual Aid Present commonalities and differences you have discovered between yourself and your other.At least 3 belief systems from your identity wheel are visually represented Thoughtful consideration for presentation of these identities is evidentAt least 3 belief systems from your identity wheels are visually represented For the most part, consideration for presentation of these identities is evidentAt least 2 belief systems from your identity wheels are visually represented Some consideration for presentation of these identities is evident1 belief system from your identity wheels are visually represented Little consideration for presentation of the identities is evident.Content Work should be able to stand alone and not require your explanation.Content is clearly displayed and easy to read from the back of the room Reflects thoughtful consideration of the other and self. Draws parallels between identitiesContent is clearly displayed and easy to read from the center of the room Reflects mostly thoughtful consideration of the other and self. Attempts to draw parallels between identitiesContent is not clearly displayed and is difficult to read from the center of the room Reflects some thoughtful consideration of the other and self. Struggles to draw parallels between identitiesContent is hard to read and cannot be viewed except for being up close. Struggles to provide thoughtful consideration of the other and self. Struggles to draw parallels between identitiesCreativity Your work should reflect the uniqueness of you and your other. Imagery, color, font choice and platform (mode of presentation) should be thoughtfully considered. Work is neat and organized Choices made for visual aid reflect thoughtful consideration. This project has a WOW-factor.Work is mostly neat and organized Choices made for visual aid reflect some thoughtful consideration. This project reflects a clear attempt at the WOW-factor.Work struggles with neatness and organization Choices made for visual aid reflect a struggle with thoughtful consideration. Work is missing neatness and organization Choices made for visual aid reflect an apathy for thoughtful consideration.  !$%*+67=>JKz{  % / 0 V n y  $ F Q [\xݻמטהh h hXYCJ h}CJh$h$5CJ h$CJ h$5CJ h5CJ h<CJhS.hCJ hS.CJ hCJh$h5CJ h5CJ h35CJ h5 hCJ5!KT]hnz $$Ifa$ @ ^@ `@&z{kd$$Iflr *u(2K K K K : 204 lap2yt${ J ? ^ V u ($If^( & F h$IfgdS. & F h$If & F4$If^`4gdS.$If & F $IfgdS.$If$Ifu  # l m ($If^($If & F h$Ifm n y QH>>4 & F$If & F$If $$Ifa$kd $$Iflr *u(2K K K K : 04 layt$ & !\ & F h$If Z$If^Z & F$If & F$If 2GbOC====$If $$Ifa$gd><kd$$Ifl r *u(2K K K K : 04 layt$bc:b ($If^( & F h$If & F$If$If QHH33 & F Z$If^Z`gd$ $$Ifa$kd=$$Iflr *u(2K K K K : 04 layt$>7[x$If & F h$If & F$If QOJE2$Ifgd]sl gd gd kd$$Iflr *u(2K K K K : 04 layt$-.ef@Aɺ铏qfqfqfqfqfqfqfqfh]shkyOJQJh]shkyCJOJQJaJh]shwCJOJQJaJhYvh]shkyCJh]sh CJOJQJaJh]shF CJOJQJaJh]shYvCJOJQJaJh]sh 5CJOJQJaJh]shYv5CJOJQJaJh]sh OJQJh h OJQJ$$Ifgd]sl 0$$Ifa$gd]sl kdi$$IflrNN  H$x( t0r'644 laBp2yt]sL.R & F L$If^`Lgd]sl  & F <$If^<gd]sl  & F $If^gd]sl $Ifgd l $$Ifa$gd]sl 0$$@&Ifa$gd]sl kdP$$IflrNN  H$x( t0r'644 laBp2yt]s-fAL & F K$If^Kgd]sl  & F x$If^xgd]sl $IfgdYvl 0$$@&Ifa$gd]sl kd7$$IflrNN  H$x( t0r'644 laBp2yt]sz|}h OJQJh]shVoOJQJh]shVoCJOJQJaJhVoh]shVoCJ pq N.z{ & FZ$If^Zgd]sl  & F$If^gd]sl $IfgdVol {|}0+gd kd$$IflrNN  H$x( t0r'644 laBp2yt]s9&P1F0:p$= /!"#$% ,&P/ =!"#$%  $$If!vh#vK #v: :V l 205K 5: / 4p2yt$$$If!vh#vK #v: :V l05K 5: / 4yt$$$If!vh#vK #v: :V l 05K 5: / 4yt$$$If!vh#vK #v: :V l05K 5: / 4yt$$$If!vh#vK #v: :V l05K 5: / 4yt$$$IfB!vh#vx#v#v#v#v(:V l t0r'65x5555(aBp2yt]s$$IfB!vh#vx#v#v#v#v(:V l t0r'65x5555(aBp2yt]s$$IfB!vh#vx#v#v#v#v(:V l t0r'65x5555(aBp2yt]s$$IfB!vh#vx#v#v#v#v(:V l t0r'65x5555(aBp2yt]ss666666666vvvvvvvvv66666686666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666hH6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666866666662 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p(8HX`~8XV~ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@_HmH nH sH tH D`D NormalCJOJQJ_HmH sH tH D@D  Heading 1$@&5CJOJQJL@L  Heading 2$$@&a$56CJ OJQJJJ  Heading 3$$@&a$5CJ OJQJ<<  Heading 4$@&OJQJDA`D Default Paragraph FontVi@V 0 Table Normal :V 44 la (k ( 0No List 4>@4 Title$a$5CJ8B@8 Body Text$a$CJ6P@6 Body Text 2CJ8"@8 Caption$a$5CJj`3j  Table Grid7:V0PK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭Vc:E3v@P~Ds |w<v }#H#;H}!z{u m b{} "#8@0(  B S  ?U[JS ^fuy#*&+!)\dcn:>bf " > C     7 ; [ ] 0Mn333333333333333333333333333333333333333 Wcpq{||)Vh}# Ix.I&I*Iac50H~/O:I<S. <'}XY}ky}@ UUUU H$}@UnknownG.[x Times New Roman5Symbol3. .Cx ArialA. Trebuchet MS?= .Cx Courier New;WingdingsA$BCambria Math"hZ\'Z\'kF7 # #!24tt3Q?'}2: d  WRITING RUBRIC: REFLECTIVE ESSAYValued Gateway ClientHornung, MargaretD         Oh+'0  <H h t  $WRITING RUBRIC: REFLECTIVE ESSAYValued Gateway ClientNormalHornung, Margaret14Microsoft Office Word@ @@*hr@֋r ՜.+,0$ hp   Pittsburgh Council On Pub. Ed# t !WRITING RUBRIC: REFLECTIVE ESSAY Title  !"#$&'()*+,./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEGHIJKLMOPQRSTUXY\Root Entry Fr[Data %1Table-1WordDocument iHSummaryInformation(FDocumentSummaryInformation8NMsoDataStore5rЪrK251F4NTP4JVA==25rЪrItem  PropertiesUCompObj r   F Microsoft Word 97-2003 Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q