ࡱ> KMJ sbjbj uEaa# O dddxxxx x'   '''''''$y)+,8'd @   8'1M' 8d' '%hL&0L0&&c'0'N&|,5, &,d&4   8'8'   '    ,          :  Directions: Using the Landmark Case on Weebly answer the questions below. Essential Question: Does the police practice of interrogating individuals without notifying them of their right to counsel and their protection against self-incrimination violate the Fifth Amendment? Part 1: Background of the Case (Level 3) What rights of the accused does the Fifth Amendment protect? The Sixth Amendment? How might knowledge of these rights have changed what Ernesto Miranda did when the police questioned him? Some would argue that it is the individual's responsibility to know what his or her rights are under the Constitution, and the government can assume that accused persons know their rights without informing them. Do you think the government should have to inform each individual who is arrested of his or her rights? Why or why not? Part 2: Key Excerpts from the Majority Opinion According to Chief Justice Warren, what fundamental questions does this case raise about the American justice system? What does he mean by "custodial interrogation"? Why does he say that we should not rely on asking individuals whether they are aware of their rights without a warning being given? What does Chief Justice Warren say the police have to do to ensure due process? Do you agree that when a person is taken into custody and subjected to questioning, the privilege against self-incrimination is jeopardized unless explicit warnings are given about rights? Why or why not? Should there be any exceptions to this rule? Explain. Part 3: Key Excerpts from the Dissenting Opinion Why does Justice Harlan say the Miranda warnings are not designed to guard against "police brutality or other unmistakably banned forms of coercion"? According to Justice Harlan, how will the Court's new rules impair "an instrument of law enforcement that has long and quite reasonably been thought worth the price paid for it"? Why does Harlan say the Court's new rules are "hazardous experimentation"? This case involves the balancing of individual rights against the desire of society to fight crime. How do Justice Harlan and Chief Justice Warren disagree in how they believe these rights and values should be balanced? Has reading the excerpts from the majority and dissenting opinions changed your opinion about this case? How? Shepard Academy Name: U.S. Supreme Court Cases: Miranda v. Arizona (1966) Sg   D E P Q #2<opqrsŷųhSCJ OJQJ^JaJ h\0#CJ OJQJ^JaJ hSh\0#hhh5OJQJ^Jh5OJQJ^Jh\0#5OJQJ^JhS5OJQJ^J!hS5OJQJ^JmHnHsHjhSURS  E F   Q R , -  & Fgd\0#gd\0#&gd\0#^gd\0# & Fgd\0#-    =>#5<pqrs & Fgd\0#gd\0#&gd\0# & Fgd\0#/ 01h/ =!"#$% n<-bPNG  IHDRAVsRGB,IDATx^wtMUGR@bN E$."F%"s2 ɀ A EQ1+ &>7Ǟ;|Guvw:}WU__ook)ڗ]v_^JW:|W:$|+_y\* ˿5y??}ի^u]H)W[[}|ͻۻ]Hx%J`D-jQ>Ǿ%/ywzFovooS?SG=W-\_/˃FEN&D~ڧ}"d7|7~wwhZ׹^^ y( gmv]'-浮uE9WµsOB %y>qk ??#^S K_ҵ9?νG [xCԬx|ɗ$Wₓ}e"!$ooL:op|~!gUVbz1pEtYDć?S ľBßɟ-nA@Nf˭{[<. !? ҖBK/|aY@/-8R /ٟQT$mH#ոu7vI(g|\q$s??++(D"U)Rۼ_QΝ<3[k=W Wǯ- C6 hF15>`+"U!C?g|g0mw\\TZ~7~~"yn[ rS^HςN9&}CODڡ#׽Ֆt;V/H:B 'py#?#W?C>D=}FA|^칑²I$j뿦*~!kȆ"oo0HD!Iɵ4j̰UH!9 0ˤAϢ7Q;;\(82Ho"cHt"FKfsMS|9%Dʳ#Q.͝n!??˨ͅ5Nwz_\6QΘɴ{ҿ΍"etp}G }/S"pIr7 pV /uRe=~$|ӓ oVjF7tG-=˩a$mVEݱ3To?#?r]]{GgܐP.Q~}(v9z"LwtCKbǂj[w?4FTp4wK_/!zja"(T0m J<Nt%ce3!㞍ۆ[$B}ԴWP~riCVw3ix16f{g<׿(Z4;фEEWl6䏰ҨzPaOvo'M2vnFJb]$5(&rKs2,A6mT|sL -]<1"S3 (fB~"+$C~|2s~c! 5.t3JkZ!,k=[["@o h"n؏Q_nBpbբP3 \IM 4g봻$NY,O.Qe(u4'?8v;Ͳ_cywY}˳wl$6 ӷQ>+8(EQSRrV۝9|<9ϑ9k ~MZYAMMJ˽ٛW}WQp~0fɒa~f5:L}>veBbf,A e[|Pݚ3N՗4 pZ@)`8 .ĸSfAnkɭJѕ^"h2;lWWGCXZn3(RWX- J¥\j){O~2 ͚1%q~~g\8Hh Po|[%Ð7>i:>Fc}zjqq=Q TH vA' GuCM4w~| x-i|SJ?3?>ԎkO_jLݖ4 w:m͂Ge`jIE2ZIp1CEO7(wQ-00 u3+oF`5y7%/x tm/ 7f sg\U^u==osVpu3E3ZWV>볾雾<;Gh)CH؉A&~OO'~/Ve S&tಿAc:-4f7#m`&H=-.r4%b> x0y 'ZZ;㑳v49f|&7@ {7+_'=IP,=0jykHnJ'GBt;ѯOxGi#lc;Zrvnh%sRmpiwIA&U o>?yBiv;&HD69Ûo|$O&z/ d͸,{8#_qMxWPDZtg ܅_pC wNr>^r}jڪH\AA'֡|&ih+O i`s sOO>ƀo'8oytʠ%K Zbs4m M%77SYtWiϥ_.O`YM:oNbbdl1=iO$w43͖bc u+ `ʤgg~&d[J.'fb }ߗ^zy^X?CUU1)$Wfc.͡ǀ!.OZ3!$$lqD3-𖷼%~pZ2sEP0wy2l< hIpbp=9S$nZ G&2VYyvfd@Bb[z)ф> 6e"u*&$w/"3$n@B{w#Įkc瀄msV-DʔZs"2cڈgi!*קX*²dTdzS‰N&*Fܦg&7V+D?O|96 PFgYCf3vF jD43ҊXۊ}]6i5D`~ݭ=Zo!P'#u|݌K^1 A998oP;{v1e\E]RSʛZF\QZ^C#RWŎ.k3)mr|G}>H1BE͎~'}|}~]<#70+sEѵ qij;+3k@ˎ[0{Li__?L ǁ\ԩG2#L Ĉvj6~^ A2wЃ0ڵ>TL9M"BS4}۷R0'9͡h-] p>[XSuHXOz&02hDs/cHvYB$2 Uqm EVC (;<<"D~闼 $;P*Ooh,IHD. y~6ՒsNYq2Oz|}|$a<=N3O$ @΄;^B6iHO}SCH.f7uA,a.O+>YY+VxVWf>ЉpqB wm&!,o Gr-Q{}u6{)-LBu:MdC,MBLML_M~gi.3ыOJjz(PqÛ|dV7 !B M]PuV#e͌y8gH> x2 6/r6f{pM_'\=Ak&}lU( EN=яV@$܍-&adԺ |ctrTR$/f& ~ U\[KIJ)[HAHJ;h(LANlrkڛT(LyY%U"Ed(+ tD7Ŝw%mŷ~JÒ>Q e|{S˲S6J.0O֠}ãaɷ *wyw! aws5y_%OAӞz+ˀym[F=Go!Yl9T//EB4א?H/|I:sY+(p68T+1 ^vXMRW^{+RCn@Ѭ٥c2I $ɫ}~j~딹;r&ѬG$E@Sr U]l!=c#s 2ʜ~~ ;t,7uXXIhwl`a;;;{n=|{^kUk{j4:`U6\{ ^{H4L ̾۳+fgwLq"?M."݁<f/z"ݵ+Wtf[_Fۨ6.)FPm"$Y ա(bG.Gd(q$󞉅0,Ijph` k;n{f{*WOPbz)WW_]xoBlRJDGŷ8$*Mcx ϑTJBz&MʊZ3TmHEg#e:dw/e@BB65t tMK^ej3^VAlb2z#wT!!$ݖ"Վq;a ^ؠBL8`a9[Cŭ$6ז;k#_=^NH)KO%dwa=D[INzQ'K:8Ent̆郕私 R1&4'pKx. KvVh[J{Y# xi54Ri#j`Jp+UoD񐵤A)RK g }7AC!]RhKTK3Zg +.>dwpRQE'ݾc P1жOgt61OfU6v0oYѠ p**ƚ[IH%rqmܱ Φ_%Qmce!t%%&j>,G>Z댎TDa8Nk:u+~X3ggJŽ;7LY2P߉,$; Y|io\Džԑ$ٷSMD'2$UApXjCh, mc!ww3@B5tWpx]inC!,N/)>ȈuOc3s}%k멲-+s||Ӓ:|(̒InNpseLRF9)2 {nɩq**Y:GN2)&j `nĢ餀ix-q@@ 0QudM(kE7r$`%eT,LPPPJ;U)=ԭZC{ZsQnؒ7$?AfpjL"C\e^\;2$*˝Z*\A!@ӯ92+OJ15c&?q)D=a\9wusg5m*k"}xBܿr8S ܢClХ:ˏ{swS%rC |곒kbTDDIlL?]%;V)d-F.6'4g9Ңlᎀ::~{Z!a| `o k9t;y],oTb1Aڸs'U $t;{ٚl+Hr#H ګ^f92bba2C2vPS+8ۦǡ\8皬 "g1c"|ѬVs w:?x_gS _: uwgS\dc ϾO8^19wbPG[bbCZuʵ |w~wa! R8 UohB/m؜O95˷}Fl6#+rdBul0q\+xC:&긌4'Mfւ]y̫lRAhB/,;h[O!**lb"4 NlAWr f _n҂"0%lL5 [X!n#|QU`9#;#h*U!'n@evhdBXQ*:$zn /  ;UxL١ˆqS'{_o+5vs2קN{)aw$0B^*PޭKy}P 1 -l xAۤeɅ8la ќstnM$ԳC..$ZI#5,QuX4 ~P 9ײC@$ԅAђ_UH^M3P/HÊ4.6J >!Z[UE> +oq1v<#مc5YI4kVgo<0FنA~(Zb<t"lpOm}ׄLk+LH9s:r/9Hd!mw8C=N Il_ o)D65PM GFm=~A /4b '}G̩gWc(]Sв=[mQXK8t,N!d۟}u![kJW2jqUFP&+ACsy<(PήdT.@ӧ_6(ÐjG@}SX3RqF9񨽐Xgx7Iw2Q 9t")lvҰR@OZ|r/|cݬ0Ut<2ɹ~j=ETX˘9p[YK!Վko&>#SMigʜT1+N~jM-~MR8/8 R>%yI$ [Zj&As ΎQ[$QqMZgC-$e2o[Ќa 7:|rݝlcYww_pʭ:s= RmN{隧&!+i'|+/UoJP32 2L65>nl 'mN#i  !9\;涟Ҿ˿IcRkfy: Ea%Y}nF } #tR7G#{ )F\__}#;$@>)P^t( K!aN"l xaM QіWDkG0e=g @isT堺~Poެ c!CSJ)_8+ajYT36% xxlnشOy&mi rv9kXdxh >@En|s6am_"gjIJmtˈHi>RO,N:x&)D<$ˏ%LKY3?KfyO>%"؞ݲ 5_q\휠^t8'`rRoa)tDR HB-y ndw c-l7Ju\O+o:" 0OTf_.%qTimx;hّ˥QFZeCN>f{M$,V_PԌ asp!DӡݢsĂs-B^jwB|U{t T98LC8џ^ѭVC1?U(c >:67H(ڐ_2<<q ;c!'#ȇ?qp-NݮNM4v+ K`1ZޛlnN)4FqGNO)~W~KS| mTGn82 $'TVwfV6z>ĄzRސZ3zHS0yhj+ Ӷ671옜%mdP \s(+ yl^$YF^ƪcC&?`DAJ6_\Iw(x[BG,6pGBz怐dHrۇf,FɃcK|7Ht%*opБK߀Ηo*XC=c#"F+B&Q$`"!>q^#HhgJO v-1-#/SXί~`FcCs,c e#It͓܋qϸp"G["mer6ksf_wc=Mms$pef8OYi0~E0TzD<5mӍ9DxՇ9[ôt-\u&4iX#~IoPA[ k-}RUW5lIBXxBbZ M.BnAm6G،}Wu1PB<0ɲgr )4WyeZqެwAK'[9dynH3p#';׹!!3]tB`_sy;k+8!wnHaP/ts_,Mi"c{zύ;3N,:1^dI#4+~NES^Ɠ<4NڍR*Y&Ч2S~nHXʁhQ`@@{ rIui1j, vNq_l.?A~Tޮ\Fwl Ir.0Εr פx4u8xSw+/ё%-)cIQq-YWոqڨʶXȶ>kuKb%g:7T/]-;6N vOiʕ0|UbRbx/MH~kriswS/yCX>bJ5x#!N:H&(UHT,*;?EvBö]>錥}gN:@mmbS|V6yCiKdZ{2.lU M*ʿ*B*phNON Heading x$OJQJCJPJ^JaJ6B@6 Body Text x(/@( List^JH"@H Caption xx $CJ6^JaJ].O. Index $^J88 Frame contents!<O"< Table Contents" $FO!2F Table Heading #$a$ $5\D^@BD Normal (Web) $*$KH<OR< bioblurb %*$KH@@b@ \0# List Paragraph &^PK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭V$ !)O^rC$y@/yH*񄴽)޵߻UDb`}"qۋJחX^)I`nEp)liV[]1M<OP6r=zgbIguSebORD۫qu gZo~ٺlAplxpT0+[}`jzAV2Fi@qv֬5\|ʜ̭NleXdsjcs7f W+Ն7`g ȘJj|h(KD- dXiJ؇(x$( :;˹! I_TS 1?E??ZBΪmU/?~xY'y5g&΋/ɋ>GMGeD3Vq%'#q$8K)fw9:ĵ x}rxwr:\TZaG*y8IjbRc|XŻǿI u3KGnD1NIBs RuK>V.EL+M2#'fi ~V vl{u8zH *:(W☕ ~JTe\O*tHGHY}KNP*ݾ˦TѼ9/#A7qZ$*c?qUnwN%Oi4 =3N)cbJ uV4(Tn 7_?m-ٛ{UBwznʜ"Z xJZp; {/<P;,)''KQk5qpN8KGbe Sd̛\17 pa>SR! 3K4'+rzQ TTIIvt]Kc⫲K#v5+|D~O@%\w_nN[L9KqgVhn R!y+Un;*&/HrT >>\ t=.Tġ S; Z~!P9giCڧ!# B,;X=ۻ,I2UWV9$lk=Aj;{AP79|s*Y;̠[MCۿhf]o{oY=1kyVV5E8Vk+֜\80X4D)!!?*|fv u"xA@T_q64)kڬuV7 t '%;i9s9x,ڎ-45xd8?ǘd/Y|t &LILJ`& -Gt/PK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 0_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!0C)theme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] Ns NQs s - s l,b$bD-1@R(    Hqq1 "?   BA "?B S s *Ft@%;*t@# q t # q t R# 2 2 < o t YW)bSK)' h Zd^`OJQJP^`P@@^@`0^`0``^``^`^`^``^``00^0`^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.SK)h ZYW)WW8Num1                           \0#5<+]&;BS# % @s @UnknownG*Ax Times New Roman5Symbol3. *Cx Arial?= *Cx Courier New;Wingdings;(SimSun[SO5MangalA$BCambria Math"hBB"f]h !r0 m 3QPB!xx )Advanced Placement Literature/CompositionCoyFetscher, Chad      Oh+'0l   ( 4 @LT\d,Advanced Placement Literature/CompositionCoyNormalFetscher, Chad2Microsoft Office Word@F#@3@F@F]՜.+,0 hp   Microsoft  *Advanced Placement Literature/Composition Title  !"$%&'()*+,-./0123456789;<=>?@ACDEFGHILRoot Entry F\LN1Table#,WordDocumentuESummaryInformation(:DocumentSummaryInformation8BCompObjr  F Microsoft Word 97-2003 Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q