ࡱ> jli#` .)bjbj Nh \\\\$ 2 2 2P\2D2D"L,23XX3X3X3444KKKKKKK$0MhOK:44::K\\X3X34K===:\X3\lX3J=:K==yG\,QIX32 rl 2W;vH,JK0L%I,P;6PXQIPQI4H5=6~7K444KK=444L::::"""D 2""" 2tT\\\\\\  SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK WESLEY VAUGHN, Plaintiff, vs. JAMES A. NICHOLS, Deputy Superintendent of Programs (Mid-State); GLENN S. GOORD, Commissioner (D.O.C.S.); ROBERT PROSSER, Maintenance Supervisor (Mid-State); MR. ABBIS, Vocational Supervisor (Mid-State); WILFREDO BATISTA, First Deputy Superintendent (Mid-State); DONALD SELSKY, Director of Special Housing/Inmate Disciplinary Programs (D.O.C.S.); in their individual capacities as personnel of the Department of Correctional Services (D.O.C.S.), Defendants.  Civil Action No. 9:02-CV-1512-LES/GJD  PLAINTIFFS PRE-TRIAL MEMORANDUM OF LAW HISCOCK & BARCLAY, LLP Office and Post Office Address One Park Place 300 South State Street Syracuse, NewYork 13221-4878 Telephone: (315)425-2836 Gabriel M. Nugent Facsimile: (315)703-7361 of Counsel E-Mail: gnugent@hiscockbarclay.com INTRODUCTION Plaintiff Wesley Vaughn (Plaintiff) submits this pre-trial memorandum of law pursuant to the Courts order of August 22, 2006. The issue to be resolved at the trial of this matter is whether Plaintiffs constitutionally protected right to petition the government for redress of grievances was violated at the Mid-State Correctional Facility in March 2002. Plaintiff alleges that defendants James A. Nichols, Glenn S. Goord, Robert Prosser, Mr. Abbis, Wilfredo Batista, Donald Selsky (collectively, Defendants), deprived him of his right to petition the government for redress of grievances by (a) removing him from his position as a law clerk, and (b) filing a false misbehavior report against the plaintiff because the plaintiff assisted another inmate with a grievance. Plaintiff commenced this action by filing a Summons and Complaint on December 5, 2002. He filed an Amended Complaint on January 2, 2003, alleging that Defendants violated (1) his First Amendment right to petition the government for redress of his grievances (Counts I and II), and (2) his Fourteenth Amendment rights to procedural and substantive due process and equal protection (Counts III and IV). Defendants filed a motion for summary judgment dismissing all of Plaintiffs claims on May 28, 2004. On November 8, 2004, this Court granted Defendants motion in part and denied it in part. The Court denied Defendants motion for summary judgment dismissing Plaintiffs claims (Counts I and II) based upon the Plaintiffs allegation of (a) his removal from his position as a law clerk, and (b) the filing a false misbehavior report against the plaintiff because the plaintiff assisted another inmate with a grievance. The Court also denied that portion of the Defendants motion to dismiss the Amended Complaint based on the defense of qualified immunity. The Court, however, dismissed the Plaintiffs claims based on the Fourteenth Amendment (Counts III and IV). POINT I STANDARD FOR PROVING A RETALIATION CLAIM A plaintiff alleging a retaliation claim under 42 U.S.C. 1983 must demonstrate that (1) the activity in question was protected by the First Amendment, and (2) that the defendants conduct was in response to that protected activity. Dawes v. Walker, 239 F.3d 489, 492 (2d Cir. 2001); Hynes v. Squillace, 143 F.3d 653, 657 (2d Cir. 1998), cert. denied, 525 U.S. 907 (1998); Graham v. Henderson, 89 F.3d 75, 79 (2d Cir. 1996); Jackson v. Johnson, 118 F. Supp. 2d 278, 291-92 (N.D.N.Y. 2000); Gaston v. Coughlin, 81 F. Supp. 2d 381, 386 (N.D.N.Y. 1999). Once a prima facie showing is made by the plaintiff, a defendant may avoid liability by demonstrating by a fair preponderance of the credible evidence that it had proper reasons for acting adversely against the plaintiff. Hynes, 143 F.3d at 657; Graham 89 F.3d at 79; Gaston, 81 F. Supp. 2d at 386; Jackson, 118 F. Supp. 2d at 292. Plaintiff intends to establish at trial that Defendants retaliated against him for assisting another inmate in connection with a grievance by (a) removing from his position as a law clerk, and (b) filing a false misbehavior report against him. Such conduct states claim under Section 1983. See Franco v. Kelly, 854 F.2d 584, 589-590 (2d Cir. 1998). Defendants assert that Plaintiffs removal from his position as a law clerk was based on suspicion that he was using the law library copy machine to copy gambling sheets. Plaintiff intends to prove at trial that these allegations simply are not credible. Significantly, Defendants never advised Plaintiff of their improper copying suspicions and never produced any information to corroborate that claim until during this lawsuit. Defendants also assert that the misbehavior report was issued to Plaintiff because of alleged violent conduct. However, the misbehavior report was administratively reversed. Accordingly, Plaintiff submits that Defendants cannot meet their burden of proving that they acted properly in removing Plaintiff from his law clerk position and issuing the misbehavior report. POINT II QUALIFIED IMMUNITY Qualified immunity is an affirmative defense that must be pleaded and proven by a defendant. Tellier v. Fields, 230 F.3d 511, 515 (2d Cir. 2000). Qualified immunity protects prison officials from personal liability [for damages] under 1983 when their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known. Walker v. McClellan, 126 F.3d 127, 129 (2d Cir. 1997) (quoting Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800, 818 (1982). Defendants qualified immunity defense fails because Plaintiffs retaliation claim relates to the clearly established constitutional free speech right to petition the government for redress of grievances. Franco, 854 F.2d at 589. Further, there is no question that, as prison officials, the Defendants should have known that their actions would violate Plaintiffs rights. Luna v. Pico, 356 F.3d 481, 490 (2d Cir. 2004); Stephenson v. Doe, 332, F.3d 68, 78 (2d Cir. 2003). Accordingly, Defendants will be unable to establish that they are entitled to qualified immunity. IN LIMINE MOTION POINT III DEFENDANTS SHOULD BE PRECLUDED FROM OFFERING ANY EVIDENCE REGARDING PLAINTIFFS CONVICTIONS, OR ANY UNRELATED DISCIPLINARY MATTERS The Federal Rules of Evidence permit the impeachment of a witness by prior convictions punishable in excess of one year. See Fed. R. Evid. 609(a). If more than ten years has lapsed since the conviction or the release from confinement for the conviction, the evidence is not admissible unless the probative value substantially outweighs prejudicial effect. Fed. R. Evid. 609(b). In Zinman v. Black & Decker, Inc., 983 F.2d 431, 434 (2d Cir. 1993), the Second Circuit stated that a conviction outside of the ten year window should be admitted very rarely and only in exceptional circumstances. Plaintiffs three criminal convictions, all drug-related offenses, are more than ten years old and have no relevance to this matter. Accordingly, Defendants should not be permitted to offer evidence concerning Plaintiffs convictions. Additionally, Defendants should likewise be precluded from offering any evidence regarding any separate and unrelated disciplinary matters against Plaintiff. Under Rule 404(b) of the Federal Rules of Evidence, [e]vidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts is not admissible to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity therewith. Fed. R. Evid. 404(b). Thus, evidence concerning any prior and unrelated disciplinary actions involving Plaintiff cannot be used by the Defendants to support their allegations against Plaintiff in this case. Accordingly, Plaintiff requests that the Court issue an Order precluding Defendants from mentioning or offering evidence concerning any unrelated disciplinary matters against Plaintiff. CONCLUSION For the reasons set forth herein, Plaintiff was the victim of improper retaliation for having exercised his constitutionally protected rights. DATED: October 23, 2006 Hiscock & Barclay, LLP By: s/Gabriel M. Nugent Gabriel M. Nugent (513947) Attorney for Plaintiff Wesley Vaughn One Park Place 300 South State Street Syracuse, New York 13221-4878 Telephone: (315) 425-2836 Facsimile: (315) 703-7361 Email: gnugent@hiscockbarclay.com   (..continued) PAGE  PAGE 2  DOCPROPERTY "Identifier1" \* MERGEFORMAT SYLIB01\525947\1  {H0854106.1} {H0854106.1}  PAGE 3 {H0854106.1}  PAGE 2 PR`afruxy6 7 < H I J M O P ` a b d e f h i u v x ~    ! % ( 1 9 < o y 篨稤砗hM?5>*@haChM? h6hA heHhA 5hhA 5 hhA hsShA h5V;hA 5 hA 6hFhA 6 hA 5hA hFhA 5jhFhA 5U93QRabqrxy7 8 H I J K L M N O P a $$1$Ifa$gdA $$1$If`a$gdA $$1$Ifa$gdA $1$IfgdA x1$gdA 1$gdA h())-)a v w x y z { | } QLLLLLgdA kd$$IflF`$Vv t06    44 la $$1$Ifa$gdA $$1$If`a$gdA } ~  & B n - d@&`gdn $d@&a$d] 8gdA 8BgdA 8BgdA ^gdA $a$gdA gdA  , - M N S b m x       5  .>?1EFGRavL]pqNQƽͷ߱߱߱߱߷߷߱߱߱߫߫ h|X@ h 1@ hY@ hn5h 1 hnhn hn@ h[@ hTu{@ haC@ h;@ hB@ hM?@haC5>*@B- GHQz{Qt}b c $@&a$ d`gdR $da$ $da$gdd` d`gd8#$a$ $d@&a$ d@&`gd 1 d@&`gdn3FGHIQfhz{fu&8FGgy"CxyʺҺҶʲҮҪҦҖҦhYh8#hY6hkGhaC6hkGh=h ?sh:|hlEh8#h8#6hlEhaC6h8#hYhaC h7v5>* haC5>* haC5 hY5 hY@ haC@ hlE@9*|)2QtRst}$%&Hx hR hR 0J_>*B*aJph#hR hR 0J_6>*B*aJph hR aJhR hR aJhR hR CJhhaC6 haC6h haC5>* haC5h ?shYh*(h$o6h*(h$ohYhKhkGhkGhaC6haC-HIJQRfhqvyQWi+<^    / 򸴰}x}xsnsxs h65 hw{5 haC5 hw{haChaC56>*h6hR 6h6h6h66h:|h hhhaC6haChhR hR hR 0J_>*B*aJph#hR hR 0J_6>*B*aJphhR hR 6aJhR hR aJhR 0J_>*B*aJph'/ ? B C L a b !!!!"$"%"&"9"""">####$%%I%%C&c&|&&&&&'3'4'9'L'b'c'd'g'h'j'{'~'㼵㩥~ hA 6>*h24hA 6>* h hA hA >*h hA 5;hA h"}hA 5h hB:haC haC5>*hFhhNs hw{hB:h\AhB:haC6haC haC>*hw{haC5>*hw{hw{5>*1c #&&&4'L'c'd'''''''''()(C(e( $IfgdA `$IfgdA $IfgdA dgdA  vpd`gd $ vpa$ d`gdw{~''''d(e(f(g(h(i(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((()))) ) )¼¼¼±¼С̒СЇ¼zhq-0JmHnHu*h0`h0`0JCJh0`h0`0J! hq-0J! h0`0J!jh0`0J!Uh0`0JmHnHu h0`0Jjh0`0JUhq-h0`jh0`UhaC hUhA hfhA hA 6hA h24hA >*,e(f(g(h(j(k(y(z({(|(~((((((((d  vpgdA @kd$$Iflt(# t644 la $IfgdA ((((((((((((() ) ))')()))*)+),)-) &#$gdq-  Hh]hh]h&`#$ ) ) ) ))))))#)$)%)&)')())),).)ɸhaChq-0JmHnHu h0`0Jjh0`0JU h0`0J! hq-0J!h0`h0`0J!h0`h0`0J!CJjh0`0JU*-).)  vpgdA I....()()))()() 000&P1P/R 8$:pFBP/ =!"#$% I....()()))()() 000&P1P/R 8$:pFBP/ =!"#p$% $$If!vh5V5v5 #vV#vv#v :V^l t65V5v5 / / / $$If!vh5#v:V^l t065aa@@@ NormalCJ_HhmH sH tH PP Heading 1 & F x@&^KHNN Heading 2" & F 8x@&^NN Heading 3" & F ppx@&^pNN Heading 4" & F  @ @ x@&^@ LL Heading 5  & F x@&^LL Heading 6 & F xx@&^LL Heading 7  & F x@&^LL Heading 8 & F x@&^N N Heading 9" & F PPx@&^PDA@D Default Paragraph FontVi@V  Table Normal :V 44 la (k(No List 4B@4 Body Text$a$L>L Title$$$@&a$5>*@KHll Memo Headings7 `0 `xx*$^``zz Memo Heading Last= `0 `xx&d*$^``4@24 Header  !8 @B8 Footer  !CJ2)@Q2 Page NumberCJ>'a> Comment ReferenceCJ8r8  Comment TextCJDTD Block Textx]^\$\ Envelope Address!@ &+D/^@ >%> Envelope ReturnCJ@V@ FollowedHyperlink>*B* 0U0 Hyperlink>*B*: : Index 1^`:!:  Index Heading5:.:  TOA Headingx5.. TOC 2 ^2O2 IDSmall CJOJQJ<P"< Body Text 2 "dx:Q2: Body Text 3#xCJTMBT Body Text First Indent$`NCRN Body Text Indent%$^a$ZNQbZ Body Text First Indent 2&$`a$XRrX Body Text Indent 2'$d^a$PSP Body Text Indent 3(hx^hCJ6"6 Caption )xx52?2 Closing *^$L$ Date+@Y@  Document Map,-D OJQJ8+8  Endnote Text-CJ::  Footnote Text.CJ: : Index 2/^`: : Index 30^`: : Index 41^`:: Index 52^`:: Index 63^`:: Index 74^`:: Index 85^`:: Index 96p^p`4/r4 List7h^h`828 List 28^`838 List 398^8`848 List 4:^`858 List 5;^`:0: List Bullet < & F>6> List Bullet 2 = & F>7> List Bullet 3 > & F>8> List Bullet 4 ? & F>9> List Bullet 5 @ & F BDB List ContinueAhx^hFE"F List Continue 2Bx^FF2F List Continue 3C8x^8FGBF List Continue 4Dx^FHRF List Continue 5Ex^:1b: List Number F & F>:r> List Number 2 G & F>;> List Number 3 H & F><> List Number 4 I & F >=> List Number 5 J & F l-l  Macro Text"K  ` @ OJQJ_HhmH sH tH lIl Message Header.L8$d%d&d'd-D^8`OJQJ>> Normal Indent M^4O4 Note HeadingN<Z< Plain TextO CJOJQJ0K0 SalutationP6@6 Signature Q^DJ"D SubtitleR$$$x@&a$5T,T Table of AuthoritiesS^`L#L Table of FiguresT ^` && TOC 1U.. TOC 3 V^.. TOC 4 W^.. TOC 5 X^.. TOC 6 Y^.. TOC 7 Z^.. TOC 8 [^.. TOC 9 \^hh Quote - 1" indent Left & Right]]^j@j A Table Grid7:V^0^6O6 R Hyperlink6 >*ph3H@H q- Balloon Text`CJOJQJ^JaJ.!.! L KM !z!z !z!z!z!z!z I cdf .!C33QRabqrxy78HIJKLMNOPavwxyz{|}~&B-GQ z { Qt}bc4Lcd ) C e g ! !!/!$$~~~~~~~ ~~~~         {5$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$Y$4 $o%$$*$$${5$id$!0$Y$Y$;-@$$$$$$$!0$*$$$4 $Y$$$$$^$^^$$^$3QRabqrxy78HIJKLMNOPavwxyz{|}~&Bn-GH Q z { Qt}bc4Lcd ) C e f g h j k y z { | ~  ! ! !!'!(!)!/!0 000000000000 0 000000000 00000000000000000000000.0.0.0.0000000000000000000000000000000000000 0 00 '0 '0 '0 '0 '0 '0 '0 '0 '0 '0 k'00  p0p0p0p0p0p0p0 $l'00p000p  0000)xz H/ ~' ).)!$a } - c e((-).) "#%-).! %)024`r!!TU!!@  @H 0( "  0(  B S  ?_F4`Ff^Fft^FUEBClY'VEBCl_WEBC,_i(_'l_l(_'l_e(_['l_A(_ ,_!_"_#_oEBC_\'_pEBC_qEBC_ll; /!     %%+ ppK   /! B *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagscountry-region:*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsStreet>*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PostalCode9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsState8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsdate;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsaddress9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity Y 10111220022004200622232858DayMonthYear           h ! ! ! ! !!!&!)!,!/!"^#h )!/!:::::::: sttddg h ! ! ! ! !!!!!&!/!h )!/!|wBJ}I~=FJFp;<@ TLq*C;6ǴTGffGTO^* @b6d8$Ald`]Ut21^`.^`.88^8`.^`. ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( 88^8`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(hh^h`. hh^h`OJQJo(hh^h`o(()0^`00^`0.p0p^p`0.@ 0@ ^@ `0.0^`0()0^`0()0^`0)0^`0)P0P^P`0)0^`0o(()88^8`o(()0^`0o(()^`.8^`.^`()p ^p`()@ ^@ `()x^`()^`()^`()^`()88^8`o(()0^`0o(. 0^`0o(()TLq~}|^$AldffGTG@b]Ut;6@ ,+[8#=Ns A  1;*(;+'-B:\AlEU_M|X h ?sgu7vTu{w{:|0`aCYkGnK6q-{BFdM?R ^."F$oY3QIJwx~ny 4Lf g /!a0a0 AllPagesIdentifierAllPagesSaveDateLastPageIdentifierLastPageSaveDateEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty@.!@UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial5& zaTahoma?5 z Courier New" ,& ,& ,&22#pduV2qHX?aC27C:\Program Files\Microsoft Office\Templates\hnb_gen.dotTrial memo 3 (H0854106.DOC;1) H0854106.1GNUGENTBobbi J. PabonX              Oh+'0 ( H T ` lx Trial memo 3 (H0854106.DOC;1) H0854106.1GNUGENT hnb_gen.dotBobbi J. Pabon2Microsoft Office Word@@k]@k]@k]՜.+,D՜.+,` px  TechLaw2 Trial memo 3 (H0854106.DOC;1) Title P!19Im Identifier1Pref_AdHocReviewCycleID_EmailSubject _AuthorEmail_AuthorEmailDisplayName_ReviewingToolsShownOnceSYLIB01\525947\1 L000ϫrFormsgnugent@hiscockbarclay.comNugent, Gabriel M.  !"#$%&')*+,-./123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXZ[\]^_`bcdefghkRoot Entry FlmData (1Table0QWordDocumentNSummaryInformation(YDocumentSummaryInformation8aCompObjq  FMicrosoft Office Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q