ࡱ> '` 6#bjbj 8%```````t<:<:<:8t::t$b<="===-@;@ G@kTmTmTmTHTx-[xa$dhvfja`B-@-@BBa``==uaHHHB`=`=kTHBkTHH:N``/O=< 0<: DN Oa0$bO.fDxf/O/Of`CO\O@v@THAD]AO@O@O@aaFO@O@O@$bBBBBtttx)tttx)ttt`````` Medical Ethics Initial Schedule Check online for continuously updated schedule that supersedes this one. You need to use the online schedule to get the LINKS. DateTopicsReadings  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/howtoread.htm" Study aid: How to Read a Philosophical Essay (see link from online schedule)Slides, Notes, Assignments Study Guides (check online)Introduction to Bioethics: Basic Concepts and TheoriesW, 9/9 HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/attendance.doc" \o "Please read carefully!"Attendance and your grade: see link from online scheduleIntroduction to the course. A case study illustrating and anticipating some core bioethical issuesM, 9/14 Introduction to basic ethical concepts and theoriesIntroduction to Bioethics Links to both of these are available on the online schedule.The Caregiver-Patient Relationship: Autonomy vs PaternalismW, 9/16Autonomy and the refusal of treatment Video: Dax caseCowart and Burt, Confronting Death Baumgarten, The Concept of Competence in Medical Ethics Baumgarten,The Concept of Autonomy M, 9/21Test 1 (20 minutes) on basic concepts and theories The extent and limits of autonomyGuiora, Freedom of Information vs Freedom from Information Gewande, Whose Body Is It, AnywayLink to study guide from online scheduleW, 9/23Informed consent: how much information?Canterbury v Spence Brody, TransparencyThe Nature of Limits of MedicineM, 9/28A conservative view of medicineKass, The New BiologyW, 9/30An expansive view of medicineMunson and Davis, Germline Genetic Therapy  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/sportsgene.doc" Article in 11/30/08 New York Times with my comment.  HYPERLINK "http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/30/sports/30genetics.html?_r=1&hp" Original sourceM, 10/5Guest and campus lecture: Dr. Randoloph Nesse, Darwinian Medicine, 1030 CB. Time: 4:30-6 (our regular class time) This lecture is part of the campuss year-long series of events marking the 200th anniversary of Charles Darwins birth and the 150th anniversary of the publication of Origin of Species. Randolph Nesse is a professor of psychology and psychiatry and a leading figure on Darwinian medicine. His main theme is showing how understanding Darwinism can influence medical practice. You can learn more about him on  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~nesse/" his website. Reading: Nesse and Williams, Evolution and the Origins of Disease  The Caregiver-Patient and Caregiver-Caregiver Relationship: Various IssuesW, 10/7ConfidentialityTarasoffM, 10/12Caregiver rights and responsibilitiesKroeger-Mappes, Ethical Dilemmas for Nurses Conscientious objectionEuthanasia and End-of-Life IssuesW, 10/14The issue of euthanasia (introduction) Active and passive euthanasiaRachels, Active and Passive Euthanasia Sullivan, Active and Passive Euthanasia Rachels, More Impertinent Distinctions (first half)M, 10/19For and against voluntary active euthanasiaRachels, More Impertinent Distinctions (second half) Callahan, When Self-Determination Runs AmokW, 10/21Planning ahead for end-of-life careBattin, The Least Worst Death Your Life, Your ChoiceM, 10/26Decisions for the incompetent. Origin and role of ethics committees Deciding for a child: the case of Kenny.Robertson, Examination of Arguments Engelhardt, Ethical Issues in Aiding the Death of Young Children.W, 10/28Test 2: 45 minutes (Time permitting) Is there a duty to die?Hardwig, Is There a Duty to Die? Ackerman, The Duty to Die versus the Duty to Help the Ill Stay AliveStudy guide forthcomingJustice in the Use of Scarce ResourcesM, 11/2Right to Health Care vs Rationing Health CareUN, The Right of Everyone Singer, Why We Must Ration Health Care Lamm, Doctors Have PatientsW, 11/4Two opposing views on medical care HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/econjust.pdf" Economic Justice and American Politics (unpublished, written by instructor) Sade, The Political Fallacy Pellegrino, AltruismM, 11/9What moral obligation does government have to provide health care?Presidents Commission, An Ethical FrameworkW, 11/11Microallocation: Who Shall Live When Not All Can Live?Rescher, The Allocation of Exotic Medical Lifesaving Childress, Who Shall LiveM, 11/16Tough allocation decisionsPersad, Wertheimer, Emanuel, Principles for Allocation  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/CEA.doc" Cost-effectiveness analysis in the UK and US (two NY Times articles)M, 11/18Age-based rationing?Even 90-year-olds are having open-heart surgery:  HYPERLINK "http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/11/health/research/11heart.html?_r=1&sq=survival%20aged%20heart&st=cse&oref=slogin&scp=1&pagewanted=print" Link to very timely article in recent (11/11/08) NY Times on exactly this issue.  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/age-success.doc" Alternate link to article as Word file Callahan, Aging and the Ends of Medicine Childress, Ensuring Carefor the ElderlyM, 11/23Voluntary risks to healthCappelen and Norheim, Responsibility in Health Care: A Liberal Egalitarian Approach Cohen, et al, Alcoholics and Liver TransplantationGenetics and New Reproductive TechnologiesW, 11/25Genetic selection and screening. Is there a moral obligation not to have a genetically seriously disadvantaged child? Purdy, Genetics and Reproductive Risk: Can Having Children Be Immoral?  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/genetics2014.htm" A modest proposal: using genetic information to reduce health care costs Kass, Implications of Prenatal Diagnosis for the Human Right to LifeDo you want to know your genetic profile HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/geneticselftest.doc" \o "Pay $1000 to learn your genetic risks?" ? Two timely articles in The New York Times You might want to look again at the  HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/sportsgene.doc" article in 11/30/08 New York Times with my comment M, 11/30Stem cells and cloning for research (sometimes called therapeutic cloning) HYPERLINK "http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/pres-cloning.doc" Presidents Council Report Kass, The Wisdom of Repugnance Strong, The Ethics of Reproductive CloningW, 12/2Surrogate motherhooodSteinbock, Surrogate Motherhood Anderson, Is Womens Labor a Commodity?December 7 and 9: Student reports/panels, Review, and/or New TopicsW, 12/7 and 12/9Topics to be announced. Student reports may also come earlier and then the schedule for above topics will be revisedM, 12/14Final TestStudy guide forthcoming     PAGE  PAGE 1   gij  5 6 ´£jSj>j)hAPhb10JB*CJOJQJaJph,hAPhb1B*CJOJPJQJ\aJph5jhAPhb1B*CJOJPJQJU\aJphhAPhb15B*CJphhAPhb15B*CJ"ph h Shb1>*B*CJ.aJXphhG>*B*CJaJXphh S>*B*CJaJXph h Sh S>*B*CJaJXphh Sh SB*CJ8aJXphh Shb1B*CJ8aJXph W $Ifl, +]edp:  +x]edp: gd S#5#6 V W  ; < = οߒr^O8^,jhchb1B*CJUaJphhchcB*CJaJph&jhchb1B*CJUaJphhAPhb1B*CJaJph!hAPhb1B*CJOJQJphhAPhb1B*CJaJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphh Shb1B*CJphh Sh SB*CJaJph hAPhb15B*CJaJphhAPhb1B*CJph&h SB*CJOJPJQJ\aJph ?.$@&Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST x wwwwww$Ifl,xkd&$$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcT= H I Q R W X w   4 5 6 r s t u veVGVhAPh`_5B*CJphhAPhb15B*CJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphhAPhb1B*CJphhcB*CJaJph!hAPhAPB*CJOJQJphhAPhb1B*CJaJphhchcB*CJaJph&jhchb1B*CJUaJph6hchb1>*B*CJOJPJQJ\^JaJo(ph!hchb10JB*CJaJph  6 s WGG6G$@&Ifl,$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: TsFX)& 00*6    44 saitp: pyt STs t u *kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST$Ifgdcl,u  R w udPP$@&IfgdKl,$@&Ifl,zkd-$$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcT$Ifl,   R v w x y z   8 ` a b g i Ź{n_TJ{h SB*CJphhAPhb1B*phhAPhb15B*aJphhAPhKB*CJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJph hKhKhKhK5B*aJphhKhK5hAPhK5B*aJphhb15B*CJphhAPhb15B*CJphhAPh`_B*CJphhAPhb1B*CJph!hAPhb1B*CJOJQJphw x y $Ifl,$IfgdKl,y z =-$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST  8 a $@&Ifl,$Ifl,$IfgdKl,a b j :**$Ifl,kd!$$Ifedp: Ts4\Xv")& !00*644 saf4itp: p(yt ST "#$Jwx庭n_nN;N$hAPh`_0J6B*CJaJph!hAPh`_0JB*CJaJphhAPh`_B*CJaJph&jhAPh`_B*CJUaJphhAPh`_5B*aJphhAPh`_B*ph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*CJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphhAPhb1B*phhAPhb15B*aJphhAPhb1B*CJphhAPhnGB*CJph $Ifl,$@&Ifl, =)$@&Ifgdb1l,kdQ$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST "#rr_r$Ifgdb1l,$Ifgdb1l,zkd{ $$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcT#$,J=**$Ifgdb1l,kdE $$Ifedp: Tsc\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STJwde$Ifgdb1l,$@&Ifgdb1l,RSbcdefz{˴xgxVCV-V*jhAPh`_B*CJOJQJUph$hAPh`_6B*CJOJQJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*CJphhAPh`_B*ph!hAPh`_0JB*CJaJph$hAPh`_B*CJPJ\aJph-jhAPh`_B*CJPJU\aJphhAPh`_B*CJaJph&jhAPh`_B*CJUaJph!hAPh`_0JB*CJaJphefn=***$Ifgdb1l,kdo $$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STQRjstƸ{j[jL=0hAPhb1B*CJphhAPhb15B*aJphhAPhb1B*CJaJphhAPh`_5B*CJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*CJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJph!hAPh SB*CJOJQJphh SB*CJOJQJphh`_B*CJOJQJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJph%hAPh`_0JB*CJOJQJph*jhAPh`_B*CJOJQJUph/kd $$Ifedp: TsFv")&400*6    44 saitp: pyt ST$Ifgd Sl,$Ifgdb1l,QRZjstud$@&Ifl,zkd $$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcT$Ifl,tu~=--$Ifl,kdm$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STtu  \fövk^vQ^vD^vQhAPh`_5B*phhAPh`_B*aJphhAPh`_B*CJphhAPh`_B*phhAPh`_B*CJaJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJphhAPh`_5B*aJph hAPh`_5B*CJaJphhAPhb1B*CJphhAPhb1B*aJphhAPhb15B*aJphhAPhb1B*CJaJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJph$Ifl,$@&Ifl, =-$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST >\uuudduu$@&Ifl,$Ifl,zkd$$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcTX=----$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST*kd$$Ifedp: Ts4\Xv")& !00*644 saf4itp: p(yt ST$Ifl,$Ifl,$@&Ifl,=f=----$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STf$Ifl,$Ifl,cdeҔ{jҔ_LL%jhAPh`_5B*UaJphhAPh`_B*ph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJphhAPh`_5B*CJphh SB*CJphhAPh`_5B*aJphhAPh`_B*CJaJphhAPh B*CJaJph hAPh 5B*CJaJphhAPh`_B*CJaJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*CJph=-$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST>$Ifl,$@&Ifl,$Ifgd l,=-$Ifl,kd9$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STDcduuduuu$@&Ifl,$Ifl,zkdi$$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcTdem=--$Ifl,kd3$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST,Ldef#[xyz#$V^hijklͼͱͤͱttgXgthAPh`_0J6B*phhAPh`_0JB*phjhAPh`_B*UphhAPh`_B*CJaJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*CJphhAPh`_B*ph hAPh`_5B*CJaJphhAPh`_5B*aJph%jhAPh`_5B*UaJph hAPh`_0J5B*aJph-Lde$Ifl,$@&Ifl,efn=--$Ifl,kd]$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STkd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST$Ifl,$@&Ifl,#[xy$@&Ifl,$Ifl,yz=--$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STjk$Ifl,$@&Ifl,klu=--$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt STTUpq|"#$O؝v_v_J_v;hAPh`_5B*aJph(hAPh`_0JB*CJPJ\aJph-jhAPh`_B*CJPJU\aJph$hAPh`_B*CJPJ\aJph'hAPh`_6B*CJPJ\aJph$hAPh`_B*CJPJ\aJph!hAPh`_0JB*CJaJph-jhAPh`_B*CJPJU\aJph$hAPh`_B*CJPJ\aJph'hAPh`_5B*CJPJ\aJph$Oz{$Ifl,$@&Ifl,$Ifl,$Ifl,Oyz{|)*+UVW` !tu0ɺɦڕwggZgG$h Sh`_B*CJPJ\aJphhAPh`_0JB*phjhAPh`_B*UphhAPh`_5B*aJphhAPh`_B*PJaJph!hAPh`_B*CJOJQJph'hAPh`_5B*CJPJ\aJphhAPh`_B*CJaJph!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*CJphhAPh`_B*aJphhAPh`_B*ph{|)=----$Ifl,kd$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST)*+V-kd/$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST$Ifl,VW`  uudduuuuu$@&Ifl,$Ifl,zkdY $$Ifedp: Ts)&0*00*644 saitp: p ytcT 01  W X m { | vePE4!hAPhFB*CJOJQJphhAPh`_B*ph(h Sh`_0JB*CJPJ\aJph!h Sh`_0JB*CJaJph$h Sh`_0J6B*CJ aJph!h Sh`_0JB*CJ aJph&jh Sh`_B*CJ UaJphh Sh`_B*CJ aJph(h Sh`_0JB*CJPJ\aJphh Sh`_0JB*CJphh Sh`_B*CJph"jh Sh`_B*CJUph =--$Ifl,kd#!$$Ifedp: Ts\Xv")& !00*644 saitp: p(yt ST ;!*ph@V@@ FollowedHyperlinkph2B@2 Body TextxdO!d Normal (Web) Char)OJPJQJ^J_HmH o(phsH tH `^@2`  Normal (Web)dd[$\$B*CJOJPJQJ^JphJBJ  Footnote Texth<1$`hCJ<@R< Header$ e$x68+b8  Endnote TextCJd-rd  Macro Text"  ` @ CJ_HmH sH tH 4/@4 Listh^h`HC@H Body Text Indenthx^h>O> Greeting $ & FOJQJ:L@: Date$$xa$OJQJN@ +Body Text First Indent 2,Essay double spaced`KH<Q@< Body Text 3 B*phJOJ Double indentx]^HOH Numbered 1.5hx^h`BOB Skip number xx^>O> Multi-level 1.5!xPO"P Numbered 2-digit"h%x^h`%.O2. MC#$$ & F8O28 MCQ$$$ & F<:O: Quote%x]^DObD Comment&$*$ 6B*phDOrD critique '$<x 6B*phPOP bulleted hyperlink ( & FxKH8OQ8 headerwithline)TOT wp-caption-text*dd[$\$ OJQJaJDOD TypewriterCJKHOJQJ^Jo(|@| Table GridA:V,0a ,PP4 @4  SFooter - !.)@.  S Page Number6 Wx6stuRwxyz8abj "#$,Jwdefn    Q R Z j s t u ~   > \  X  = f >Dcdem-Ldefn#[xyzjklu$Oz{|)*+VW` XyZ[l%&'23470p: 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: @0 @0p: @0@00 @0@0 @0 @0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 00 0000 0 0p: 0 00 00 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 0 0 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 000@00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 0 0 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 00 000 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 000 00 0 0p: 0 000 00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 0 000 0 0p: 0 0 000 0 0p: 0 0 0 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0 0000 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 0 0000 000 0p: 0 0 000 0 0p: 0 0 00 0 0p: 0 0p: 0 0 0p: 0 0 0 0p: 0p: 00,0000,0000,00@-000@-00000@-0@-000 00uRxyz8abj#$,Jwdefn    > \  X  = f >Dcdm-Lden#[xyjku$Oz{)*VW` XyZ[l700؀@00 00@00 00H000000{؀@00 00{p: @00 00w00w؀@00 00w@00 00  @00p: 00 00 00 00 00@00 00 0000000000000 0} L70000p: 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000p: 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000p: 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000p: 000000p: 000000 $$$'6 = tO0 l"/#6#!')-6<DFJLRV s u w y a #Jet fdeyk{)V !!"Z""##6# "#$%&(*+,./012345789:;=>?@ABCEGHIKMNOPQSTU5#5<WwRbz #hTp" t0W;V6XXXXXXXXXXXXX  '!!2# AA@0(  H c $ ?top773 p"3$2I 3lQ 3tZ 3L,3tlI 3PJ 3pI  7 78*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace  jmnrsuRa ]e j r \ c  & DH#*X\$'147j\^$'14733 T^6V<Xw456rssw8`    $'17 %&,-01=>EFNOST^_cdgjmnrsuvyz}~/67;<@AEFLMV8<=?@EFKLPQWX` $'147CL JR(wEo8.$#^`OJQJo(hH ^`hH. pp^p`hH. @ @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. ^`hH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PP^P`hH. h(h^h`(hH. ^`hH. 00^0`0hH)  0^ `0hH)  0^ `0hH() 0^`0hH() p0^p`0hH() @0^@`0hH() 0^`0hH()wEwEՅ CL CL Յ 0? 0fu0(Э        p: nG&.b1=4AP S`_ejrGOcK FLWxstuxyz8abj "#$,Jdefn   Q R Z j s t u ~   \  f cdemdefn#xyzjkluz{|)*+VW`Z[l7@1-Canon MP530 printer on DESKNe09:winspoolCanon MP530 Series Printer1-Canon MP530 printer on DESK ߁ od LetterBJDM 0VT$m,`Oj,`OjVT$m,v`Oj,v,v`OjXXDRAFTSample 1' dVT$mVT$m@ VT$m   1-Canon MP530 printer on DESK ߁ od Letter7A1-Canon MP530 printer on DESK ߁ od LetterBJDM 0VT$m,`Oj,`OjVT$m,v`Oj,v,v`OjXXDRAFTSample 1' dVT$mVT$m@ VT$m   1-Canon MP530 printer on DESK ߁ od Letter7A4H 6p@UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z ArialI& ??Arial Unicode MS7&  VerdanaqCentury SchoolbookBookman Old Style?5 z Courier New"1h[<&[<&  1  1Y#Ѕ4>QЅHX?e2Medical EthicsElias BaumgartenEB  Oh+'0  < H T`hpxMedical EthicsElias Baumgarten normal.dotEB2Microsoft Office Word@F#@70@70 ՜.+,D՜.+,P  hp  University of Michigan1 ' Medical Ethics Title$  8@ _PID_HLINKSA NBN$Fhttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/pres-cloning.doc 0{!Dhttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/sportsgene.doc PIhttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/geneticselftest.doc SFhttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/genetics2014.htm K^Ehttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/age-success.doc  'http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/11/health/research/11heart.html?_r=1&sq=survival%20aged%20heart&st=cse&oref=slogin&scp=1&pagewanted=print ^=http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/CEA.doc OT>http://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/econjust.pdf K &http://www-personal.umich.edu/~nesse/  Ahttp://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/30/sports/30genetics.html?_r=1&hp 0{Dhttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/sportsgene.doc ?cDhttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/attendance.doc w/Chttp://www-personal.umich.edu/~elias/Courses/442/09f/howtoread.htm   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijkmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry Fv0Data X_'1TablelfWordDocument8SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjq  FMicrosoft Office Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q