ࡱ>  Objbj "GV V ++++8c+~+4"< !+#+#+#+#+#+#+.T1#+( "( , #+b&E8+b&b&b&0 !+b&( !+b&b&((5+#()N+0~+(1b&1(b&(L)( ( ( V :    New York University Educational Leadership Program 82 Washington Square East, 6th Fl. New York, NY 10012 Fall Semester, 2012 E10: 2130 Participatory Action Research (PAR) Instructor: Gary AndersonClass Location:LC7 Tisch Hall (Stern)Office Location: Pless Hall 626Class Time: Wed. 4:55-6:35Telephone  Use emailEmail Address:gary.anderson@nyu.eduOffice Hours: By appointment  Catalogue description: Introduction to various approaches to Participatory Action Research (PAR) with an emphasis on approaches that encourage the participation of as many stakeholders as possible. The course will cover various action research traditions, including practitioner research, and issues of positionality, methodology, validity and ethics. Objectives: Students will demonstrate an understanding of the various traditions of action research. (evaluated by Synthesis paper) Students will demonstrate an understanding of the various insider/outsider positions along a continuum that researchers can take, and related issues of a studys trustworthiness, transferability, and ethics. (Evaluated by double entry journals) 3. Students will be able to apply these concepts to specific PAR studies. Grading: 30% Double Entry journals on readings. These typically run from 3 to 4 pages. (See appendix A) 50% Final Paper (Doctoral students working on dissertation proposals can replace this assignment with proposal-related work) 20% Class attendance and participation (One emergency absence allowed. You neednt contact me for this one; 5 points off for each additional absence) Due Dates: Due DateAssignmentPagesSept. 26Double Entry Journal (DEJ)3-4Oct. 3Double Entry Journal (DEJ)3-4Oct. 10Double Entry Journal (DEJ)3-4Dec. 12Final Paper10-12  Required Texts: Herr, Kathryn. and Anderson, Gary. L. (2005). The action research dissertation: A guide for students and faculty. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Freire, Paulo. (1970). The pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Continuum. Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association (fifth Edition) Washington, D.C.: A.P.A. (All of your papers should follow APA. Guidelines; All students should own a copy of this manual.) Not required, but recommended: Any text that reviews basic qualitative data gathering skills (ie. interviewing, observation, document analysis, discourse analysis, etc.) See also methods chapter in the Studying Your Own School pdf on Blackboard. See also (not required): M. Brinton Lykes website on Participatory Action Research:  HYPERLINK "http://www2.bc.edu/~lykes/research.htm" http://www2.bc.edu/~lykes/research.htm Action Research Organizations: Research for Action:  HYPERLINK "http://www.researchforaction.org/index.html" http://www.researchforaction.org/index.html The Institute for Community Research:  HYPERLINK "http://www.incommunityresearch.org/index.htm" http://www.incommunityresearch.org/index.htm Youth Action Research Group:  HYPERLINK "http://www.yargdc.blogspot.com/" http://www.yargdc.blogspot.com/ Institute for Participatory Action Research and Design (CUNY):  HYPERLINK "http://web.gc.cuny.edu/che/start.htm" http://web.gc.cuny.edu/che/start.htm East St. Louis Action Research Project:  HYPERLINK "http://www.eslarp.uiuc.edu/" http://www.eslarp.uiuc.edu/ Course schedule: Sept. 5: What is Action Research and how is it different from other research? Issues of Epistemology, Positionality, and Power. Matt Waynes action research video: (This video may no longer be available)  HYPERLINK "http://www.teachersnetwork.org/teachnetnyc/mattwayne/actionres.htm" http://www.teachersnetwork.org/teachnetnyc/mattwayne/actionres.htm Pio Pico Student Researchers Participatory Action Research  HYPERLINK "http://gallery.carnegiefoundation.org/collections/castl_k12/ewolk/index.html" http://gallery.carnegiefoundation.org/collections/castl_k12/ewolk/index.html Sept. 12: Action Research Paradigms and traditions; Validity criteria for Action Research and Creating local and public knowledge through Action Research: Positionality. Required readings: Herr, K. and Anderson, G. (2005). The action research dissertation: A guide for students and faculty. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. (Chapters 1, 2 and 3). See also (not required): Anderson, G.L. and Herr, K. (1999). The new paradigm wars. Is there room for rigorous practitioner knowledge in schools and universities? Educational Researcher, 28(5), 12-21. Sept. 19: Examples of PAR Video: From the Community to the Classroom Sept. 26: Getting Started: The evolution of a research question and participants. Due: Double entry journal on chapter 4 (Kathryn Herr). Guest speaker: Kathryn Herr Required readings: Anderson, G.L., Herr, K., and Nihlen, A. (2007). Studying your own school: An educator's guide to qualitative, practitioner research, (second edition). Newbury Park: Corwin Press. (chapter 4 Empowerment and Practitioner Action Research: An Example). (On Blackboard, scroll down for chapter 4). See also (not required) Herr, K. (1999). Private power and privileged education: De/constructing institutionalized racism. Journal of Inclusive Education, 3 (2). 111-129. Oct. 3: The Power of Voice: Double Journal Entry of the two Couldry chapters due. Couldry, Nick (2010). Why voice matters: Culture and politics after neoliberalism. London: Sage (Chapters 1 and 2). Pushor, D. and Clandinin, J. (2009). The interconnections between narrative inquiry and action research. In S. Noffke and B. Somekh (Eds.) The SAGE Handbook of Educational Action Research. Los Angeles: Sage. Additional readings (not required): Bullough, R.V. and Pinnegar, S. (2001). Guidelines for quality in autobiographical forms of self-study research. Educational Researcher, 30(3), 13-22. Connelly, F.M. and Clandinin, J. (1990). Stories of experience and narrative inquiry. Educational Researcher, 19(5), 2-14. Reed-Danahay, D. (Ed.). (1997) Auto/ethnography: Rewriting the self and the social. New York: Berg. Oct. 10: No Class. You will upload a double entry journal discussing quality or validity criteria for action research this evening instead of attending class. Read Chapter Four of The Action Research Dissertation and Peter Reasons article, Choice and quality in action research practice and discuss your reactions to the two approaches. Herr, K. and Anderson, G. (2005). The action research dissertation: A guide for students and faculty. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. (Chapter 4: Quality Criteria for Action Research: An ongoing conversation) Reason, P. (2006). Choice and quality in action research practice. Journal of Management Inquiry, 15(2), 187-203. Oct. 17: A whole systems approach to PAR Required reading: Burns, D. (2007). Systemic action research: A strategy for whole system change. Bristol: UK: The Policy Press. (chapters 2, 3, and part of 4; pp. 21-68) Oct. 24: PAR and Paulo Freire. Due: Double entry journal on chapter 3 of Freire. Required readings: Freire, Paulo. (1970). The pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Continuum. (Focus especially on chapters 2 & 3) See also (not required): Gonzalez, E.R., Lejano, R., Vidales, G. Conner, R. , Kidokoro, Y., Fazeli, B. Cabrales, R. (2007). Participatory Action Research for environmental health: Encountering Freire in the urban barrio. Journal of Urban Affairs, 25(1), 77-100. Reyes, L. and Torres, M. (2007). Decolonizing family literacy in a culture circle: Reinventing the family literacy educators role. The Journal of Early Childhood literacy, 7, 73-94. (On Blackboard) Oct. 31: YouthPAR Cahill, Caitlin (2006) At risk'? The Fed Up Honeys re-present the gentrification of the Lower East Side. Women Studies Quarterly 34, 1 - 2, 334-363. Cahill, Caitlin (2007). participatory data analysis and beyond the journal article: Representations, audience, and the presentation of participatory research (chapters 21 and 23) In Kindon, S., Pain, R., and Kesby, M. Participatory Action Research Approaches and Methods. New York, Routldege. (Accesible as an e-book though the NYU library). Nov. 7: PAR and Technology: Flicker, S., Maley, O. Ridgley, A., Biscope, S., Lombardo, C. and Skinner, H. (2008). e-PAR: Using technology and participatory action research to engage youth in health promotion. Action Research, 6(3), 285-303. Video: The War Tapes ( HYPERLINK "http://www.thewartapes.com" www.thewartapes.com) NPR audio: http://www.npr.org/player/v2/mediaPlayer.html?action=1&t=1&islist=false&id=5524323&m=5524871 See TED talk:  HYPERLINK "http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.html" http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.html Interview with Deborah Scranton: http://www.pbs.org/mediashift/2006/08/war-tapes-film-lets-soldiers-tell-their-stories-from-iraq227.html Nov. 14: PAR and Community organizing Guest Speaker: Donna Nevel, Center for Immigrant Families Participatory Action Research for Community Organizing. http://parceo.org/2012/02/14/about-parceo/  HYPERLINK "http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home"  INCLUDEPICTURE "http://www.researchfororganizing.org/uploads/images/structure/RFOtype.png" \* MERGEFORMATINET  A Toolkit for Participatory Action Research from the Community Development Project  HYPERLINK "http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home" http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home Watch brief videos at: http://www.sundancechannel.com/thegoodfight/projects/toxic_tour?video=230324329 Required reading: Segregated and Unequal: The Public Elementary Schools of District 3 in New York City, Center for Immigrant Families (on blackboard) See also (not required): Tandon, S. D., Kelly, J.G. and Mock L. (2001). Participatory action research as a resource for developing African American community leadership. In D. Tolman and M. Brydon-Miller (Eds.) From subjects to subjectivities: A handbook of interpretive and participatory methods (200-217) New York: New York University Press. Nov. 21: Dilemmas of PAR; Ethics of PAR Nygreen, Kysa (2009-2010). Critical dilemmas in PAR: Toward a new theory of engaged research for social change. Social Justice, 36(4), 14-35. Cahill, C. (2007). Repositioning ethical commitments: Participatory Action Research as a relational praxis of social change. ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies, 6 (3), 360-373. Nov. 28: PAR and Organizational Learning. Herr, K., & Anderson, G. (2008). Teacher research and learning communities: A failure to theorize power relations? Language Arts, 85(5), 382391. Anderson, Laurie. (1997). Argyris and Schons theory on congruence and learning [on line] Available at  HYPERLINK "http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/arp/argyris.html" http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/arp/argyris.html Dec. 5: School Inquiry Teams and Participatory Action Research? Robinson, M. (November, 2010). School perspectives on collaborative inquiry: Lessons learned from New York City, 2009-20010. New York: Consortium for Policy Research in Education (CPRE). Blogs: http://edwize.org/inquiring-about-inquiry-teams-can-the-doe-mandate-reflective-practice/comment-p  HYPERLINK "http://mets2006.wordpress.com/2007/09/29/inquiry-teams-can-the-department-mandate-innovation-and-creativity-will-the-lure-of-merit-pay-and-the-fear-of-denial-of-tenure-foster-collegiality-does-trust-preceed-inquiry/" http://mets2006.wordpress.com/2007/09/29/inquiry-teams-can-the-department-mandate-innovation-and-creativity-will-the-lure-of-merit-pay-and-the-fear-of-denial-of-tenure-foster-collegiality-does-trust-preceed-inquiry/  HYPERLINK "http://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htm" http://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htm Dec. 12: Final papers due and final presentations. Nov. 7: YouthPAR Cahill, Caitlin (2006) At risk'? The Fed Up Honeys re-present the gentrification of the Lower East Side. Women Studies Quarterly 34, 1 - 2, 334-363. Cahill, Caitlin (2007). participatory data analysis and beyond the journal article: Representations, audience, and the presentation of participatory research (chapters 21 and 23) In Kindon, S., Pain, R., and Kesby, M. Participatory Action Research Approaches and Methods. New York, Routldege. (Accesible as an e-book though the NYU library). Nov. 14: PAR and Community organizing Guest Speaker: Donna Nevel, Center for Immigrant Families Participatory Action Research for Community Organizing. http://parceo.org/2012/02/14/about-parceo/  HYPERLINK "http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home"  A Toolkit for Participatory Action Research from the Community Development Project HYPERLINK "http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home"http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home Watch brief videos at: HYPERLINK "http://www.sundancechannel.com/thegoodfight/projects/toxic_tour?video=230324329"http://www.sundancechannel.com/thegoodfight/projects/toxic_tour?video=230324329 Google: Where we live: The changing face of climate activism. Required reading: Segregated and Unequal: The Public Elementary Schools of District 3 in New York City, Center for Immigrant Families (on blackboard) See also (not required): Tandon, S. D., Kelly, J.G. and Mock L. (2001). Participatory action research as a resource for developing African American community leadership. In D. Tolman and M. Brydon-Miller (Eds.) From subjects to subjectivities: A handbook of interpretive and participatory methods (200-217) New York: New York University Press. Nov. 21: Dilemmas of PAR; Ethics of PAR (Class?) Nygreen, Kysa (2009-2010). Critical dilemmas in PAR: Toward a new theory of engaged research for social change. Social Justice, 36(4), 14-35. Cahill, C. (2007). Repositioning ethical commitments: Participatory Action Research as a relational praxis of social change. ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies, 6 (3), 360-373. Nov. 28: PAR and Technology: Flicker, S., Maley, O. Ridgley, A., Biscope, S., Lombardo, C. and Skinner, H. (2008). e-PAR: Using technology and participatory action research to engage youth in health promotion. Action Research, 6(3), 285-303. Video: The War Tapes (HYPERLINK "http://www.thewartapes.com"www.thewartapes.com) NPR audio: http://www.npr.org/player/v2/mediaPlayer.html?action=1&t=1&islist=false&id=5524323&m=5524871 See TED talk: HYPERLINK "http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.html"http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.html Interview with Deborah Scranton: http://www.pbs.org/mediashift/2006/08/war-tapes-film-lets-soldiers-tell-their-stories-from-iraq227.html Dec. 5: School Inquiry Teams, organizational learning and Participatory Action Research? Herr, K., & Anderson, G. (2008). Teacher research and learning communities: A failure to theorize power relations? Language Arts, 85(5), 382391. Anderson, Laurie. (1997). Argyris and Schons theory on congruence and learning [on line] Available at HYPERLINK "http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/arp/argyris.html"http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/arp/argyris.html See also (not required): Robinson, M. (November, 2010). School perspectives on collaborative inquiry: Lessons learned from New York City, 2009-20010. New York: Consortium for Policy Research in Education (CPRE). Blogs: http://edwize.org/inquiring-about-inquiry-teams-can-the-doe-mandate-reflective-practice/comment-p HYPERLINK "http://mets2006.wordpress.com/2007/09/29/inquiry-teams-can-the-department-mandate-innovation-and-creativity-will-the-lure-of-merit-pay-and-the-fear-of-denial-of-tenure-foster-collegiality-does-trust-preceed-inquiry/"http://mets2006.wordpress.com/2007/09/29/inquiry-teams-can-the-department-mandate-innovation-and-creativity-will-the-lure-of-merit-pay-and-the-fear-of-denial-of-tenure-foster-collegiality-does-trust-preceed-inquiry/ HYPERLINK "http://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htm"http://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htm Dec. 12: Final papers due and final presentations. Meet on Monday. Appendix A Suggested format for the Double Entry Journal PRIVATE 1. Author(s), year of publication, title of chapter or article and title of book or journal it came from, and the location and name of the publisher.  PRIVATELeft-hand side- Objective Summary & Highpoints Right-hand side- Subjective Reflections 2. Full summary of reading (5 or 6 sentences someone who hadn't read the reading could understand) 1. Your thoughts on the overall content of the reading. 2. How did it tie in with your experiences, beliefs, philosophy, prior knowledge? 3. Have your ideas changed or been confirmed? 3. List 6-10 thought provoking points or quotes from the reading These are just prompts for reflection you neednt answer each one. 1. Do you agree or disagree with each point? 2. Are you annoyed, impressed, scared, dazzled or ? 3. Is there anything more you would like to know about the topic? 4. Are you aware of any literature or research that conflicts with the author's position? 5. How did this change your understanding of this topic? 4. 1 question you have. 1. Why is this question important to you? 2. What are the implications of the question? Appendix B Assignment Due Dec. 12 (No late papers, as I have to hand in grades): Compare and contrast the following Action Research Studies: 1) Kathryn Herrs research with her middle school students 2) Caitlin Cahills study with the Fed Up Honeys; 3) the School for Pregnant and Parenting Teens School Inquiry Groups and 4) either The War Tapes or From the Community to the Classroom. In a paper of 10-12 pages, try to address the following: 1) Which tradition(s) of action research is each informed by? (See Herr and Anderson, 2005, pp. 10-25); 2) Which knowledge interests do they represent? (Herr and Anderson, 2005, pp. 26-28); 3) Discuss the positionality of the researcher(s) (Herr and Anderson, 2005, chapter 3); and 4) Evaluate the quality of the studies. Based on Herr and Andersons (2005) five validity criteria (pp. 53-57) or Reasons criteria: How would you evaluate them on EACH criteria? PAGE  PAGE 1 4PRVWk    XYst|zmbzbzbzbzbzh?,h'B*phhh'5B*phh'B*phh'Fh'5 h'5 hallh' h'>* h'5>*jh'CJUmHnHuh'OJQJ hy$h'h\h'5h\h'6CJOJQJh\h'6CJH*OJQJh'6CJOJQJh'CJOJQJh'&4Wk $If !`gd'$a$gd' $a$gd' $7$8$H$a$$xa$$a$   # 0 ? $Ifmkd$$Ifl\%(& > d&64 la? @ K V e { $Ifmkd$$Ifl\%(& > d&64 la{ | x$Ifmkd$$Ifl\%(& > d&64 la      ~yp~h`hgd'gd' & F pxmkd$$Ifl\%(& > d&64 la 6 7 LMXYbms $Ifgd'gd' st}qhhh $Ifgd'kd8$$IflF.[T t06    44 laqhhh $Ifgd'kd$$IflF.[T t06    44 laqhhh $Ifgd'kd$$IflF.[T t06    44 laqhhh $Ifgd'kd0$$IflF.[T t06    44 la I/   ABCijklܹ؏؂wd$jh}Kh'B*Uphh`Y~h'B*phjh'B*Uphh`Y~h'5h'0JB*ph333jh'B*Uph333h'B*ph333jh'B*Uph333 h'hhah'6 h'6h' h'5hr(h'B*phh'B*phh?,h'B*ph&  qlgg_RRRR $0^`0a$$a$gd'$a$gd'kd$$IflF.[T t06    44 la  kl    gd' $@&a$gd'$0@&^`0a$gd'$@&a$ $0^`0a$$a$gd' 0^`0gd'    123?kmno    CKLMY}❘zohKD`h'B*ph$jh}Kh'B*Uphhh'B*ph h'5hh'5$j%h}Kh'B*Uph$jZh}Kh'B*Uphh`Y~h'B*phh`Y~h'5h'h'B*phjh'B*UphhVjh'0J)+,-MNO)޷묡wrn[UJhl*h'B*ph h'0J$jv h?,h'B*Uphh' h'5h'B*CJOJQJphh?,h'B*CJ phh?,h'5B*CJ phh}fh'B*ph333h}fh'B*phhT7Lh'0J$j hT7Lh'B*UphhKD`h'B*phjh'B*Uphh'B*phhKD`h'5B*ph,-{|,-@A 0^`0gd'$0@&^`0a$gd' $@&a$gd'$a$$@&a$)+,-yz{|,-?@Ac/yDdnTuȸyqqh*#h'5 h'6] h'aJhn;h'aJ hn;h' hph' hL}h'hh'6 hh' h'6h' h'5 h'5@ h'@hT7Lh'0Jjh'B*Uph$jm hT7Lh'B*Uphh'B*ph,@AxyNO ! 0^`0gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd' $@&a$gd',!D7Q]|{ !!!=!!!(")"J"W"X"ոxrc[xh\h'6h\h'B*OJQJph h'@h'5B*OJQJphh'56B*OJQJph#hh'56B*OJQJph hh'5B*OJQJphhh'B*OJQJphh'6B*OJQJphh'B*OJQJph h'6 h'5h>x2h'6h'hezkh'6!EF\]!!!!X"Y"""""2#3#R#S###$0@&^`0a$gd'$0@&^`0a$gd' $@&a$gd'X"Y"""""""1#2#S#_#x####### $ $#$%$$%%%%%%%%%Y&s&'''ùù桚桍暅undh*#h'5aJ h'5aJh*#h'6aJ h'aJhr/h'6h[=h'6B*ph hr/h'h'B*ph h'6hb%(h'B*phh'5B*phhALh'5B*phh\geh'6 h\geh' hh'h' h'5 hh'5B*OJQJph%### $ $$$%$%%%%%%D&&&'p01$7$8$H$^p`0gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd' 1$7$8$H$gd'$0@&^`0a$gd'$0^`0a$gd' $@&a$gd'''''((()))))2*3*****+++++B,,gd' $@&a$gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd' 1$7$8$H$gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd'''P((((((()))%)&)4)))))))))0*1*T*****W++++++ԹްާޗԹާޒsbs!jh$h'CJOJQJUh$h'CJOJQJ h$h'h' hph' h'5j hQfh'UaJh2h'aJho^[h'aJhQfh'0JaJj hQfh'UaJjh'UaJ h'aJh&h'6aJh&h'aJh&h'aJ#++++=,>,?,@,A,,,,,,,,,---1-----ijĝڐ}of^SKAh'OJQJ^JhQVh'5hQVh'B*phh'B*phhQfh'0Jj,hQfh'U h$h'jh'Uh'h$h'CJOJQJ*jAh$h'B*CJOJQJUph!h$h'B*CJOJQJph*jh$h'B*CJOJQJUph!jh$h'CJOJQJU'j^h$h'CJOJQJU,,--1-----..3.4.u/v///.0/000"1#101$7$8$H$^`0gd'gd'$0@&^`0a$gd' $@&a$gd'--.2.3.4..E/t/u/v//0!0/0B0Y0d0e0i000000000 1 1"1#11111122ü⦝~rir~aaah'OJQJh'5^JaJhh'5^JaJh'^JaJhb#h'^JaJhb#h'\^JaJ(h'\^JaJ(hb#h'6]^JaJhHh'6 hh' h'5h'6B*OJQJphh'B*OJQJphh' h'^Jh9i-h'^Jh9i-h'6^J11222233334455E6F6y601$7$8$H$^`0gd' 1$7$8$H$gd'" & 0` P@21$^2`gd' $@&a$gd' #^#`gd'gd'01$^`0gd'22b2c2d2222222Y334444444455555 6 6󥗆n`O h h'B* \^J aJ0ph:hWh'0J\^J aJ0/j/hxh'B* U\^J aJ0ph: hh'B* \^J aJ0ph:h'B* \^J aJ0ph:#jh'B* U\^J aJ0ph: h h'h'OJQJ h'5 h*:h' h'0Jjh'0JU h'0Jj:.h'Uh'jh'U 6 6 6C6D6x6y6667{8889?9A9B9C99999999չtlalFlt5jl3hh'B*CJOJQJUmHnHphuj2h'Ujh'Uh$h'CJOJQJ h$h'h' hph'h*#h'6aJ h'aJ h'5 h4Ph'B* \^J aJ0ph:h'B* \^J aJ0ph:hQfh'0J\^J aJ0#jh'B* U\^J aJ0ph:/j81hQfh'B* U\^J aJ0ph:y6z6666#7$7z8{88888@9A9B9999c:gd'p01$7$8$H$^p`0gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd' 1$7$8$H$gd' $@&a$gd'$@&a$99':(:):a:b:d:{:|::::(;);i;j;};~;;;<<<<.=]=^=_==>>#>6>׻󱧞~yryj\hb#h'6]^JaJhHh'6 hh' h'5h'6B*OJQJphh'B*OJQJph h'^Jh9i-h'^Jh9i-h'6^Jh'OJQJ^JhQVh'5h[`h'0JjCQh'Uh'B*phhQfh'0Jj`Ph'Uh'jh'U!c:d:{:*;+;j;k;};~;<<<<^=_===">#>>> ? ? 1$7$8$H$gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd'gd'$0@&^`0a$gd' $@&a$gd'6>M>X>Y>]>}>>>>>>>>> ? ?`???????@@ @3@4@B@@@@@@@A?AAA"B#BBBCCC #^#`gd'gd'01$^`0gd' $@&a$gd' 1$7$8$H$gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd'01$7$8$H$^`0gd'`AAA#BBBBBBCCC`CaCbCCCCCCC0DxDDDDEEEFFFFFFFGG\G]G_Gןבxבg h4Ph'B* \^J aJ0ph:hQfh'0J\^J aJ0jVh'Uh'B* \^J aJ0ph:hWh'0J\^J aJ0jTh'U h h' h= h' h'0JjSh'Ujh'Uh'OJQJh' h'5 h*:h'h2h'aJ(CCoDpDwDxDDDFFGG]G^G_G`GaGbGcG  !gd' $@&a$gd'$@&a$01$7$8$H$^`0gd' 1$7$8$H$gd'" & 0` P@21$^2`gd'_G`GaGcGnGGGGGCHDHKHLHIMVMZM}MOOOOOOOOOOOOOɸh'0JmHnHu h'0Jjh'0JUhL}h'6 h'jh'Uh' h'5h'B*OJQJphcGnGoGGGGGAHBHCH|HHg^ggd'4kdW$$IfTP=$$4agT$If^gd'^gd' $^a$gd'^gd'$a$gd' HH ICIIIIJLJyJJJbLkdX$$IfT0P,8?X%4agT$IfJkd%X$$IfT0P,8?X%4agT JIKKKKKKKKKKe```gd'JkdqY$$IfT0P,8?X%4agTJkdY$$IfT0P,8?X%4agT$If KLLLLLMLMMOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO &`#$gd'^@&^$@&a$$a$gd'gd'$a$gd'OOOOOOOOgd' &`#$gd'h]hgd' 1h/ =!"#$%$$If!vh55 545 #v#v #v4#v :V ld&65(5& 5>5 4$$If!vh55 545 #v#v #v4#v :V ld&65(5& 5>5 4$$If!vh55 545 #v#v #v4#v :V ld&65(5& 5>5 4$$If!vh55 545 #v#v #v4#v :V ld&65(5& 5>5 4$$If!vh55[5T#v#v[#vT:V l t0655[5T$$If!vh55[5T#v#v[#vT:V l t0655[5T$$If!vh55[5T#v#v[#vT:V l t0655[5T$$If!vh55[5T#v#v[#vT:V l t0655[5T$$If!vh55[5T#v#v[#vT:V l t0655[5TDyK 'http://www2.bc.edu/~lykes/research.htmyK Nhttp://www2.bc.edu/~lykes/research.htmDyK yK Xhttp://www.researchforaction.org/index.htmlDyK yK Zhttp://www.incommunityresearch.org/index.htmDyK yK @http://www.yargdc.blogspot.com/DyK yK Jhttp://web.gc.cuny.edu/che/start.htmDyK http://www.eslarp.uiuc.edu/yK 8http://www.eslarp.uiuc.edu/DyK yK http://www.teachersnetwork.org/teachnetnyc/mattwayne/actionres.htmDyK Mhttp://gallery.carnegiefoundation.org/collections/castl_k12/ewolk/index.htmlyK http://gallery.carnegiefoundation.org/collections/castl_k12/ewolk/index.htmlDyK www.thewartapes.comyK 6http://www.thewartapes.comuDyK @http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.htmlyK http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.htmlDyK yK rhttp://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=homeDd)N4*  s A.ÞRFOtypeesearch for OrganizingyK yK rhttp://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=homeb"?\+3 ˿Un?\+3 ˿UPNG  IHDR)N|tEXtSoftwareAdobe ImageReadyqe<IDATx]}uyy]eű:jSLJV!NRF BAJHGSD*EdRa%j'Q i프,4N}{{yvsܙy#-f9{{/ )BUJRH!,be'77]#s؛ qr6?À>4a.x5ނ ?%'|-bHMm䱃dF^(9SL[y]WڸTj'5MmbSv| kFϛ#ͯ${zW<qbc9w]үnJo}QyRKWʝ=^ yx:{mwzBRqOU*% z{.5V mOV=s=V`Am1hsx'RLfIVV)C6aaPl)i&gƸg\yt~ JnqFKPINQ+GNU'F s 'l%蜫yc1*"ӹN2ލ6feWﴮ2ݳߩ7ڦAʦ_.6aK+b+4N(7~VʳI@1{t4 ~}fphא1G6Tτ7bJzkL@GA>'_6}qcx?*l?:8tK_0Hu 6XRҐt!ېi3EQ@ݬ{6] A {7ɯΔlHYg!yl[eCk/хt͖e37;zr͊ڱm"]a{CIhAB⼈PM%iAܑё0Zx6MC,:ţ0sS!mR&PJܐKg*r=Kׯkɲ*G :O ͓292ܧ$ZH{&"dZapTT/%Oʛڜ **ݳQL*_jyH0 PYYڲ~瘡ճk$'u">^ESԣDБi3 ^@hBbhKyYܐP/Wq}Ɓ ~woJzZ[4#ޡ[Y]oך4!3>g#ޫ#ygk]w͒o\Xn޿3:H%.Ԋ\n;(1+g0'c^3Fc|TGOlîkrtr[ ` Y{ԇOI?3j5/, 8͝5+t@m<,Tਖ਼x6u&օzO3M]뵢ߝW1aA~Jkbi0yF(O ޔ%>_ő>4ABj(r}s~n )Ӿ?pcLnT=tl{@hIN lw_yz/oՍ <ܼ֓Bx\&&&qWAf DE$% 4g`Ivך{#7rt;:yo䕏L{wy_SKBxvtY7~U_sSo~{S {fEșQK``XPaʣd9 `VUQx$腁8kg,?8ަ#?E?n7<#xaw t HT9)Hzbm]J6չ%UVnMpn^TYኜO@W|׭Yk#8Y&3I<%Z`Wnᡓ"u;Ϟ~/~$=  ;D C{̲ܯ2|U;Zzȣ  w^®ےo]o?➇P0󃯊 Fw+:Ny^w8Og0nvF T(@6k9r C^sl}8%)-_Yc<,IW3r!pK)n!ɣ_AےRZ]{G(;[l.AvyD ؝ r烯?/p.,;|k @*L SAT B?gZY~闹ԕSI/@,pO+:$PdU̥{t^DS%B[/O ?[ES9sp2) TWwC.y*keSz&π'2Kiyf-cp7hQU tҚaJ9j&'1 d⹜] AȑVfKjʎMsh su!>b;8%x,,Aݩ#rGkZpqݪL4c\9 {dv. ;_dpa;7U0u*W¢@H]tmZh†xMy&~  S ~ϴn@82D5st9^:Խ/-4> [}WGj|AJ.t\ ) YMDצ':2pr`U![dŠi v 5q &Uپ\Sߩ6tr7vo\h隿@s u]7ϡR~X+ޟM6i(z,PK ќ!`(& ʢ88`i\ gP!AfUJuad_;86\e Y +g&;OQY5_cJ.5rJKKyQԃg|>7H\y.\EkH\+$rjehLa4cXvȊu^J`@ba&)YyIxoM'0J`W SZT18x*vO(Jx繽@w6^ f@lNʬ7G2ٕ,h6P|@8! fй [\"|mU0jB@輨EDZaܓ?D)n4G+B,d,y\j)̭CpN!b58ز%-bUЭ5U%` HiVweALס6OuڰrY޹GrS Sp`A4..~WA8Ƣ3UpWv 8J3OQ 3uc^ ׁl 9D9mImUHq^g9V8pꜷR|K =("v)#oOJfza7<1NNUIy@ܝA < 8Ar'(L 1*3mgk:Lp*x-{mlurr~YLlQY 9Ws2'}~qQһ^*K#WMM&u]Q,\PyTlY "LJ֢sPN;T2c] >%ʱKm[.š꾋z+* #NvtTWzab|)TF&wʰ];YD9h2yf:hSrl"%Nޏmҥ881mx5Inc;eODJTȗXڵRQ6(&ʷ.n <wU5K;Q{ (*h)8G>,PQu4BvM*U$NNd6[N҃Qb J MnDɃʲ,n$pM#&ʑˬ6ޔLnH18GgTs%T +$Jxg!UXvXᩒ&xہQ2rQPq"JFCx7Dӭn43ų)T3Vq0c$_v5gY-&zy?L=pBh[c# 7=F!8^KpG nsN4txhK -h'AEVGo68Vx[\Wz|:ɖH=8x] z#@CpM\mou|5'ѻq0E GuFSn]τ QQ/8P9D9dT=- hrMnދl8<.DzE]/bZ'~BĠ2jRqw{17m;өIŤNDq`*1&H߲?u9 P{\pdq3XA_Ç[])#V|h^U:bm7W3@sb7jtW565vk'(GUT µWԉB.8gGKZCDy I\!M"w<1ukvQ^DAțIʛIA(g;XݱY$<:9 1=y/3.p%T*PA8SIGp PɝI{ǯ|8^FE c{BG7KW"#S"/BR%jv;R%Tx|lv-P /P@7B=0^]'R.jE1SEȭP:}c[ S5**m X׉[W0$un|4|P+8pԠƓmD`,p{5ʓ,Ƥvշ,&482ʳ uXZPkҦFg#Vgbj;RIz:~`&;-0'Pʹe*]HB f )CPH! UH!b)/-,.^u IENDB`YDyK 9http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=homeyK rhttp://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=homeDyK yK lhttp://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/arp/argyris.html!DyK yK http://mets2006.wordpress.com/2007/09/29/inquiry-teams-can-the-department-mandate-innovation-and-creativity-will-the-lure-of-merit-pay-and-the-fear-of-denial-of-tenure-foster-collegiality-does-trust-preceed-inquiry/QDyK 7http://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htmyK nhttp://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htmDyK yK rhttp://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=homeDd4~  JA.?.Þ esearch for OrganizingPicture 1esearch for OrganizingyK yK rhttp://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home"b"?\+3 ˿U3n?\+3 ˿UPNG  IHDR)N|tEXtSoftwareAdobe ImageReadyqe<IDATx]}uyy]eű:jSLJV!NRF BAJHGSD*EdRa%j'Q i프,4N}{{yvsܙy#-f9{{/ )BUJRH!,be'77]#s؛ qr6?À>4a.x5ނ ?%'|-bHMm䱃dF^(9SL[y]WڸTj'5MmbSv| kFϛ#ͯ${zW<qbc9w]үnJo}QyRKWʝ=^ yx:{mwzBRqOU*% z{.5V mOV=s=V`Am1hsx'RLfIVV)C6aaPl)i&gƸg\yt~ JnqFKPINQ+GNU'F s 'l%蜫yc1*"ӹN2ލ6feWﴮ2ݳߩ7ڦAʦ_.6aK+b+4N(7~VʳI@1{t4 ~}fphא1G6Tτ7bJzkL@GA>'_6}qcx?*l?:8tK_0Hu 6XRҐt!ېi3EQ@ݬ{6] A {7ɯΔlHYg!yl[eCk/хt͖e37;zr͊ڱm"]a{CIhAB⼈PM%iAܑё0Zx6MC,:ţ0sS!mR&PJܐKg*r=Kׯkɲ*G :O ͓292ܧ$ZH{&"dZapTT/%Oʛڜ **ݳQL*_jyH0 PYYڲ~瘡ճk$'u">^ESԣDБi3 ^@hBbhKyYܐP/Wq}Ɓ ~woJzZ[4#ޡ[Y]oך4!3>g#ޫ#ygk]w͒o\Xn޿3:H%.Ԋ\n;(1+g0'c^3Fc|TGOlîkrtr[ ` Y{ԇOI?3j5/, 8͝5+t@m<,Tਖ਼x6u&օzO3M]뵢ߝW1aA~Jkbi0yF(O ޔ%>_ő>4ABj(r}s~n )Ӿ?pcLnT=tl{@hIN lw_yz/oՍ <ܼ֓Bx\&&&qWAf DE$% 4g`Ivך{#7rt;:yo䕏L{wy_SKBxvtY7~U_sSo~{S {fEșQK``XPaʣd9 `VUQx$腁8kg,?8ަ#?E?n7<#xaw t HT9)Hzbm]J6չ%UVnMpn^TYኜO@W|׭Yk#8Y&3I<%Z`Wnᡓ"u;Ϟ~/~$=  ;D C{̲ܯ2|U;Zzȣ  w^®ےo]o?➇P0󃯊 Fw+:Ny^w8Og0nvF T(@6k9r C^sl}8%)-_Yc<,IW3r!pK)n!ɣ_AےRZ]{G(;[l.AvyD ؝ r烯?/p.,;|k @*L SAT B?gZY~闹ԕSI/@,pO+:$PdU̥{t^DS%B[/O ?[ES9sp2) TWwC.y*keSz&π'2Kiyf-cp7hQU tҚaJ9j&'1 d⹜] AȑVfKjʎMsh su!>b;8%x,,Aݩ#rGkZpqݪL4c\9 {dv. ;_dpa;7U0u*W¢@H]tmZh†xMy&~  S ~ϴn@82D5st9^:Խ/-4> [}WGj|AJ.t\ ) YMDצ':2pr`U![dŠi v 5q &Uپ\Sߩ6tr7vo\h隿@s u]7ϡR~X+ޟM6i(z,PK ќ!`(& ʢ88`i\ gP!AfUJuad_;86\e Y +g&;OQY5_cJ.5rJKKyQԃg|>7H\y.\EkH\+$rjehLa4cXvȊu^J`@ba&)YyIxoM'0J`W SZT18x*vO(Jx繽@w6^ f@lNʬ7G2ٕ,h6P|@8! fй [\"|mU0jB@輨EDZaܓ?D)n4G+B,d,y\j)̭CpN!b58ز%-bUЭ5U%` HiVweALס6OuڰrY޹GrS Sp`A4..~WA8Ƣ3UpWv 8J3OQ 3uc^ ׁl 9D9mImUHq^g9V8pꜷR|K =("v)#oOJfza7<1NNUIy@ܝA < 8Ar'(L 1*3mgk:Lp*x-{mlurr~YLlQY 9Ws2'}~qQһ^*K#WMM&u]Q,\PyTlY "LJ֢sPN;T2c] >%ʱKm[.š꾋z+* #NvtTWzab|)TF&wʰ];YD9h2yf:hSrl"%Nޏmҥ881mx5Inc;eODJTȗXڵRQ6(&ʷ.n <wU5K;Q{ (*h)8G>,PQu4BvM*U$NNd6[N҃Qb J MnDɃʲ,n$pM#&ʑˬ6ޔLnH18GgTs%T +$Jxg!UXvXᩒ&xہQ2rQPq"JFCx7Dӭn43ų)T3Vq0c$_v5gY-&zy?L=pBh[c# 7=F!8^KpG nsN4txhK -h'AEVGo68Vx[\Wz|:ɖH=8x] z#@CpM\mou|5'ѻq0E GuFSn]τ QQ/8P9D9dT=- hrMnދl8<.DzE]/bZ'~BĠ2jRqw{17m;өIŤNDq`*1&H߲?u9 P{\pdq3XA_Ç[])#V|h^U:bm7W3@sb7jtW565vk'(GUT µWԉB.8gGKZCDy I\!M"w<1ukvQ^DAțIʛIA(g;XݱY$<:9 1=y/3.p%T*PA8SIGp PɝI{ǯ|8^FE c{BG7KW"#S"/BR%jv;R%Tx|lv-P /P@7B=0^]'R.jE1SEȭP:}c[ S5**m X׉[W0$un|4|P+8pԠƓmD`,p{5ʓ,Ƥvշ,&482ʳ uXZPkҦFg#Vgbj;RIz:~`&;-0'Pʹe*]HB f )CPH! UH!b)/-,.^u IENDB`DyK yK rhttp://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=homeDyK yK http://www.sundancechannel.com/thegoodfight/projects/toxic_tour?video=230324329DyK yK 6http://www.thewartapes.comDyK yK http://www.ted.com/talks/deborah_scranton_on_her_war_tapes.htmlDyK yK lhttp://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/arp/argyris.html!DyK yK http://mets2006.wordpress.com/2007/09/29/inquiry-teams-can-the-department-mandate-innovation-and-creativity-will-the-lure-of-merit-pay-and-the-fear-of-denial-of-tenure-foster-collegiality-does-trust-preceed-inquiry/DyK yK nhttp://schools.nyc.gov/Teachers/Spotlight/iqtps48m.htmZ$$IfP!vh5$#v$:V $5$/ 4 agTk$$IfP!vh5X5#vX#v:V %5X5/ 4 agTp$$IfP!vh5X5#vX#v:V %5X5/ 4 agTk$$IfP!vh5X5#vX#v:V %5X5/ 4 agTk$$IfP!vh5X5#vX#v:V %5X5/ 4 agT666666666vvvvvvvvv666666>66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666hH6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666662 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p8XV~_HmH nH sH tH <`< NormalCJ_HmH sH tH P@P  Heading 1$<@&5CJ KH OJQJN@N  Heading 2$<@&56CJOJQJLL  Heading 3$<@&5CJOJQJH@H  Heading 4$ h@&`h5B@B  Heading 5$7$8$@&H$5>@>  Heading 6$$@&a$58@8  Heading 7$@&>*HH  Heading 8$0@&^`05F F  Heading 9 $$@&^a$5DA`D Default Paragraph FontVi@V  Table Normal :V 44 la (k (No List <B@<  Body Text $1$a$hJCJ Body Text Indent$v`va$8@8 Header  !CJ6U@!6 Hyperlink >*B*ph4 @24 Footer  !>PB> Body Text 2 CJOJQJeR HTML Preformatted7 2( Px 4 #\'*.25@9 CJOJ QJ NYbN  Document Map-D M OJ QJ VRrV Body Text Indent 2$0^`0a$HS@H Body Text Indent 3 ^@V@ FollowedHyperlink>*B* jj :! Table Grid7:V0.)@. A0 Page Number<< OhBody Text CharCJh:o: "8 Hyperlink1 >*CJph2PK![Content_Types].xmlj0 u$Nwc$ans@8JbVKS(.Y$8MVgLYS]"(U֎_o[gv; f>KH|;\XV!]օ Oȥsh]Hg3߶PK!֧6 _rels/.relsj0 }Q%v/C/}(h"O = C?hv=Ʌ%[xp{۵_Pѣ<1H0ORBdJE4b$q_6LR7`0̞O,En7Lib/SeеPK!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xml M @}w7c(EbˮCAǠҟ7՛K Y, e.|,H,lxɴIsQ}#Ր ֵ+!,^$j=GW)E+& 8PK!\theme/theme/theme1.xmlYOoE#F{o'NDuر i-q;N3' G$$DAč*iEP~wq4;{o?g^;N:$BR64Mvsi-@R4Œ mUb V*XX! cyg$w.Q "@oWL8*Bycjđ0蠦r,[LC9VbX*x_yuoBL͐u_. DKfN1엓:+ۥ~`jn[Zp֖zg,tV@bW/Oټl6Ws[R?S֒7 _כ[֪7 _w]ŌShN'^Bxk_[dC]zOլ\K=.:@MgdCf/o\ycB95B24S CEL|gO'sקo>W=n#p̰ZN|ӪV:8z1f؃k;ڇcp7#z8]Y / \{t\}}spķ=ʠoRVL3N(B<|ݥuK>P.EMLhɦM .co;əmr"*0#̡=6Kր0i1;$P0!YݩjbiXJB5IgAФ޲a6{P g֢)҉-Ìq8RmcWyXg/u]6Q_Ê5H Z2PU]Ǽ"GGFbCSOD%,p 6ޚwq̲R_gJSbj9)ed(w:/ak;6jAq11_xzG~F<:ɮ>O&kNa4dht\?J&l O٠NRpwhpse)tp)af] 27n}mk]\S,+a2g^Az )˙>E G鿰L7)'PK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 /_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!\theme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] G )X"'+-2 696>`A_GO2=@ACEGJKMOPRTVX ? { s!#',#1y6c: ?CcGHJKOO3456789:;<>?BDFHILNQSUWYZ[\] B i 2 n L  N,y !%!!!0"###=$?$@$$$%*c**,,-- .C.B1111(2a2{22(3783888<9;a;;<=>>>?GXXXXXXXXXXXCXXXXXXXXXTXXX !!8@(  bB  c $D>"?B S  ?GD%t _Hlt30523856 _Hlt24613733 _Hlt208461769 _Hlt50697608 _Hlt125469404 _Hlt209084295 _Hlt189896500` b cGU|*G@@@@@@@a c dHV}*GGG    L   ! z*+OU^gFNYabiJP}5;AHZbhns{<BV[  % '!)!,!!1"3"<"="A"""$$%%%% %%%4&:&&&&&''''))))**z.)2a22(3k34#44444555569X:=?FFGGGGGG"kt*-} -dkTzt o67[]t)WVYDGYP Q a!h!!!#V#p%v%b&&''..."/,9http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home]b>,RFOtype]W99http://www.researchfororganizing.org/index.php?page=home]  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry Ff6Data _Y1Table1WordDocument"SummaryInformation(8DocumentSummaryInformation8@ CompObj` F Microsoft Word 97-2004 DocumentNB6WWord.Document.8