ࡱ> G bjbjَ ]i=]$""""Pr&l"'* Z6661333N| |y$$) +$E]@$Y66'YYY661 ) ""1YbY16<%/"")CHAPTER 11 Capital Budgeting QUESTIONS 1. Why does capital budgeting analysis pay attention only to cash flows?Capital budgeting looks only at cash flows because finance theory argues that cash flows are the underlying determinant of the financial value of a company. By examining cash flows, capital budgeting analysis measures the exchange of value between a proposed project's projected cash outflows and projected cash inflows to test whether the benefits exceed the costssymbol 190 \f "Symbol"if so, the company's financial value should increase. 2. What is a sunk cost? Why is it ignored in capital budgeting?A sunk cost is a cost that has already taken place. It is ignored in capital budgeting because it cannot be changed by the decision under consideration, hence it is irrelevant to the potential change in the company's financial value that would come from accepting the proposed capital budgeting project. 3. What would happen to a capital budgeting analysis if inflation were omitted from the cash flow estimates? Omitting projected inflation would result in a miscalculation of the cash flows from capital budgeting projects. With incorrect projected cash flows, the subsequent analysis and conclusions could also be incorrect, and the company might invest in a value-decreasing project or miss investing in a value-adding opportunity. 4. What is meant by the option inherent in a capital budgeting decision? Every capital budgeting project takes place over a period of time during which a company will face many choices. Examples of these choices are to expand or contract the investment, to replace equipment with newer technology part-way through the project, and to abandon the project altogether. Each of these choices is an option, the opportunity to take whatever course of action is best at that time. By investing in a capital budgeting project, therefore, a company buys not only the immediate project but all subsequent opportunities that derive from it. A financial analyst included the interest cost of the debt used to buy new machinery in the cash flows from a capital budgeting project. Is this correct or incorrect? Why?This is incorrect. The proposed project will be evaluated against a cost of capital after its estimated cash flows are summarized. To include interest in the project's cash flows risks double counting the cost of this capital. In addition, it is not clear which debt will be used to fund the project if it is accepted. Finance theory argues that it is better to wait and incorporate the cost of capital into the analysis after the project's projected nonfinancing cash flows and risks are summarized. 6. What function does a cash flow table play in capital budgeting analysis?A cash flow table is a spreadsheet that organizes cash flows by event and time. It summarizes the flows in a way that makes it easy to apply time value analysis. 7. What is the meaning of: a.Net present value?The net present value of a proposed investment project is the anticipated increase (if positivesymbol 190 \f "Symbol"or decrease if negative) in the financial worth of an organization from investing in that project. b.Internal rate of return?The internal rate of return of a proposed investment project is the anticipated interest rate an organization would earn on the money invested in that project. (Analytically, a proposed project's IRR is the discount rate that makes NPV=0.) In what ways are they the same, and how do they differ?They are the same in that they both begin with the projected cash flows from the investment. They differ in the way they match the cash flows against the organization's cost of capital. NPV incorporates the cost of capital directly in the analysissymbol 190 \f "Symbol"as a result, an NPV number is valid only for an organization with that specific cost of capital. IRR first analyzes the investment's projected cash flows without regard to a cost of capital, making the IRR number valid for any organization with the same cash flow estimates. Cost of capital enters in a second step to test whether the IRR is sufficiently high to add financial value. 8. Why is the net present value of a capital budgeting project equal to zero when its internal rate of return is used as the discount rate?Calculating an NPV involves obtaining the present values of future cash flows. These future flows are greater than the project's initial outflowsymbol 45 \f "Symbol"the IRR describes this difference. If the IRR is used as the discount rate in the NPV analysis, its effect is to exactly remove the greater value in the future cash flows. The present value of these flows becomes equal to the project's initial outlay, and NPV calculates as equal to zero. 9. True or false (and why?):The NPV technique uses the firm's cost of capital in its calculation, but the IRR technique does not. Therefore, the cost of capital is relevant only if capital budgeting projects are evaluated using NPV.False. Although the IRR technique does not use a cost of capital in its first stepsymbol 190 \f "Symbol"calculating the IRR, a cost of capital is required to proceed with the analysis. It is useless to calculate an IRR unless we can compare it to a cost of capital and see whether the return from the proposed project is sufficiently high to justify investing in it. 10. What is the danger of applying one cost of capital to all proposed capital budgeting projects?Not all capital budgeting projects are of the same risk or time horizon. The Fisher model of interest rates tells us that investor's required rates of return depend on forecasted inflation (a function of time horizon) and risk. As a result, each capital budgeting project has its own hurdle rate, a cost of capital appropriate for its particular combination of time and risk. Applying one cost of capital to all proposed projects runs the risk of making poor decisions: rejecting value-adding low-risk projects and accepting nonvalue-adding high risk projects. PROBLEMS SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-1 (a) Should enter the analysis: Cost to purchase $40,000 Cost to install 1,000 Cost of new wiring 2,000 Sales tax 3,000 Economic salvage value 10,000 (b) Initial outlay in the capital budgeting analysis: Cost to purchase $40,000 Cost to install 1,000 Cost of new wiring 2,000 Sales tax 3,000 $46,000 These cash flows all represent payments (outflows) made at "time 0", the initiation of the project. (c) Should not enter the analysis First-year depreciation Accounting salvage value These are not cash flows (although they might lead to tax changes which do affect cash). (d) Yes, both could have a later impact: symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Depreciation will lead to a reduction of income in year 1 (and beyond if the machine can be depreciated past the first year). This will reduce the taxes the firm is obligated to pay. symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Accounting salvage value will enter the depreciation calculation and affect the amount of the periodic tax savings. It will also be part of the calculation of "tax on gain or loss" at the disposal date of the machine. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-2 (a) The switch would result in lower depreciation, hence higher income, in the early years of the life of each asset the firm acquires. This pattern will reverse in the later years of ownership since total depreciation must be the same either way. (b) Nothing - GAAP income is not connected to cash flows. (c) Higher taxable income would lead to higher taxes to pay in the early years of asset ownership. This is opposite to the rules of time value of money and would lower the firm's value. (d) Investors and others make judgements about a firm based, in great extent, on its financial statements. Most managers want always to "put their best face forward." SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-3 (a) Should enter the analysis: Cost of addition $500,000 Cost of new machinery 200,000 Cost of new wiring 30,000 Increase to working capital 60,000 $790,000 The four items above are all incremental cash flows. (b) Should not enter the analysis Book value of existing plant - neither incremental nor a cash flow. Amount spent on study to date - not incremental, a sunk cost. Interest on loan - a financing flow. (c) This would reduce the need for new working capital and lower the initial investment of part (a) to $790,000 - 15,000 = $775,000 The answer to part (b) would not change. (d) This would have to be added to the initial outlay since to build the addition is to forego this benefit. $790,000 + $1,500,000 = $2,290,000 The answer to part (b) would not change here either. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-4 (a) None - it is a sunk cost! Today's decision cannot change that expenditure. (b) The $75,000 would appear in the ice cream analysis as an incremental cash outflow on the date of the inception of the project ("year 0"). (c) symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Alternate uses symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h What they could be sold for today symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h How would the ice cream decision change their future pattern of cash flows. (d) symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Non-truck related costs (e.g., advertising) symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Revenue projections symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Quality-related issues symbol 183 \f "Symbol" \s 10 \h Tax rate. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-5 (a) The given numbers, since cash-flow numbers must include inflation (b) Year Number 0 -25,000 1 8,000(1.06) = 8,480 2 8,480(1.06) = 8,989 3 8,989(1.06) = 9,528 4 9,528(1.06) = 10,100 5 10,100(1.06) = 10,706 (c) (1) To be accurate forecasts of actual cash flows (2) To be consistent with the cost of capital which does include inflation (d) Without inflation in the cash flows, the forecasted flows would be lower. For a standard project (-, +), this would reduce forecasted inflows and bias the analysis toward a lower NPV and IRR. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-6 (a) The given numbers, since cash-flow numbers must include inflation (b) Year Number 0 -70,000 1 10,000(1.09) = 10,900 2 10,900(1.09) = 11,881 3 11,881(1.09) = 12,950 4 12,950(1.09) = 14,116 5 14,116(1.09) = 15,386 6 15,386(1.09) = 16,771 7 16,771(1.09) = 18,280 (c) Since the 70,000 outflow occurs immediately, there is no time for it to change due to inflation. The inflows, coming later in time, are subject to price changes. (d) Yes - in the cost of capital. Like all market-connected interest rates, it contains a premium for inflation. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-7 (a) Cost of machine -$100,000 (b) Annual depreciation = $100,000 - 20,000 = $10,000 per year 8 Incremental cash flow = tax savings = 35%($10,000) = $3,500 per year for 8 years. (c) Improvement to earnings $25,000 per year - Tax on increased earnings (35%) (8,750) $16,250 per year for 8 years (d) Salvage (cash proceeds) $20,000 SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-8 (a) Cost of machine $650,000 (b) Annual depreciation = $650,000 - 50,000 = $66,667 per year 9 Incremental cash flow = tax savings = 35%($66,667) = $23,333 per year for 9 years. (c) Improvement to earnings $80,000 - Tax on above (35%) (28,000) $52,000 per year for 9 years (d) Sale price $60,000 - Tax on gain-on-sale* (3,500) $56,500 * Anticipated gain = sales price - book value = $60,000 - 50,000 = $10,000 Tax on gain = 35%(10,000) = $3,500 SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-9 (a) Present value of costs ($200,000) PV of benefits: % PMT = 75,000, set END % n = 4 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 218,528 i = 14 % % NPV = $18,528 (b) % PV = -200,000 % PMT = 75,000, set END %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 18.45% n = 4 % % (c) Accept NPV > 0 IRR > cost of capital of 14% (d) 18.45%, the IRR. When used as the cost of capital, this rate produces a zero NPV, the indifference point. Also, if the firm's cost of capital were 18.45%, this project's IRR would exactly equal the cost of capital, another indication of indifference. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-10 (a) Present value of costs ($3,000,000) PV of benefits: % PMT = 275,000, set END % n = 16 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 2,434,127 i = 8 % % NPV = - $565,873 (b) % PV = -3,000,000 % PMT = 275,000, set END %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 4.91% n = 16 % % (c) Reject NPV < 0 IRR < cost of capital (d) 4.91%, the IRR. When used as the cost of capital, the IRR produces a zero NPV, the indifference point. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-11 (a) Present value of costs ($200,000) PV of benefits: i = 10, then (1) n = 1, FV = 110,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 100,000 (2) n = 2, FV = 150,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 123,967 (3) n = 3, FV = 120,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 90,158 (4) n = 4, FV = 200,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 136,603 NPV = $250,728 or use cash-flow portion of your calculator: % FLOW 0 = -200,000 % FLOW 1 = 110,000 % FLOW 2 = 150,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" NPV = $250,727 FLOW 3 = 120,000 % FLOW 4 = 200,000 % i = 10 % % (b) Use the cash-flow portion of your calculator. Enter the cash flows as above, then solve for: IRR = 55.10% (c) Accept NPV > 0 IRR > cost of capital (d) $250,727, the NPV, assuming the financial markets agree with the firm's estimates of these future cash flows. This is the economic meaning of the NPV number. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-12 (a) Present value of costs ($1,600,000) PV of benefits: i = 13, then (1) n = 1, FV = 500,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 442,478 (2) n = 2, FV = 720,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 563,866 (3) n = 3, FV = 300,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 207,915 (4) n = 4, FV = 600,000symbol 93 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 367,991 NPV = ($ 17,750) or use the cash-flow portion of your calculator: % FLOW 0 = -1,600,000 % FLOW 1 = 500,000 % FLOW 2 = 720,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" NPV = ($17,750) FLOW 3 = 300,000 % FLOW 4 = 600,000 % i = 13 % % (b) Use the cash-flow portion of your calculator. Enter the cash flows as above, then solve for: IRR = 12.46% (c) Reject NPV < 0 IRR < cost of capital (d) -$17,750 (i.e., a loss in value of this amount), the NPV, assuming the financial markets agree with the firm's estimates of these future cash flows. This is the economic meaning of the NPV number. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-13 (a) Produce a cash-flow table Year 0 Years 1-10 Year 10 Purchase machine A (120,000) Tax-dep'nsymbol 129 \f "Wingdings" 3,500 Salvage 20,000 Cost reduction 40,000 Tax (35%) (14,000) Working capital (30,000) 30,000 (150,000) 29,500 50,000 symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Annual depreciation = $120,000 - 20,000 = 10,000 10 Tax saving = 35%(10,000) = 3,500 (b) Present value of costs ($150,000) PV of benefits: % PMT = 29,500, set END % FV = 50,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 182,780 n = 10 % i = 12 % % NPV = $32,780 (c) % PV = -150,000 % PMT = 29,500, set END % FV = 50,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 16.64% n = 10 % % (d) Accept NPV > 0 There is added value. IRR > cost of capital Investors get their required rate of return and more. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-14 (a) Produce a cash-flow table Year 0 Years 1-7 Year 7 Purchase machine X (1,000,000) Tax-dep'nsymbol 129 \f "Wingdings" 43,750 Salvage 125,000 Increased receipts 400,000 Tax (35%) (140,000) Working capital (100,000) 100,000 (1,100,000) 303,750 225,000 symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Annual depreciation = $1,000,000 - 125,000 = 125,000 7 Tax saving = 35%(125,000) = 43,750 (b) Present value of costs ($1,100,000) PV of benefits: % PMT = 303,750, set END % FV = 225,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 1,539,703 n = 7 % i = 11 % % NPV = 439,703 (c) % PV = -1,100,000 % PMT = 303,750, set END % FV = 225,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 21.79% n = 7 % % (d) Yes NPV > 0 Value is added. IRR > cost of capital Investors get their required rate of return and more. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-15 (a) Produce a cash-flow table including incremental cash flows: Year 0 symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Years 1-5 Year 5 Sell machine A 40,000 Tax-losssymbol 130 \f "Wingdings" 10,500 Tax-lost dep'n (3,500) Lost salvage (20,000) Buy machine B (80,000) Tax-dep'nsymbol 131 \f "Wingdings" 4,200 Salvage 20,000 Additional savings 20,000 Tax (35%) ( 7,000) Working capitalsymbol 132 \f "Wingdings" (29,500) 13,700 0 symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Year 0 here is equivalent to year 5 in problem 13, since 5 years have past symbol 130 \f "Wingdings" Book value of A after 5 years: 120,000 - 5(10,000) = 70,000 Loss on sale = 70,000 - 40,000 = 30,000 Tax benefit on loss = 35%(30,000) = 10,500 symbol 131 \f "Wingdings" Annual depreciation = $80,000 - 20,000 = 12,000 5 Tax saving = 35%(12,000) = 4,200 symbol 132 \f "Wingdings" Machine B can use the $30,000 of working capital now used by machine A. There is no need to acquire more, nor is there an opportunity to retrieve some cash here by reducing working capital. In sum, no change. (b) Present value of costs ($29,500) PV of benefits: % PMT = 13,700, set END % n = 5 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 49,385 i = 12 % % NPV = $19,885 (c) % PV = -29,500 % PMT = 13,700, set END %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 36.72% n = 5 % % (d) Yes Incrementally, NPV > 0 and IRR > cost of capital. The conversion to machine B adds still more value to the company. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-16 (a) Produce a cash-flow table including incremental cash flows: Year 0 symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Years 1-3 Year 3 Sell machine X 100,000 Tax-losssymbol 130 \f "Wingdings" 140,000 Tax-lost dep'n (43,750) Lost salvage (125,000) Buy machine Y (750,000) Tax-dep'nsymbol 131 \f "Wingdings" 70,000 Salvage 150,000 Additional Receipts 300,000 Tax (35%) (105,000) Additional working capitalsymbol 132 \f "Wingdings" (60,000) 60,000 (570,000) 221,250 85,000 symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Year 0 here is equivalent to year 4 in problem 14, since 4 years have past symbol 130 \f "Wingdings" Book value of X after 4 years: 1,000,000 - 4(125,000) = 500,000 Loss on sale = 500,000 - 100,000 = 400,000 Tax benefit on loss = 35%(400,000) = 140,000 symbol 131 \f "Wingdings" Annual depreciation = $750,000 - 150,000 = 200,000 3 Tax saving = 35%(200,000) = 70,000 symbol 132 \f "Wingdings" Since machine Y needs $160,000 of working capital and since the sale of machine X would free up $100,000 of investment in working capital, the incremental investment is $60,000. (b) Present value of costs ($570,000) PV of benefits: % PMT = 221,250, set END % FV = 85,000 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = 602,823 n = 3 % i = 11 % % NPV = $32,823 (c) % PV = -570,000 % PMT = 221,250, set END %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 14.10% FV = 85,000 % n = 3 % % (d) Yes Incrementally, NPV > 0 and IRR > cost of capital. The conversion to machine Y adds more value to the company. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-17 (a) The equation of the SML is: Required rate of return = risk free rate + (market price of risk)symbol 98 \f "Symbol" r = .04 + .085symbol 98 \f "Symbol" (b) Put each value of symbol 98 \f "Symbol" into the SML: Proposal symbol 98 \f "Symbol" Required rate of return A .85 r = .04 + .085(.85) = 11.23% B 1.00 r = .04 + .085(1.00) = 12.50% C 1.10 r = .04 + .085(1.10) = 13.35% D 1.25 r = .04 + .085(1.25) = 14.63% (c) Compare each project's IRR to the company's existing 13% cost of capital. By this test the company should accept C and D since the IRRs of those projects exceeds 13%. (d) Now compare each project's IRR to its own risk-adjusted cost of capital: A: 12% IRR > 11.23% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"accept B: 10% IRR < 12.50% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"reject C: 16% IRR > 13.35% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"accept D: 14% IRR < 14.63% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"reject Adjusting for risk changes (improves) the analysis. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11-18 (a) The equation of the SML is: Required rate of return = risk free rate + (market price of risk)symbol 98 \f "Symbol" r = .05 + .08symbol 98 \f "Symbol" (b) Put each value of symbol 98 \f "Symbol" into the SML: Proposal symbol 98 \f "Symbol" Required rate of return W 1.40 r = .05 + .08(1.40) = 16.20% X 1.15 r = .05 + .08(1.15) = 14.20% Y .90 r = .05 + .08(.90) = 12.20% Z .65 r = .05 + .08(.65) = 10.20% (c) Compare each project's IRR to the company's existing 14% cost of capital. By this test the company should accept W and X since the IRRs of those projects exceeds 14%. (d) Now compare each project's IRR to its own risk-adjusted cost of capital: W: 15% IRR < 16.20% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"reject X: 19% IRR > 14.20% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"accept Y: 11% IRR < 12.20% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"reject Z: 12% IRR > 10.20% required return symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol"accept Adjusting for risk changes (improves) the analysis. APPENDIX 11B Mathematical Limitations of the IRR Technique PROBLEMS SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11B-1 (a) Produce a cash-flow table: Year 0 Years 1-4 Sell machine 5,000 Tax-gainsymbol 129 \f "Wingdings" (1,750) Lost savings (3,000) Tax (35%) 1,050 3,250 (1,950) symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Gain on sale = sale price - book value = 5,000 - 0 = 5,000 Tax on gain = 35% 5,000 = 1,750 PV of year 0 benefit $3,250.00 PV of year 1-4 costs: % PMT = -1,950, set END % n = 4 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = (6,181.24) i = 10 % % NPV = ($2,931.24) (b) % PV = 3,250 % PMT = -1,950, set END %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 47.23% n = 4 % % (c) No, the company should not sell the machine. To do so would be to lose value of $2,931.24. (d) Since this is an opposite project (+, -), an IRR greater than the cost of capital is the reject signal, agreeing with the negative NPV. The $3,250 opportunity of selling the machine can earn at a 47.23% rate if we leave the investment untouched. Also, to go ahead and sell the machine would be the equivalent of raising $3,250 of funds at a 47.23% rate of interest. Do not pay this rate, hence do not sell the machine. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11B-2 (a) Produce a cash-flow table: Year 0 Years 1-2 Sell machine 20,000 Tax-gainsymbol 129 \f "Wingdings" (7,000) Lost savings (11,000) Tax (35%) 3,850 13,000 ( 7,150) symbol 129 \f "Wingdings" Gain on sale = sale price - book value = 20,000 - 0 = 20,000 Tax on gain = 35% 20,000 = 7,000 PV of year 0 benefit $13,000.00 PV of year 1-2 costs: % PMT = -7,150, set END % n = 2 %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" PV = (11,926.93) i = 13 % % NPV = $1,073.07 (b) % PV = 13,000 % PMT = -7,150, set END %symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 190 \f "Symbol"symbol 174 \f "Symbol" i = IRR = 6.60% n = 2 % % (c) Yes, the company should sell the machine. This would add $1,073.07 of value to the firm. (d) Since this is an opposite project (+, -), an IRR less than the cost of capital is the accept signal, agreeing with the positive NPV. The $13,000 from selling the machine can be better used elsewhere; it is currently earning only 6.60%, far less than the 13.00% WACOC. Also, to sell the machine would be the equivalent of raising $13,000 of funds at a rate of 6.60%, very attractive when capital is averaging a 13% cost. SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11B-3 (a) The NPVs, found by taking the PV of each cash flow individually and then summing, or by using the cash-flow-list feature of a calculator, are: discount rate NPV 5% -426.30 9.79% 0 50% 1,111.11 127.71% 0 200% -1,222.22 (b)  (c) This project has two IRR's: 9.79% and 127.71%. (d) Yes, NPV is positive here (see graph). Note that with multiple IRRs here, the IRR has lost its economic meaning! SOLUTION - PROBLEM 11B-4 (a) The NPVs, found by taking the PV of each cash flow individually and then summing, or by using the cash-flow-list feature of a calculator, are: discount rate NPV 5% -13,718.82 12.92% 0 100% 31,250.00 387.08% 0 500% -7,638.89 (b) (c) This project has two IRRs: 12.92% and 387.08%. (d) No, NPV is negative here (see graph). Note that with multiple IRRs here, the IRR has lost its economic meaning! 11symbol 45 \f "Symbol"page 2 Chapter 11 Capital Budgeting 11symbol 45 \f "Symbol"page 15 11symbol 45 \f "Symbol"page 1 11Bsymbol 45 \f "Symbol"page 4 Appendix 11B Mathematical Limitations of the IRR Technique 11Bsymbol 45 \f "Symbol"page 3 11Bsymbol 45 \f "Symbol"page 1  !"*,./t578u\ ^ _ suv cef!$%(\z>*CJ5CJOJQJ jU jCJU5CJCJ 56CJ5CJT   !+,45[ \ rs$0 0h$ 0 $ & F 0$ 0 $h 0   !+,45[ \ r ^.pr $BWabxy~ }!~!!!!" " $ $D$E$%%%%%%& &^&&&'d'z'|''',((4)))**** ,,z,|,~,,,P-R-7.8.n..$/%/x/ cbc ! ^.pr $   h 0 $h 0$ 0$h 0hzMVY` !"""""""$$$$%&&&&&(&\&N'b'h'x''*(((X)Z)b*d*|**+ ,~,,,,,,,,,,,,--<.=.\.].^.o.p.........)/*/ CJOJQJ5CJOJQJ5CJ jU jCJU>*CJCJ>*CJT$BWabxy~ }!~!!!" " $ h h  0 h h   h h h    $ $D$E$%%%%%& &^&&&'d'z'|''',((4))) h    h h h )**** ,,z,|,~,,,P-R-7.8.n..$/%/x///2040h h  h h   h  */I/J/K/y/z///////////00060H0J0`0b0d0p000111 1"1.1R1b111111122"202U2e2444444444445555555555 66&6.6A6I6\6d6w66666 CJOJQJ>*CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJ jU jCJUCJQx///204060f0h000101d111122P222344444~5555556/6J6e6666C7D7L78889 9F9H999:<:~:::6;t;v;;;;;;.<0<<<<<=(=l=n===6>8>f>>>>\??????,@2@X@@AAAAAA B&Cd4060f0h000101d111122P222444h p\ j hp\ j \ j p\ j  p@ h h h h 444~5555556/6J6e6666C7D788h p\ jh \ j \ j j p@ h h h h 66H788088889992949D9|9999D:b::: ;4;:;Z;;;;;;;;;<,<d<v<x<<0=P======>h>j>>>>>>? ?6?8????????T@V@@@@@@@@ž jCJU CJOJQJOJQJ CJOJQJ>*CJOJQJ>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJ>*CJOJQJCJ>*CJK889 9F9H999:<:~:::6;t;v;;;;  @ j p@ j p p j& p\ j  h h  p\ j;;;.<0<<<<<=(=l=n===6>8>f>>  @ j p@ j p p j& p\ j  h h >>>\??????,@2@X@@AA|d( h8\ d( h8\  d( h\  d( h\  hp~ d p~ x \ j $ 2    @@@ A AAAA@ABAnApArA~AAAAAAAAAAAABB8B:B*CJ CJOJQJ>*CJCJ jCJU jUQAAAAA B&CDCLCNCtCCCEq$h hN  hN  hN d( hN d( h8N d( h8N dd( h8N  d( hN  hN d( h\  &CDCLCNCtCCCEEEEEEEEEHFNFtFFGGGHH4HPIpIxIzIIIIJJJJJ0K2KTKrKCLLXMMMMDNJNtNN|OOOOOOXPgPzPPP6Q7Q8QAQ R"RtRvRRRSoTTUUUUUV2VbVHWxWWWWWXXXXXYZZZZZdEEEEEEEEEHFNFtFFGGGH hN d( hrd( h8drd( h8 d( h d( h hp~ d p~ xGGGGGGGGGGG H HHH0H2HdHfHhHHHHHHHHHHHHH*I,I.I8INIlInItIvIIIIIJJJJJJKKKKKKLLLLLLLL3L4L5L\L]LrLsLtLuLLLLLLj5CJU5CJOJQJ5CJ CJOJQJ>*CJ CJOJQJ>*CJCJ jU jCJUNHH4HPIpIxIzIIIIJJJJJ p~ xh hN  hN  hN d( h d( h8 d( h8 dd( h8  d( h J0K2KTKrKCLLXMMMMDNJNtNN|Od(   d(   x d(  x  :  hx hp~ d hp~ d hLLLLLLLLLLLLLMMMM.M/M0M1MGMHMIMqMrMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMFNHN^N`NpNrNNNNNNNNNN&O(O*O,OXOZO\O^OzOOOOOOOOOZPfPkPqP8Q CJOJQJ CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ5CJj5CJUCJ jU jCJUQ|OOOOOOXPgPzPPP6Q7Q8Q R"RtR h, p~ x hN h FT  h     d(  d( 8FT d(   x8QRRRRRRRSSSSFSHSJSLSxSzS|S~SSSSSSTTTT-T.T/T0TFTGTHTIT_T`TaTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTUU(U)U*U+UAUBUCUDUZU[U\U]UsUtUuU{UUUUVVV CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ jCJU jUj5CJUCJ5CJOJQJ5CJPtRvRRRSoTTUUUUV2VbVHWxWWd( #  Hd(   x d(  x  x  hx hp~ d hp~ dVV.V0V^V`VVVVVVVVVVVV"W$W&W(WFWtWvWWWWWWWXXXXY YZZZZZZ[$[&[4[6[:[<[N[[[[[[\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\"]$]&]T]f]>*EH jEHU>*CJOJQJ>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJ>*CJ jU jCJU CJOJQJCJ CJOJQJJWWWWXXXXXYZZZZZZZZZ h  h h  hN   h FT  h   d(  d( 8FT ZZZZZ[[P[[[ \>\h\\\\]]]](^N^^______ `0`d`naaaaaabbbbbbbbbbbbb ccHccc dDdpddeeeeeeLfrffgggh4h6hDhlhhiiiiijjjjjjjjjjjjjzk|kkl>lVleZ[[P[[[ \>\h\\\\]{    H& h  h  pB hpB  B  h  B 2 @ B h  f]h]v]]J^L^~^^^^^^^^^____4_6_8_:_f_h_j___________` ```,`.```b````````````aaaaFaHaJaTalaaaaaaabbbbbbc c"c5CJOJQJ5CJ CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ jU jCJU CJOJQJCJ>* >*OJQJN]]]](^N^^_____ttd( hd( h8d( h8drd( h8 d( h hp~ d p& p j& & __ `0`d`naaaaaayj @ &  hp& hd( h8drd( # hd( h8d( h hd  hx abbbbbbbbbbbbb ccHccc d B B  h  B 2 @ B h   p@ &"c0c2c4c6cFccccccdddddddddddeeee:eeleeeeenfpffffffffff*g,g.g0g\g^g`gbgggggggggghh h2h@hBhRhThhhjhhhhhh CJOJQJ jCJU CJOJQJ >*OJQJ>*>*CJ jUEH jEHUCJ>*CJOJQJ>*CJL dDdpddeeeeeeLfrfzn d( h hp~ r p& p ,& &  N 4 h  h B h B pB hp:B rffgggh4h6hDhlhhiiid( # hd( h hd  hx hN  rd( hd( h8H^d( h8drd( h8 hhhhh"i$i&i(iTiViXiZiiiiiiiiiiiijjjjjjJk`k~kkkkkkkkkkkkll4l5l6llllllmmmmmm"m#m$m%m(m+m3m4m:m*CJOJQJEH jEHU>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJ CJOJQJ>*CJ jU jCJUCJMiiiijjjjjjjjjjjjjzk|k h   p@ & @ &  hp&  hx h|kkl>lVlmllllll)mCmuh h2 P h2 \ dP pB hB P B h2 B    B  h  B 2 @ B Vlmllllll)mCmDmmmmm.nnnnoooopp qqr8r8s^sfsssssttuuuuv2v4vvv.w`wwwx,x]xoxxxxyyyyyy2zzzz{{{{|||}~:~>^&FNP>@Btvtʃ̃#dCmDmmmm.nnnnoooop  p@ & 8 \ &  \ & # 8p \ V # 8p \ & # 8p@ & 8p@ & h  mmmmmnnbndnnn$o&o(oVofohovooopppprr4r6rTrVrXrrrrrrrrrrrrrsssVsXsZs\sbsdslsssssssssssttt tLtNtPtRt~ttttttt CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ jCJU CJOJQJCJ >*OJQJ>*OJQJ jUEH jEHUMopp qr8r8s^sfssswkY  hx hN d( hd( h8dPd( h8drd( h8 d( h hp~   p@ &8 8p@ & sssttuuuuv2v4vrrpg h   p@ &8 # h8p@ &  hx hd( h8drd( # hd( h hd ttttttt uuuuuuvvv*v,v0vvvvvvwwwwwwww,wrwtwwww6x7xPxQxRxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx y yyyyy1y2y3yyyyyyzzhzjzz{2{4{OJQJ>*CJOJQJ jUEH jEHU>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJ CJOJQJ>*CJCJN4vvv.w`wwwx,x]xoxxxy pHB hHB  HB h  HB  H  N  HB  hN  H B   HB h  xxyyyyy2zzzz{{r  \ & & 8p \  r4 # 8p \ & # 8p@ & 8p@ & h  hN  Hl hN H&l 4{6{d{v{x{{||||||||~~6~8~X~Z~\~~~~~~~~~~~~~ "Z\|~HJLNz|~ހ"$BDJLX^ CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ jCJU CJOJQJCJEH jEHU >*OJQJ>* jUO{{{|||~:~>^vgd( hd( h8dd( h8drd( h8 d( h hp~ 8 8p@ &  p@ & 8 \ & &FNP>xx8 # h8p@ & hd( h8drd( # hd( h hd  hx hN r ^BTVlnrBDnprxăƃȃ$,-/0EFGIJaۄ |-.DEFG]^_eĆ#JKabcj>*CJU>*CJj>*CJU jU jCJU5CJOJQJ5CJ>*CJCJP>@Btvtʃ̃#b h hp@ & 8p & p & # h8p@ &  p@ &#b fņ$Ç "b tvxz9b܋;X @JpxВ & "`>nX"VbȜ&.0!"#$%&'(dfņ$ "b tvxz9b 8p & p & # h8p@ &  p@ &h # h8p@ &cdz{|$BDnpr҉ԉ։ !8[aڊQ_234:abxyz{׌،ٌڌ j>*CJU>*CJj>*CJU5CJOJQJ5CJ>*CJ jUCJ jCJUPb܋;Xˍ͍̍΍׍ 0h # h8p@ &h hp@ & 8p & 6789OPQWʍ̍΍ύ֍؍bnp~ŽĎRTVdjtv*, <>\^`¿¿ CJOJQJ CJOJQJOJQJEH jEHU>*CJOJQJ>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJ5 56CJ5CJ>*CJ jU jCJUCJD׍؍ "` :fFqq  h~ Blz< h~ Blz< # h$ Blz<  h$ Blz< h~ Blz< $ Blz< h@ Blz<h b$ & ڐ @Jpxsl   hx hN d( hd( h8dd( h8drd( h8 d( h hr  h~ Blz< ‘đ"$&hjlntv~̒Β0246bdfhƓȓʓ֓ (,68bnp~ĘƘVXZlr~𿼿EH jEHU>*CJOJQJ5CJOJQJ5CJ CJOJQJ>*CJ>*CJ CJOJQJCJ jCJU jUJВ  }geeh  h~ Blz<$h  h~ Blz<  h~ Blz< hN d( hd( # h8Vr4d( h84d( h "`>nXvvv  h~ Blz< h~ Blz< h$ Blz< # h$ :Blz<  h$ Blz< h$ Blz< $ Blz< h@ Blz< ~̙ΙЙ :<  24RTrtvԛ֛؛ڛ 8:<ĜƜHJLNz|~ޝ"$*,8>B>*CJ jCJU CJOJQJ CJOJQJOJQJ jUEH jEHU>*CJCJP"VbȜ~nd( h   hx hN rd( hd( h8dd( h8drd( h8 d( h hr &.0!"#$%&'wwwwwwh  h~ Blz<$h  h~ Blz<  h~ Blz< hN d( hd( # h8Vr4d( h84 BD,bz|"$@Bnޤȥʥ̥(*<LN$?ACRȨɨʨ˨ШѨҨӨި 1234 5CJmH jUj5CJU5CJ>*CJjCJUmH>*CJ5CJOJQJ5CJCJ CJOJQJL'()*+, "HJ`֣w p2 Blz< 2 Blz<d(  b Blz<d(  ~ Blz<  ~ Blz<h ~ Blz<h  h~ Blz< ()*+,5 "HJ`֣68@BDΥХ>b:;ѨҨߨ:;=>`apq©ĩũE֣68@DΥХ  ~ Blz<h ~ Blz<h  h~ Blz<  h~ Blz< p2 Blz< 2 Blz<>b:;  h~ Blz< b2 Blz< 2 Blz< Blz< *2 Blz<d(  b@ Blz<d(  ~ Blz< ;ߨ=>pqĩũ !$h  h~ Blz<49:;<>ABWXYZ_`aboq©éũɩʩߩ jU 5CJmHj5CJU5CJ'1 000P/ =!"#p$%1 000P/ =!"#p$%n(1O&RU*PNG  IHDR8Z/y&gAMAPLTEٟ IDATxώ۸vh~dyouM(Djpk^aޠUSZyEV,ZA'^R]VEwl"yx!E&trs "4< Ei(2OCyPd"4< +J˄49wK_b5MyQ\"0tŘܦ]l̄1/hL9g&K_c?!K_E\%/5suD%aw$o'y\K_bUesaSb;Xc+\.IlEgw #_.IU sEBȿ$mʙ&tKL;fYb^DؤoXŘ9:ɘ?Ǘ0oCLo]2%bf=1ӷ$hqH\o&AD2f˜ Yuc]ADy ["Z 2sd)}),PHwИ#\"\"\"\"\d|Fd+2Vd+2Vd+2Vdkk1*25I)ȌZYȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[YȌ[Y 2O#3nEf"3nEf"3jEf؟#3nEf"3jEf"3jEf"3jEfEf܊rEf܊rMy>ض#3nEf"3jEf"3jEf"3jEf&q Mm:z6vmـ6 .ϴNm527wAǜoZ9msL1 7g-֦A\hjz܆468|2ߙ37se UKΜ۠bt1g1~ݰ҇*3 6fʙu[\w* 3˜uk*l iH2Kfz"d vc]N+a1Wݰc~bޙ0sc8tbpCƙoeNy 1vwK]0Wyә]X3ye|+7{虛yQfBÜn:/{Jv-I\c9|L6{"+17Xioy\F\$[?{_=3/P|[ 3B 4V%ar(=??̽2gO{'Z m7|ޕk-82VmsfJ(f5ECѶL\'Zc!`[0(!`[0(!`N6fh Lw~'.NLCxi_8KgnNf.|Te3>,؅3W~g[7ًlfȹ%3{E3{.^loi.d.[Ӿ`fse58 fb=\)[󍁙YeKJݓa=Z097ӂ] т).feRu13]6wc[;I6KOY%h=`R!ڷd]uk f2wr55}mVEJeZ(3J|̰VSZ{/#_=h2>kμkMfH z)sق0s|MJk\$J$\5\rf0S[nv`[Z{/g`jσ3=n^N 5r`^WO4!TE/i=mٜd.X!'d&t=Ĺ֧bKnT|_%rϓȘ`Jχe»cq|-{'rejQʙ|ψJ+Xot~s;s_/%­G{{927CӸnkd?3W/*rhϹ6uhs/GJ.i;6Ǎѡ5mG1 4Tvd.]:coAiQXQ)+[_ 9g[Q)[Kv-х RufpcH0~'6Z!58S,ʦ„T\깑Ks$L˥?K?kPwbKi1ͭX祴A hYn]̉Yj¨9C:Zau Xo|1rA3*r\.&=^tan X^\?i0;Om?bPJFM|M!Z/e\:^Iri\&d9d>}k{YN15ss 47j?a/ֆ{0,OTk =8SSf{ 2:}UčyuЅOx[*[03Üiuz-vȹAVZu fʜ_jmS,!3?qh}34#^&=qDFn]3\c!:t,~&Wǔ;aWQ>zK^mREge4uo)llW4 Ԍy2bygjWO>zt YN.;[/%m{kJٚqhgkf9}Kb}ȹZ)=X\3 || 셬M**=GZ{/9:q/WȊY;l~'se1?|,Αˊh>0t?Ls/+fHr-\-wv_oӟ=>{NVl^ad kltx/.eXTҡF6FV>el<]=λ*/!,cWYżYсY/9}2,ós߸sSe^d,Hz0n z Z̝͘tŶY-'B0Ti1Yy.$i+_.L̯wNY;F_YWsR-?I%f rv9 Vd7[RgeIw؁*\kVd5-s/Z+ 3N1#Td. q½.7uwv>׸/an}&wNrh2(Lhd Mܭh\_:ڟ/k,C.u:y0uҫ81C~hvf֌<ɐ:S"tngmgb֋<ɐw̬gx!s4t̘C-󜮘s~T,Cͬ~Cpьy;boCJov&~NGݸ>iL6ͫM$pj/]V=I*_f0us=cO]=;3'QUP̟7`̃{2߳N⇩Ŕ|NWΓWmIb%u?9u=Yng0]'Y\IKO)cv;f~ :_$][r[咛n%.Ɇϕs3d%|Ot?ʫO~Ww3)xnԖ9?l"[bHaۛ;tChuݨ#i)-t}O(žY# R%\rt>'ǷgW,s_lp2mMj*r:72-z?P1|ߥK~zo/g'!EsƯ0iN,+k#eu?h02h Tuv&q: .iǺ3GOQitBۗL?( -J7.5ݑZ3t`T >kq[L,e0; F$0%7jq[@,C0=tsǏnU23pw? !ch7R|S-fʎ9;@I$ZB[ p'ی2=|pπ9\IIvJQ5IvW1Cn^f2gc,EoSU̗7%]M,=le?_\笽ibfTn#<21i$;[ogj2/s13סsA@Ŝ?wwIzsM|O62}{ tF}.m+_Q/~U"tzwM/U0í|"E||N?73I6tuLo놾O懥jJz `[pꌮvc.1[P}$%s!gZf]VH|}X fxr(1si3E~3c9EH6ۍ3c/P!vpI}=l7>حڰ?n }OgedkynM58q+a.3F>Hjy |ޤ0;ZM`|p;qr?fkDpZ*,n[3H33Bw`KZ  4B˙3FG} ,=(4X' aB,``̀wǭ̘%1%V.ݬb? 0U"ʌYrR"uyV̢Z4O\pfd\KRFhe,!`$i,;3p{ 0 3`;@le̜~Q/ߣ!s!1ʘY@ʐ $w6d$F 2U}ݐ~%nŠmq_q{~2DI;4f5 [3~Gh|,,qSޡ!RCni5~Gh\xqhs6g5`u9YXX]'nf"9̓V"` 7_U zCY0>l2o`jP̭\[ZŊp,`fqhl  3[y +q3oaV#;F_h$b~7t |Jtŋs$a5İ8ۜ8?iDcsy]hf +F8vFL{QUzK٭*tQnMV2NEc6n1IݔY1C+~4OXyMU~T4o1O07$szա%D8s˪ĭl:ץ 3[V3&UjܐoVT_neա-^ɖ8rfJWY2C-ssυ1򇮝d, z1Wٮ16VX26-f.!F/?y[faWc3g~`=Nڱl:-s2:.!F/?ږYZͺgj9mGs}%*n²Kb<{*T8ʚy޹G^kfy 7 w%̰fz%̬͂ׄҷsZҡ%–g=۫A#JEw`u3H36Ϙk%YvOkf'x3M ĞYPV}A}{% aϒ%xNr`>ުIk32[ VǥiUk֤tݦu90 Io8sß~ =x%̂,hC1{H~gp\b3ww0QW|Z-3oBJmBsSQg-ࡕ d Xy"0×F(bh.9̡OI[ogDY+hwh y7}L\0+2gbb4bAw! su?3ڶBUK(?D+p5+?:/1bk,}m6tGHiR$)k䛵|ґP~W)[)Wܜ{~Rƈ{%}ևb8GX-+t vZ]Hqf3,Lcd?2C:Bf._k0^ (alZIڡ8 $Wڜ$6dkaW"_ګ|}w.9n&1YW!$cfFzN2@$a.입E"PF 9I}5t\Ja%zlN*X#×R@W( 3KyHc93 ;vrG&?0\f/덏`aB+ͬ0΁h- X9Phf0:W +r@1_-32A +0 C0 3`:4 s/Т)@ ?s\ L( 19%YԡwͨIC =m ٘Y2J(fA@ y(fAO2 )(c#?-x @`]O+o4KPiΆfw"G[$m4޸"%hXW|b0z m|J朹mq<_"cr%ɼgY>͓E\%3\&tXQ sסƼX}>pTWţkpEƘ׌<0&#tU'e{~l1]R2pdcnUŮl8m1:2p|Yr5ZB#1wct|f, gpATv燵;槎 ǝ伬9}(c~U}۾cM=:׳seҷmv_֌$vvkΘҡoq!s$n|f/=vM$l(ʲoVwMr!wu=M,dN8m[gf3c%c%ώqJfm6dvq2uhNaRf:N@NyN`ev 32 2th.+2;h:4Zf0-he/f^ ^f{1u+Albf'ffٶCcflۡQ3[ P3[ff|5e5lnfnfIvyv^ rf+9բ)Vș:4vfESؙm 6K31m[[EFlᕠgM=WBg6O~g6#`63Flqsazcg=fSd ̦;ۏٰCp6c̆Fl̆yq0y%`6`6;@k,`nR0JFl{$F^XMŒ0t0 lҡGlf`)h a6 AW2f5a|<^ɈXY;9"fmdDڡՈ11 ĬŘuÌ111=*f0cT̚zT̚ӓb 3ưYzz\zaƸڶ丘^12RLjY+V12f mƬhj\>ؘuck:a5Œ1kc쏎Y#F1>Dc>lOc>=B=B擋F|C?|d@ܰO1sխ^nC|]vḐ s~<"SFL\Pn21:OƼS{m*z_|bє2fl eojD0o^ӧù^4%anebV{%z\ cVge jfW"ap3g3bՠ꼁`F[\JD\TJmyQ1dPuذ} }_1f3OMӓ2ȦFʬ|XNWMkJ ȘUak1_<֟EƬ 3ha^"m=;)2~iؘS\Kl d򼁜%:fW"gD,YޡG841ٌ3KXYjF,]c1ffWV`m7ffY1ffYdY才Y╌Q3KؘmCYZY+7CY알YܡG,#gJF,4b#gz%cgJ,ʕYԡL 3 ֕YYY03zfA1~cd+i_\=3M>2~6Ilpe4dpalzuiNMCqS`.'\%ɋךDN&$NMS2flZ _k~7|ZHAw ̴d?:'̷C{D4 EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EfԊ EffuR̨"ض#3jEf"3jEf"3jEf"3jEf"3jEf0B̨̨̨̨̨"VLym[+f>y|;31/o23Zz9',gܱw'a-bdİ@aX;{İ@˼f{p9oHl% xdS'mJ'R0sf*aMJf\$+Zv{]]wUu1$i5Y&93MnWe̫->8܂eaO?iʘiG|wqL /A227m\}l2" nsOwN>^gNe sg]=9w*#0Wzܩ33{f^6e.Ӟvu6c^4[ȼv-s|@dN̫cI\enٝv c޴DȢf>Vpl)"`xIL>%,"6v\K=+x /9s\عp '.3~9)ߎyx@OH`̭FQ2 |Y08Jo\j" j*Zٹ(\_Xl_t }qc.l_"LC Ya\S̪4V*}GOyb1m(fLfSŌ)c4T3?~)€bF5T1`qm}gSdFU1cJQRu 2gf\CLFU063U212 ̸*fdfYŒlC0#A U63ن`Fa@0#KQftC3َ*Is*zg]TP̶;39 .g%*I893cKQwP̌l;30ܙUaԙYʙ(Ȍ0pfh]1mWf|I̜d`% '7fC#3J\!0\QmGf޶+3ʡy fۍeض1ÑP\d% ''l;1#5N8# 7ffۍvbFjqFnH*vaFa81c\pP/ffہk2>5ۑY41D]qap90g% '{ff۞PelڨʡF.h*{$&è3ڨʞPe͌7°gFlFU~ިʞَ* fۖPekGU̘Ͷ5s^pdl-'-3jmɌl[2c0lQmKf0jɌqUvs*;f4fZ1c0Lxيٖ0ns6rmŌq/C0#7Vh̶D6X̶L6hnel1)J0Y0`ƝV؇*fC 3vml[0#O Qf 3ʂPe%1$93ʜPeΌ>°`ћmsf z2fFaX0̙U7_Ľ}&Ly)30~U@2e H03_% 'CfSϝL'è13d5fƟ#0`͘D?Ɉy3ʐyfیyˈaC2!L̙Ǣs2 m<ÌMFa#J7'rǺξ/;@+)sʙf:qժ%,~cjI.O)믌a_3㾚M+$ӂ;wtF2]f)2$/#3j9w"3jEf"3jEf"3jEfzOԊ My놎5E)ȌZ?+4EضQ+2+4Ŷ=E{Q+2+mjEf<~שƥpPNG  IHDR`qgAMAPLTEٟ IDATx͎8,)Å^xܕ_c ojNE!/A6pqF&0[/ e)\f:&%ŇD}`PQI/fԻv !G=9QGz>r󑣞|#G=9QGz>r󑣞YϺYOY<\;jY9jY9jY9jY9jY9jY9jY9jY9jY9jtI 0~( Qw=֦?gmm6D;k43>SsRЦ:Ft:vJks! Y.~)O/zlVlr}yfӛR+J꨸Ofd&?0#__`VgUS9{l j@!NPCZ`F=v{0W݆{~ev811%Gjb~(]RoPsmJl3|$.YqfдQs3K~53X?""֑zC*sz|M"MO9#tcwwGE. > -9{87֜fˬțEI6{WЗk9R 1d)U/pMƦ|x'i C>|ML5g(G ;TT:nƆ] _Q'! Hc4+CW;.HGry\SH9} Τz%C3ij 8|H2;鸌ΤWjΤpr3}RYjPFd13z-Yj^( =+4.Ij~H#.KKRpC.Ij$$5 HR?FvIR |M?$*z@O\:0&rݵ3E$$5⿃I$9 M9j@@#.GyY6<ۼcΰB&IQc1dt2K"QaDNB{gĥl`73ΈKQ]d^IZ:cQ95ΈP碎q kf`!\g 8#.SX8#.SBBq)P.c$H.u]zE:$-iL]#uIP f`\Ibkq`֬" 3fϵ a]lA&PG1ˈKj>1#pB=PH<%kVR%aTѨ[%aDŽ '<뤠ϝS"ԣG>J ϡZGgbG9B ]AUiݨ"QGnu'EL ?PR^0!h(&e h\w"B=I%u%zIKkF"UIB.5hEr|pQjB$֤V+# [JcIfjJ$֤U!Ot׭фP "ھ(uRRXzfV%@=GyO/"o_P5>֏ Xd~FsI ٛP2)R1}4!ŚԠ>OMvJX(5ωBڬxFܧ&0Ns#ޫD&Ě+:CA GyNu8>5IIȥAFflpo5@"b*>FqA͚M^ӛv]gD>uOIH> H4QO1W{JsBHPaEi@(}F@OGk^!NXX5Yz7`* V(cAy K;WJz;ctFZ@k\,7Zz¹fk8I⧌oͦ+awUQ.! pƚK\3|KӌhVk*V}jήK~j&-_O"~M1:|mW\r~Iw-5uVu4m.u 4-[槞0䰺u~>dR?^8Ф7J:j^?A;wWS\0dT(+^΍oϥtVjnA]kR\uWYi;찃7J{#l]PxA\tꍰ՞WRN*h6]C=uxM76v{u}I+ޅF< HsFXiw]ϛ[ˬBSZ@:Η+K[2H*JaLB݆&,zR=J&̍|(oɇO^Co^aZa>B\R*RwG}y#>MRwTŚwZquzb35:=;rPLQcג>>ji38ǚ9=2&PWu*.DmxY+c jAwqMvcIV#H3SڻM0jSf`wbpX]QTx=E߇UCݯJ.-< _QWO[D3:D/}G9's6a{q1ʐKuC#`Qzg~- ︫hSnaAʟS_׉p/s[^Sg6]Ic\AQک+7VY] ?w.QMcMKӧT}]îpPw}xZv؍{`o$+n6ZҚuPyv {x/d]@6AOaũoaHDΙA' jDm+:jy/C]$4撢zJE,FS7rs=NjRD1#?BaQU5LtYW: !YDMw~uz꟧cuWSkAe\{4ݍmt)L.M,t-wִR״ab͛^t⤦H}i{hP21ܤi>Zs7tM^5YF7j~'M6/uxӈt3p۾Gaⷤѩ}o[?;һ8oꙺrt0h I!wn7`S)ޠCgkKbW=Gǹzi 9A](*k|ߣuk'aUIσ=L]q9~.Pi"q<{綤5Ǩ:<v$^9CyRSoOI|Q΢i]{!lN`߇[t4ajT[W bڭjo)IkRk^uQ]_agwZ.b9CFXu}x>K% jmAݷl~1 ބv=lI]wlQWwnjLԭN)!No9/o&K5w!{57}=k?*O.MuLJ&N7pS7V$SWQ5m 5 jk{җzK5o%@]ˉc [Nu3 uۃ3/um5a [{'T;۷"nlIB:ӔȖ!C9Ð"}ݾsRCK=aا܋+|~Y=H}1uӆEd!i.j4_;l^JO:Y6DK 1G7>wzlfknj$$^E썤|oFwh4Pàle:g*_rSCY E[vOthqyKjGߢgJMAӜP*ɂm[Sn}Hׂ){'A}_?c\ċ`B-MMLuVeػ QwP;)cҩВP!z}!b"DfßçQ%w| ZJ:]5׻\2w=~&1{ɢ!s{R_oۋ`socJy.z30+P3g`k"j }YSPsj Wö\uZ,`bp^im7`t} 1H!{$"޷g oVf:(4ZRKDujj& }4 ^JN@RKDu@9#qtZKF3HI@5ԚNv>F?;DB,ԍYӱa0jFqv(&YU.Qj}LenYԅIm!6uTTKZ9+7P"ajm!v#5<4/YE3XgC:dޙ^53elqjm&TۉH{9?3z<P6?Ϝ="OsQ#c{Ey_Flq/ݛϟ3ğ&#)F;+6FKڳL :!Gil]etozI 9ZqS^2T3.W~t-4:SLj }.*JӜIWvJ7 ~=lP85jF2E$Ŧ't,4vGjoO"xlGׁ29O%}@ g/vO13A>ioʴ =O1,!q`оШz8R/Zu@lY&Pׄ뤋Z9XCe]>N++GW-\O*I:&2LMBB?j c+*GJπkꥴZ3>d(sRZO՘;+G;/YH>r ZRVv*dKj5u :5XBFc^ }RWvj'_"Rl.yiqcDD8 +'h_ţqS>RlPdNf;f D>@z.->.I}D[tQcFCC쳒4nSxG9Ygp–Naw'i+3U^OzѦI}xMMڅgT!vCe݉R !vSw\띔ӡ.$;N欒-A}1sBU0Z(vȍ?4p^I9:q8?1z!vSh3Am9?@; sVi%bP_1nQ*`P_-c.tj[P_7nQkP_9n{x)^/cإٽ6gubwV׊{C6Ŭw9YMGWmy\n|fa럔çU;¤NkNGm9;*H/5gQGlL&|6jrnyGӖ;VdwVgiGRj+uqRgǼvyc.F*K# [W6I]r7{$u1XJL%m jt1H:q]$ԡF 9F=@}]&O{AEy8+r$Ig>B㨛RC1ʗ$n!?PY.5t: E#Q}U(CkئyךPs4 uRDB qW_"@ʢ'/4HP#%5WԴAA xE Ps5 _qt=UEcjËj!x)JRSQGlpD4Ζq@)Oݻ~jYNSr4A#044uBC97s0>s:u-EEz4Is dIk|_sbwO;i1*~"϶O⹾*Runi"~UE~Լ-a75(ÙX3a_cȣ [W4ԉ煈J(> Mc(5fYtCq&$DPQ) u͟qNMr/~ _vD:3} *Nϻ5Rt`4NgmB-z"TŖ2kLMݐv8?=+E}:SohG7,*?f<?jȾ=͌/u~WPO5_`'K|U]PG8R+PܿEjLkt,Υ.k?age޽(r纛$D)Cw=?wgރ/RK4OR{~H"zc␡Qu:La9G;oݛ\! v+d[3y:  ڧo'jWĔڰ󇩡<5◕M;5`)a SxCIש 4S7+ÏR_ 4|CA} ul?uMį#ԦX'Gc$Y\L&GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQۤS:-vYkqN#]SNgO{tb]`'s Tg^Y,b:Etf݇բ?atۨµ0>>l)5Gbt/Ƅ .uWoX _*j u͑s /N+5:[5,ES.KQ=m S]G>Tl),=e͈܌.{VԏY<f?[Q.O]~'\Xu^*,NYOVL]u~im~9nYuܹjF]3nv6GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$6yRǺYIΚ'<[I<<i&9jV&9jV.-&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV3:Qy|䨭nhg(ƒY9jY9jY9jY9jY9jO*ffmfmZ^U r-*f9kQ$GQ$GbhnyUW14Q[^U r-*f9WuCu˫YU],GbhnyUW14Q[^U r-*f9WuCu˫Yۣ&fmfmfkY9jY9j4wjM=A@Nh/!F5crKfGJ>5w;Qж6=`K9Pg^wmѡ6g xyAɅ/Zteݠ{J\Nk7}8.~T܉tյ-kzN{6H-!l_^ !:u>P*.nԹۨFMDw~,~|M-I "BGA/%K5^=/ʧK~xr)Ij>,tVsIGKw)61~iؘ G7CvS3IQ5/>Q7QS۸$*E9yaInzP@HSߴ;.O} 9OťMS&JdRԗy:5ҘM!秏_TG \s]6T~:;^3.c/D q4`J5rbA?|#3h 5:%x/xI3?#ʧFcWh]{ѫ>uŻ/Dde^cIL_{ɃE;&7 V"p~ sz{/NBBM-~S ϔzv{>Z)5PM~v4T3j6 KYLq}/%uZQG:YPNԻ}y<^SPKkVP_>>o)Mgj`9sI9{ئ&OКzߕYAgBj⠄YPlIb7E̵ <4%4=?-0x4͞WQORx _8ej@Bsϳ>3<~9]qRFEU.eF(QU/GjGQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$GQ$ Bje6R?QIj9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV?.N9jVoVQr6Qr6Qr6Q'u\V5+Gm5+Gm5+Gm5+Gm5+Gmi5+#W׬MrԬi̓z-|l&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&8Y׎&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9jV&9WuC:BԶQGz>r󑣞|#G=9QGz>r󑣞|#G=9QGz>r󑣞|#G=9QGz>r󑣞|#G=9QG>hn3IENDB` [4@4NormalCJOJQJkHmH <A@<Default Paragraph Font, ,Footer  !,@,Header  ![8kX3X0hhh<<?z*/6@GL8QVf]"chmt4{^c ~B4bfjnrvy{}$ $)4048;>AEHJ|OtRWZ]_a drfi|kCmos4vx{>b׍ '֣;ceghilmopqsuwxz|~x/&CZVl#(dkt   qMmnG#g#h#z######4$T$U$$$$$$$$%%----------..x............0000000 1 1 1"1#1111111111111-3C3D3E3\3]3^3u3v3w333333333334444A4W4X4Y4p4q4r4444444444444555-5.55555555668&8'8(8?8@8A8X8Y8Z8q8r8888888888888$9:9;9<9S9T9U9l9m9n9999999999999:::::::::::9=S=T====>>>>>>>??????????????? @ @7AQARAABBBBBBBBCCCC0C1CCCCCCCCDDD,D-D2ELEMEEEEEFFkFFFFFFG2G3GGGGSHmHnHIIIIIIIIIIJJpJJJJJJJJJJJJKKK3LMLNLLLL8MRMSMMMMMNNNNNDO^O_OxPPPPPPPPPPPPXQoQpQqQQQQQQQQQRSSS-S.SGS]S^SzSSSxUUUUUUUUUUVV6VMVNVOVfVgVVVVVVVWWWWWWWWWX*X+XZ'Z(Z)Z@ZAZoZZZZZZZZZZZZ-[D[E[F[][^[P\j\k\\\\]]]]]]]]]]^^p^^^^^^^^^^^^waaaaaabbbbbccccc1c2cccccccccccdd8k99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 "DZ[\bek  /0179?9!9!9!9!9!9!/Xb$O&RU*01fXb$&>~שƥp4@~(  n  C >A&A:\Graph 11B-3.tifn  C >A&A:\Graph 11B-4.tifB S  ?jgPi8k$@4~$4O [ " z#*.+...<1=11133D6E677>;?;4=9=E?F?@@2A7A]C^C/D0DEEEEJJJJcLhLLLQQQQTTxY|Y^^^^NcOcddcfgfgggg:h>hjiniiii6k9kOXcs B(12FOP[de}$'4EUluv#-$.$\%e%%%%%%%-&/&'''(("(5(=(P(X(k(s(((((--*.+...9/I///00<1=1 2 2H2W2333333-4.444P5R5D6E6$7)77777889999':4:7:9:::::;";/;:;>;?;F<K<4?5?E?F?(@)@J@O@AA8CDCMCNC]C^CuCCHDID/E2ERFZFFFCGDGlGuGGGGG8H=H3I7IIIJJJJKKLLbMlMyMMRN\NmNwNNN'O,OPPQQQQRRSSxSzSSSST#T,TMTVTZWbWWWXXfXoXXXXXXX\\"]']]]^^^^``aaaa bbQbVbbbNcOc d!dddfffggg0g4gi?i@iAiBiCiDiE_G_HzIzJzKzLDNDOKPKQKRKSWX[\]^_abcdeJfJgJhJi8k@@@@<@@"@H@@&@(@*@,@\@@0@d@@4@l@@8@:@<@>@@@B@D@F@H@J@@@N@@@R@@@V@X@Z@\@^@`@b@d@f@h@j@@@n@@@r@t@v@@@z@@@~@@@@@@@@@@@@,@@@@@@@@@@@@P@GTimes New Roman5Symbol3& Arial?5 Courier New3Times@#C V j4JI%u(E(EYV   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry=CP =6 F`Կ{P/@1Table8.H<@om8.H<@@@+HWordDocumentEtH@?E H00]SummaryInformationy(xx Oh+'0 , H T ` lx Chapter 11Werner/Stoner Solutions Manuali Frank Werner SoranYarnellFrank M. Werner37nMicrosoft Word 8.0i@>X@vː+@d@G/(EDocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjj՜.+,D՜.+,8 hp|  aR  Chapter 11 Titlex(RZ _PID_GUID _PID_HLINKSAN{8EC10691-8D4D-11D4-A755-C666970F835D}A D&A:\Graph 11B-3.tifD!A:\Graph 11B-4.tif  FMicrosoft Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q0dRR C:\WINWORD\YARNELL.DOT Chapter 11Werner/Stoner Solutions Manual Frank WernerFrank M. Werner