ࡱ> 7 bjbjUU ʞ7|7|Nl2222  PMPMPMOO zRSXTXTnT-b-b-b$s&s&s&s;as`v`!z$| ~Ez -bY_-b-b-bEz?k22XTnT Zz?k?k?k-b2XT nT$s?k-b$s?k?kWrr[ snTR @g3m BPMb*rs$pz0zr"!j"s?k 2222University of Technology School of Business Administration Corporate Finance Tutorial #1 Capital Budgeting: Other topics Chapter 12 - SOLUTIONs 12-4 Expected NPV = (0.3)(-$10,800) + (0.5)($23,400) + (0.2)($50,400) = -$3,240 + $11,700 + $10,080 = $18,540. Since NPV is stated in thousands, E(NPV) = $18,540,000. (NPV = [(0.3)(-$10,800 - $18,540)2 + (0.5)($23,400 - $18,540)2 + (0.2)($50,400 - $18,540)2] = [$258,250,680 + $11,809,800 + $203,011,920] = $21,750.23. Since NPV is stated in thousands (NPV = $21,750,227.59.  EMBED Equation.3  12-5 E(NPV) = 0.05(-$70) + 0.20(-$25) + 0.50($12) + 0.20($20) + 0.05($30) = -$3.5 + -$5.0 + $6.0 + $4.0 + $1.5 = $3.0 million. (NPV = [0.05(-$70 - $3)2 + 0.02(-$25 - $3)2 + 0.50($12 - $3)2 + 0.20($20 - $3)2 + 0.05($30 - $3)2] = $23.622 million.  EMBED Equation.3  12-6 a. 0 1 2 3 4 5 Initial investment ($250,000) Net oper. WC (25,000) Cost savings $ 90,000 $ 90,000 $ 90,000 $ 90,000 $ 90,000 Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. inc. before taxes $ 7,500 ($ 22,500) $ 52,500 $ 72,500 $ 90,000 Taxes (40%) 3,000 (9,000) 21,000 29,000 36,000 Oper. Inc. (AT) $ 4,500 ($ 13,500) $ 31,500 $ 43,500 $ 54,000 Add: Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. CF $ 87,000 $ 99,000 $ 69,000 $ 61,000 $ 54,000 Return of NOWC $25,000 Sale of Machine 23,000 Tax on sale (40%) (9,200) Net cash flow ($275,000) $ 87,000 $ 99,000 $ 69,000 $ 61,000 $ 92,800 NPV = $37,035.13 Notes: a Depreciation Schedule, Basis = $250,000 MACRS Rate ( Basis = Year Beg. Bk. Value MACRS Rate Depreciation Ending BV 1 $250,000 0.33 $ 82,500 $167,500 2 167,500 0.45 112,500 55,000 3 55,000 0.15 37,500 17,500 4 17,500 0.07 17,500 0 $250,000 b. If savings increase by 20 percent, then savings will be (1.2)($90,000) = $108,000. If savings decrease by 20 percent, then savings will be (0.8)($90,000) = $72,000. (1) Savings increase by 20%: 0 1 2 3 4 5 Initial investment ($250,000) Net oper. WC (25,000) Cost savings $108,000 $108,000 $108,000 $108,000 $108,000 Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. inc. before taxes $ 25,500 ($ 4,500) $ 70,500 $ 90,500 $108,000 Taxes (40%) 10,200 (1,800) 28,200 36,200 43,200 Oper. Inc. (AT) $ 15,300 ($ 2,700) $ 42,300 $ 54,300 $ 64,800 Add: Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. CF $ 97,800 $109,800 $ 79,800 $ 71,800 $ 64,800 Return of NOWC $25,000 Sale of Machine 23,000 Tax on sale (40%) (9,200) Net cash flow ($275,000) $ 97,800 $109,800 $ 79,800 $ 71,800 $103,600 NPV = $77,975.63 (2) Savings decrease by 20%: 0 1 2 3 4 5 Initial investment ($250,000) Net oper. WC (25,000) Cost savings $ 72,000 $ 72,000 $ 72,000 $ 72,000 $ 72,000 Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. inc. before taxes ($ 10,500)($ 40,500) $ 34,500 $ 54,500 $ 72,000 Taxes (40%) (4,200) (16,200) 13,800 21,800 28,800 Oper. Inc. (AT) ($ 6,300)($ 24,300) $ 20,700 $ 32,700 $ 43,200 Add: Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. CF $ 76,200 $ 88,200 $ 58,200 $ 50,200 $ 43,200 Return of NOWC $25,000 Sale of Machine 23,000 Tax on sale (40%) (9,200) Net cash flow ($275,000) $ 76,200 $ 88,200 $ 58,200 $ 50,200 $ 82,000 NPV = -$3,905.37 c. Worst-case scenario: 0 1 2 3 4 5 Initial investment ($250,000) Net oper. WC (30,000) Cost savings $ 72,000 $ 72,000 $ 72,000 $ 72,000 $ 72,000 Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. inc. before taxes ($ 10,500)($ 40,500) $ 34,500 $ 54,500 $ 72,000 Taxes (40%) (4,200) (16,200) 13,800 21,800 28,800 Oper. Inc. (AT) ($ 6,300)($ 24,300) $ 20,700 $ 32,700 $ 43,200 Add: Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. CF $ 76,200 $ 88,200 $ 58,200 $ 50,200 $ 43,200 Return of NOWC $30,000 Sale of Machine 18,000 Tax on sale (40%) (7,200) Net cash flow ($280,000) $ 76,200 $ 88,200 $ 58,200 $ 50,200 $ 84,000 NPV = -$7,663.52 Base-case scenario: This was worked out in part a. NPV = $37,035.13. Best-case scenario: 0 1 2 3 4 5 Initial investment ($250,000) Net oper. WC ( 20,000) Cost savings $108,000 $108,000 $108,000 $108,000 $108,000 Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. inc. before taxes $ 25,500 ($ 4,500) $ 70,500 $ 90,500 $108,000 Taxes (40%) 10,200 (1,800) 28,200 36,200 43,200 Oper. Inc. (AT) $ 15,300 ($ 2,700) $ 42,300 $ 54,300 $ 64,800 Add: Depreciation 82,500 112,500 37,500 17,500 0 Oper. CF $ 97,800 $109,800 $ 79,800 $ 71,800 $ 64,800 Return of NOWC $20,000 Sale of Machine 28,000 Tax on sale (40%) (11,200) Net cash flow ($270,000) $ 97,800 $109,800 $ 79,800 $ 71,800 $101,600 NPV = $81,733.79 Prob. NPV Prob. ( NPV Worst-case 0.35 ($ 7,663.52) ($ 2,682.23) Base-case 0.35 37,035.13 12,962.30 Best-case 0.30 81,733.79 24,520.14 E(NPV) $34,800.21 (NPV = [(0.35)(-$7,663.52 - $34,800.21)2 + (0.35)($37,035.13 - $34,800.21)2 + (0.30)($81,733.79 - $34,800.21)2] (NPV = [$631,108,927.93 + $1,748,203.59 + $660,828,279.49] (NPV = $35,967.84. CV = $35,967.84/$34,800.21 = 1.03. *Tax on SV = ($60,000 - $11,900)(0.4) = $19,240. d. The project has an NPV of ($19,549). Thus, it should not be accepted. Year Net Cash Flow PV @ 12% 0 ($178,000) ($178,000) 1 52,440 46,821 2 60,600 48,310 3 88,960 63,320 NPV = ($ 19,549) Alternatively, place the cash flows on a time line:  0 1 2 3  | | | | -178,000 52,440 60,600 40,200 48,760 88,960 With a financial calculator, input the appropriate cash flows into the cash flow register, input I = 12, and then solve for NPV = -$19,549. 12-9 a. Expected annual cash flows: Project A: Probable Probability Cash Flow = Cash Flow 0.2 $6,000 $1,200 0.6 6,750 4,050 0.2 7,500 1,500 Expected annual cash flow = $6,750 Project B: Probable Probability Cash Flow = Cash Flow 0.2 $ 0 $ 0 0.6 6,750 4,050 0.2 18,000 3,600 Expected annual cash flow = $7,650 Coefficient of variation:  EMBED Equation.3  Project A:  EMBED Equation.3  Project B:  EMBED Equation.3  CVA = $474.34/$6,750 = 0.0703. CVB = $5,797.84/$7,650 = 0.7579. b. Project B is the riskier project because it has the greater variability in its probable cash flows, whether measured by the standard deviation or the coefficient of variation. Hence, Project B is evaluated at the 12 percent cost of capital, while Project A requires only a 10 percent cost of capital. NPVA = $6,750(PVIFA10%,3) - $6,750 = $6,750(2.4869) - $6,750 = $16,786.58 - $6,750 = $10,036.58 ( $10,037. Alternatively, with a financial calculator, input the appropriate cash flows into the cash flow register, input I = 10, and then solve for NPV = $10,036.25. NPVB = $7,650(PVIFA12%,3) - $6,750 = $7,650(2.4018) - $6,750 = $18,373.77 - $6,750 = $11,623.77 ( $11,624. Alternatively, with a financial calculator, input the appropriate cash flows into the cash flow register, input I = 12, and then solve for NPV = $11,624.01. Project B has the higher NPV; therefore, the firm should accept Project B. c. The portfolio effects from Project B would tend to make it less risky than otherwise. This would tend to reinforce the decision to accept Project B. Again, if Project B were negatively correlated with the GDP (Project B is profitable when the economy is down), then it is less risky and Project B's acceptance is reinforced. 12-10 If actual life is 5 years: Amount Amount Year PV before after Event Factor tax tax Occurs at 10% PV Outflows: Investment in new equipment $36,000 $36,000 0 1.0 $36,000 Total PV of outflows $36,000 Inflows: Pre-tax operating cash flows $12,000 $ 7,200 1-5 3.7908 $27,294 Depreciation 7,200 2,880 1-5 3.7908 10,918 $38,212 NPV = PV(Inflows) - PV(Outflows) = $38,212 - $36,000 = $2,212. Alternatively, using a time line approach:  0 1 2 3 4 5  | | | | | | Investment outlay (36,000) Operating cash flows excl. deprec. (AT) 7,200 7,200 7,200 7,200 7,200 Depreciation savings 2,880 2,880 2,880 2,880 2,880 Net cash flow (36,000) 10,080 10,080 10,080 10,080 10,080 NPV10% = $2,211.13. If actual life is 4 years: Amount Amount Year PV before after Event Factor tax tax Occurs at 10% PV Inflows: Revenues $12,000 $7,200 1-4 3.1699 $22,823 Depreciation 7,200 2,880 1-4 3.1699 9,129 Tax savings on loss at end of Year 4 7,200 2,880 4 0.6830 1,967 $33,919 NPV = $33,919 - $36,000 = -$2,081. Alternatively, using a time line approach:  0 1 2 3 4  | | | | | Investment outlay (36,000) Operating cash flows excl. deprec. (AT) 7,200 7,200 7,200 7,200 Depreciation savings 2,880 2,880 2,880 2,880 Tax savings on loss 2,880 Net cash flow (36,000) 10,080 10,080 10,080 12,960 NPV10% = -$2,080.68. If actual life is 8 years: Amount Amount Year PV before after Event Factor tax tax Occurs at 10% PV Inflows: Revenues $12,000 $7,200 1-8 5.3349 $38,411 Depreciation 7,200 2,880 1-5 3.7908 10,918 $49,329 NPV = $49,329 - $36,000 = $13,329. Alternatively, using a time line approach: 0 1 5 6 7 8  | | ( ( ( | | | | Investment outlay (36,000) Operating cash flows excl. deprec. (AT) 7,200 7,200 7,200 7,200 7,200 Depreciation savings 2,880 2,880 Net cash flow (36,000) 10,080 10,080 7,200 7,200 7,200 NPV10% = $13,328.93. If the life is as low as 4 years (an unlikely event), the investment will not be desirable. But, if the investment life is longer than 4 years, the investment will be a good one. Therefore, the decision will depend on the directors' confidence in the life of the tractor. Given the low proba-bility of the tractor's life being only 4 years, it is likely that the directors will decide to purchase the tractor. INTEGRATED CASE Allied Food Products Capital Budgeting and Cash Flow Estimation 12-13 AFTER SEEING SNAPPLES SUCCESS WITH NONCOLA SOFT DRINKS AND LEARNING OF COKES AND PEPSIS INTEREST, ALLIED FOOD PRODUCTS HAS DECIDED TO CONSIDER AN EXPANSION OF ITS OWN IN THE FRUIT JUICE BUSINESS. THE PRODUCT BEING CONSIDERED IS FRESH LEMON JUICE. ASSUME THAT YOU WERE RECENTLY HIRED AS ASSISTANT TO THE DIRECTOR OF CAPITAL BUDGETING, AND YOU MUST EVALUATE THE NEW PROJECT. THE LEMON JUICE WOULD BE PRODUCED IN AN UNUSED BUILDING ADJACENT TO ALLIEDS FORT MYERS PLANT; ALLIED OWNS THE BUILDING, WHICH IS FULLY DEPRECIATED. THE REQUIRED EQUIPMENT WOULD COST $200,000, PLUS AN ADDITIONAL $40,000 FOR SHIPPING AND INSTALLATION. IN ADDITION, INVENTORIES WOULD RISE BY $25,000, WHILE ACCOUNTS PAYABLE WOULD GO UP BY $5,000. ALL OF THESE COSTS WOULD BE INCURRED AT t = 0. BY A SPECIAL RULING, THE MACHINERY COULD BE DEPRECIATED UNDER THE MACRS SYSTEM AS 3-YEAR PROPERTY. THE PROJECT IS EXPECTED TO OPERATE FOR 4 YEARS, AT WHICH TIME IT WILL BE TERMINATED. THE CASH INFLOWS ARE ASSUMED TO BEGIN 1 YEAR AFTER THE PROJECT IS UNDERTAKEN, OR AT t = 1, AND TO CONTINUE OUT TO t = 4. AT THE END OF THE PROJECTS LIFE (t = 4), THE EQUIPMENT IS EXPECTED TO HAVE A SALVAGE VALUE OF $25,000. UNIT SALES ARE EXPECTED TO TOTAL 100,000 CANS PER YEAR, AND THE EXPECTED SALES PRICE IS $2.00 PER CAN. CASH OPERATING COSTS FOR THE PROJECT (TOTAL OPERATING COSTS LESS DEPRECIATION) ARE EXPECTED TO TOTAL 60 PERCENT OF DOLLAR SALES. ALLIEDS TAX RATE IS 40 PERCENT, AND ITS WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL IS 10 PERCENT. TENTATIVELY, THE LEMON JUICE PROJECT IS ASSUMED TO BE OF EQUAL RISK TO ALLIEDS OTHER ASSETS. YOU HAVE BEEN ASKED TO EVALUATE THE PROJECT AND TO MAKE A RECOMMENDATION AS TO WHETHER IT SHOULD BE ACCEPTED OR REJECTED. TO GUIDE YOU IN YOUR ANALYSIS, YOUR BOSS GAVE YOU THE FOLLOWING SET OF QUESTIONS. TABLE IC12-1. ALLIEDS LEMON JUICE PROJECT (TOTAL COST IN THOUSANDS) END OF YEAR: 0 1 2 3 4 I. INVESTMENT OUTLAY EQUIPMENT COST INSTALLATION INCREASE IN INVENTORY INCREASE IN ACCOUNTS PAYABLE TOTAL NET INVESTMENT II. OPERATING CASH FLOWS UNIT SALES (THOUSANDS) 100 PRICE/UNIT $ 2.00 $ 2.00 TOTAL REVENUES $200.0 OPERATING COSTS, EXCLUDING DEPRECIATION $120.0 DEPRECIATION 36.0 16.8 TOTAL COSTS $199.2 $228.0 OPERATING INCOME BEFORE TAXES $ 44.0 TAXES ON OPERATING INCOME 0.3 25.3 OPERATING INCOME AFTER TAXES $ 26.4 DEPRECIATION 79.2 36.0 OPERATING CASH FLOW $ 0.0 $ 79.7 $ 54.7 III. TERMINAL YEAR CASH FLOWS RETURN OF NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL SALVAGE VALUE TAX ON SALVAGE VALUE TOTAL TERMINATION CASH FLOWS IV. NET CASH FLOWS NET CASH FLOW ADVANCE \l1($260.0) $ 89.7 V. RESULTS NPV = IRR = MIRR = PAYBACK = A. DRAW A TIME LINE THAT SHOWS WHEN THE NET CASH INFLOWS AND OUTFLOWS WILL OCCUR, AND EXPLAIN HOW THE TIME LINE CAN BE USED TO HELP STRUCTURE THE ANALYSIS. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-1 THROUGH S12-4 HERE.] 0 1 2 3 4  | | | | | CF0 ADVANCE \r1CF1 ADVANCE \r1ADVANCE \r1CF2 ADVANCE \r1ADVANCE \r2CF3 ADVANCE \r1ADVANCE \r1CF4 TIME LINES ARE HELPFUL FOR SHOWING WHERE CASH FLOWS OCCUR. WHEN THE DATA ARE DEVELOPED, AND NUMBERS HAVE BEEN PUT ON THE TIME LINE, IT FACILITATES INPUTTING THE CASH FLOWS INTO A CALCULATOR TO CALCULATE THE NPV, IRR, MIRR, AND PAYBACK. B. ALLIED HAS A STANDARD FORM THAT IS USED IN THE CAPITAL BUDGETING PROCESS; SEE TABLE IC12-1. PART OF THE TABLE HAS BEEN COMPLETED, BUT YOU MUST REPLACE THE BLANKS WITH THE MISSING NUMBERS. COMPLETE THE TABLE IN THE FOLLOWING STEPS: 1. FILL IN THE BLANKS UNDER YEAR 0 FOR THE INITIAL INVESTMENT OUTLAY. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-5 HERE.] THIS ANSWER IS STRAIGHTFORWARD. NOTE THAT ACCOUNTS PAYABLE IS AN OFFSET TO THE INVENTORY BUILDUP, SO THE NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL REQUIREMENT IS $20,000, WHICH WILL BE RECOVERED AT THE END OF THE PROJECTS LIFE. [SEE COMPLETED TABLE IN THE ANSWER TO B5.] B. 2. COMPLETE THE TABLE FOR UNIT SALES, SALES PRICE, TOTAL REVENUES, AND OPERATING COSTS EXCLUDING DEPRECIATION. ANSWER: THIS ANSWER REQUIRES NO EXPLANATION. STUDENTS MAY NOTE, THOUGH, THAT INFLATION IS NOT REFLECTED AT THIS POINT. IT WILL BE LATER. [THE COMPLETED TABLE IS SHOWN BELOW IN THE ANSWER TO B5.] B. 3. COMPLETE THE DEPRECIATION DATA. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-6 HERE.] THE ONLY THING THAT REQUIRES EXPLANATION HERE IS THE USE OF THE DEPRECIATION TABLES IN APPENDIX 12A. HERE ARE THE RATES FOR 3-YEAR PROPERTY; THEY ARE MULTIPLIED BY THE DEPRECIABLE BASIS, $240,000, TO GET THE ANNUAL DEPRECIATION ALLOWANCES: (DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS) YEAR 1 0.33 ( $240 = $ 79.2 YEAR 2 0.45 ( $240 = 108.0 YEAR 3 0.15 ( $240 = 36.0 YEAR 4 0.07 ( $240 = 16.8 1.00 $240.0 B. 4. NOW COMPLETE THE TABLE DOWN TO OPERATING INCOME AFTER TAXES, AND THEN DOWN TO NET CASH FLOWS. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-7 HERE.] THIS IS STRAIGHTFORWARD. THE ONLY EVEN SLIGHTLY COMPLICATED THING IS ADDING BACK DEPRECIATION TO GET NET CF. [THE COMPLETED TABLE IS SHOWN BELOW IN THE ANSWER TO B5.] B. 5. NOW FILL IN THE BLANKS UNDER YEAR 4 FOR THE TERMINATION CASH FLOWS, AND COMPLETE THE NET CASH FLOW LINE. DISCUSS NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL. WHAT WOULD HAVE HAPPENED IF THE MACHINERY WERE SOLD FOR LESS THAN ITS BOOK VALUE? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-8 HERE.] THESE ARE ALL STRAIGHTFORWARD. NOTE THAT THE NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL REQUIREMENT IS RECOVERED AT THE END OF YEAR 4. ALSO, THE SALVAGE VALUE IS FULLY TAXABLE, BECAUSE THE ASSET HAS BEEN DEPRECIATED TO A ZERO BOOK VALUE. IF BOOK VALUE WERE SOMETHING OTHER THAN ZERO, THE TAX EFFECT COULD BE POSITIVE (IF THE ASSET WERE SOLD FOR LESS THAN BOOK VALUE) OR NEGATIVE. TABLE IC12-1. ALLIEDS LEMON JUICE PROJECT (TOTAL COST IN THOUSANDS) INPUTS: PRICE: $2.00 k: 10.0% INFL: 0.0% VC RATE: 60.0% T-RATE: 40% END OF YEAR: 0 1 2 3 4 I. INVESTMENT OUTLAY EQUIPMENT COST ($200) INSTALLATION (40) INCREASE IN INVENTORY (25) INCREASE IN ACCOUNTS PAYABLE 5 TOTAL NET INVESTMENT (260) II. OPERATING CASH FLOWS UNIT SALES (THOUSANDS) 100 100 100 100 PRICE/UNIT $ 2.00 $ 2.00 $ 2.00 $ 2.00 TOTAL REVENUES $200.0 $200.0 $200.0 $200.0 OPERATING COSTS, EXCLUDING DEPRECIATION $120.0 $120.0 $120.0 $120.0 DEPRECIATION 79.2 108.0 36.0 16.8 TOTAL COSTS $199.2 $228.0 $156.0 $136.8 OPERATING INCOME BEFORE TAXES $ 0.8 ($ 28.0) $ 44.0 $ 63.2 TAXES ON OPERATING INCOME 0.3 (11.2) 17.6 25.3 OPERATING INCOME AFTER TAXES $ 0.5 ($ 16.8) $ 26.4 $ 37.9 DEPRECIATION 79.2 108.0 36.0 16.8 OPERATING CASH FLOW $ 0.0 $ 79.7 $ 91.2 $ 62.4 $ 54.7 III. TERMINAL YEAR CASH FLOWS RETURN OF NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL 20.0 SALVAGE VALUE 25.0 TAX ON SALVAGE VALUE (10.0) TOTAL TERMINATION CASH FLOWS $ 35.0 IV. NET CASH FLOWS NET CASH FLOW ADVANCE \l1($260.0) $ 79.7 $ 91.2 $ 62.4 $ 89.7 CUMULATIVE CASH FLOW FOR PAYBACK: (260.0) (180.3) (89.1) (26.7) 63.0 COMPOUNDED INFLOWS FOR MIRR: 106.1 110.4 68.6 89.7 TERMINAL VALUE OF INFLOWS: 374.8 V. RESULTS NPV = -$4.0 IRR = 9.3% MIRR = 9.6% PAYBACK = 3.3 YEARS C. 1. ALLIED USES DEBT IN ITS CAPITAL STRUCTURE, SO SOME OF THE MONEY USED TO FINANCE THE PROJECT WILL BE DEBT. GIVEN THIS FACT, SHOULD THE PROJECTED CASH FLOWS BE REVISED TO SHOW PROJECTED INTEREST CHARGES? EXPLAIN. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-9 HERE.] THE PROJECTED CASH FLOWS IN THE TABLE SHOULD NOT BE REVISED TO SHOW INTEREST CHARGES. THE EFFECTS OF DEBT FINANCING ARE REFLECTED IN THE COST OF CAPITAL, WHICH IS USED TO DISCOUNT THE CASH FLOWS. C. 2. SUPPOSE YOU LEARNED THAT ALLIED HAD SPENT $50,000 TO RENOVATE THE BUILDING LAST YEAR, EXPENSING THESE COSTS. SHOULD THIS COST BE REFLECTED IN THE ANALYSIS? EXPLAIN. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-10 HERE.] THIS EXPENDITURE IS A SUNK COST, HENCE IT WOULD NOT AFFECT THE DECISION AND SHOULD NOT BE INCLUDED IN THE ANALYSIS. C. 3. NOW SUPPOSE YOU LEARNED THAT ALLIED COULD LEASE ITS BUILDING TO ANOTHER PARTY AND EARN $25,000 PER YEAR. SHOULD THAT FACT BE REFLECTED IN THE ANALYSIS? IF SO, HOW? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-11 HERE.] THE RENTAL PAYMENT REPRESENTS AN OPPORTUNITY COST, AND AS SUCH ITS AFTER-TAX AMOUNT, $25,000(1 - T) = $25,000(0.6) = $15,000, SHOULD BE SUBTRACTED FROM THE CASH FLOWS THE COMPANY WOULD OTHERWISE HAVE. C. 4. NOW ASSUME THAT THE LEMON JUICE PROJECT WOULD TAKE AWAY PROFITABLE SALES FROM ALLIEDS FRESH ORANGE JUICE BUSINESS. SHOULD THAT FACT BE REFLECTED IN YOUR ANALYSIS? IF SO, HOW? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-12 HERE.] THE DECREASED SALES FROM ALLIEDS FRESH ORANGE JUICE BUSINESS SHOULD BE ACCOUNTED FOR IN THE ANALYSIS. THIS IS AN EXTERNALITY TO ALLIED--THE LEMON JUICE PROJECT WILL AFFECT THE CASH FLOWS TO ITS ORANGE JUICE BUSINESS. SINCE THE LEMON JUICE PROJECT WILL TAKE BUSINESS AWAY FROM ITS ORANGE JUICE BUSINESS, THE REVENUES AS SHOWN IN THIS ANALYSIS ARE OVERSTATED, AND THUS THEY NEED TO BE REDUCED BY THE AMOUNT OF DECREASED REVENUES FOR THE ORANGE JUICE BUSINESS. EXTERNALITIES ARE OFTEN DIFFICULT TO QUANTIFY, BUT THEY NEED TO BE CONSIDERED. D. DISREGARD ALL THE ASSUMPTIONS MADE IN PART C, AND ASSUME THERE WAS NO ALTERNATIVE USE FOR THE BUILDING OVER THE NEXT 4 YEARS. NOW CALCULATE THE PROJECTS NPV, IRR, MIRR, AND REGULAR PAYBACK. DO THESE INDICATORS SUGGEST THAT THE PROJECT SHOULD BE ACCEPTED? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-13 THROUGH S12-17 HERE.] WE REFER TO THE COMPLETED TIME LINE AND EXPLAIN HOW EACH OF THE INDICATORS IS CALCULATED. WE BASE OUR EXPLANATION ON FINANCIAL CALCULATORS, BUT IT WOULD BE EQUALLY EASY TO EXPLAIN USING A REGULAR CALCULATOR AND EITHER EQUATIONS OR TABLES.  0 1 2 3 4  | | | | | (260) 79.7 91.2 62.4 89.7 NPV = -$4.0. NPV IS NEGATIVE; DO NOT ACCEPT. IRR =  EMBED Equation.3  IRR = 9.3%. IRR IS LESS THAN COST OF CAPITAL; DO NOT ACCEPT. MIRR: 0 1 2 3 4  | | | | | (260) 79.7 91.2 62.4 89.7  68.6  ADVANCE \r1110.4  ADVANCE \r1 106.1  TERMINAL VALUE (TV) $374.8 PV OF TV $260 NPV $ 0 MIRR IS LESS THAN COST OF CAPITAL; DO NOT ACCEPT. PAYBACK: YEAR CASH FLOW CUMULATIVE CASH FLOW 0 ($260.0) ($260.0) 1 79.7 (180.3) 2 91.2 (89.1) 3 62.4 (26.7) 4 89.7 63.0 PAYBACK = 3 YEARS + $26.7/$89.7 = 3.3 YEARS. BASED ON THE ANALYSIS TO THIS POINT, THE PROJECT SHOULD NOT BE UNDERTAKEN. HOWEVER, THIS MAY NOT BE CORRECT, AS WE WILL SEE SHORTLY. E. IF THIS PROJECT HAD BEEN A REPLACEMENT RATHER THAN AN EXPANSION PROJECT, HOW WOULD THE ANALYSIS HAVE CHANGED? THINK ABOUT THE CHANGES THAT WOULD HAVE TO OCCUR IN THE CASH FLOW TABLE. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-18 AND S12-19 HERE.] IN A REPLACEMENT ANALYSIS, WE MUST FIND DIFFERENCES IN CASH FLOWS, i.e., THE CASH FLOWS THAT WOULD EXIST IF WE TAKE ON THE PROJECT VERSUS IF WE DO NOT. THUS, IN THE TABLE THERE WOULD NEED TO BE, FOR EACH YEAR, A COLUMN FOR NO CHANGE, A COLUMN FOR THE NEW PROJECT, AND FOR THE DIFFERENCE. THE DIFFERENCE COLUMN IS THE ONE THAT WOULD BE USED TO OBTAIN THE NPV, IRR, ETC. F. ASSUME THAT INFLATION IS EXPECTED TO AVERAGE 5 PERCENT OVER THE NEXT 4 YEARS; THAT THIS EXPECTATION IS REFLECTED IN THE WACC; AND THAT INFLATION WILL INCREASE VARIABLE COSTS AND REVENUES BY THE SAME PERCENTAGE, 5 PERCENT. DOES IT APPEAR THAT INFLATION HAS BEEN DEALT WITH PROPERLY IN THE ANALYSIS? IF NOT, WHAT SHOULD BE DONE, AND HOW WOULD THE REQUIRED ADJUSTMENT AFFECT THE DECISION? YOU CAN MODIFY THE NUMBERS IN THE TABLE TO QUANTIFY YOUR RESULTS. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-20 THROUGH S12-22 HERE.] IT IS APPARENT FROM THE DATA IN THE PREVIOUS TABLE THAT INFLATION HAS NOT BEEN REFLECTED IN THE CALCULATIONS. IN PARTICULAR, THE SALES PRICE IS HELD CONSTANT RATHER THAN RISING WITH INFLATION. THEREFORE, REVENUES AND COSTS (EXCEPT DEPRECIATION) SHOULD BOTH BE INCREASED BY 5 PERCENT PER YEAR. SINCE REVENUES ARE LARGER THAN OPERATING COSTS, INFLATION WILL CAUSE CASH FLOWS TO INCREASE. THIS WILL LEAD TO A HIGHER NPV, IRR, AND MIRR, AND TO A SHORTER PAYBACK. TABLE IC12-2 REFLECTS THE CHANGES, AND IT SHOWS THE NEW CASH FLOWS AND THE NEW INDICATORS. WHEN INFLATION IS PROPERLY ACCOUNTED FOR THE PROJECT IS SEEN TO BE PROFITABLE. TABLE IC12-2. ALLIEDS LEMON JUICE PROJECT (TOTAL COST IN THOUSANDS) INPUTS: PRICE: $2.00 k: 10.0% INFL: 5.0% VC RATE: 60.0% T-RATE: 40% END OF YEAR: 0 1 2 3 4 I. INVESTMENT OUTLAY EQUIPMENT COST ($200) INSTALLATION (40) INCREASE IN INVENTORY (25) INCREASE IN ACCOUNTS PAYABLE 5 TOTAL NET INVESTMENT (260) II. OPERATING CASH FLOWS UNIT SALES (THOUSANDS) 100 100 100 100 PRICE/UNIT $2.100 $2.205 $2.315 $2.431 TOTAL REVENUES $210.0 $220.5 $231.5 $243.1 OPERATING COSTS, EXCLUDING DEPRECIATION $126.0 $132.3 $138.9 $145.9 DEPRECIATION 79.2 108.0 36.0 16.8 TOTAL COSTS $205.2 $240.3 $174.9 $162.7 OPERATING INCOME BEFORE TAXES $ 4.8 ($ 19.8) $ 56.6 $ 80.4 TAXES ON OPERATING INCOME 1.9 (7.9) 22.6 32.1 OPERATING INCOME AFTER TAXES $ 2.9 ($ 11.9) $ 34.0 $ 48.3 DEPRECIATION 79.2 108.0 36.0 16.8 OPERATING CASH FLOW $ 0.0 $ 82.1 $ 96.1 $ 70.0 $ 65.1 III. TERMINAL YEAR CASH FLOWS RETURN OF NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL 20.0 SALVAGE VALUE 25.0 TAX ON SALVAGE VALUE (10.0) TOTAL TERMINATION CASH FLOWS $ 35.0 IV. NET CASH FLOWS NET CASH FLOW ADVANCE \l1($260.0) $ 82.1 $ 96.1 $ 70.0 $100.1 CUMULATIVE CASH FLOW FOR PAYBACK: (260.0) (177.9) (81.8) (11.8) 88.3 COMPOUNDED INFLOWS FOR MIRR: 109.2 116.3 77.0 100.1 TERMINAL VALUE OF INFLOWS: 402.6 V. RESULTS NPV = $15.0 IRR = 12.6% MIRR = 11.6% PAYBACK = 3.1 YEARS ALTHOUGH INFLATION WAS CONSIDERED IN THE INITIAL ANALYSIS, THE RISKINESS OF THE PROJECT WAS NOT CONSIDERED. THE EXPECTED CASH FLOWS, CONSIDERING INFLATION (IN THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS), ARE GIVEN IN TABLE IC12-2. ALLIED'S OVERALL COST OF CAPITAL (WACC) IS 10 PERCENT. TABLE IC12-2. ALLIEDS LEMON JUICE PROJECT (TOTAL COST IN THOUSANDS) YEAR 0 1 2 3 4 INVESTMENT IN: FIXED ASSETS ($240) NET OPERATING WORKING CAPITAL (20) UNIT SALES (THOUSANDS) 100 100 100 100 SALE PRICE (DOLLARS) $2.100 $2.205 $2.315 $2.431 TOTAL REVENUES $210.0 $220.5 $231.5 $243.1 CASH OPERATING COSTS (60%) 126.0 132.3 138.9 145.9 DEPRECIATION 79.2 108.0 36.0 16.8 OPER. INCOME BEFORE TAXES $ 4.8 ($19.8) $ 56.6 $ 80.4 TAXES ON OPER. INCOME (40%) 1.9 (7.9) 22.6 32.1 OPER. INCOME AFTER TAXES $ 2.9 ($11.9) $ 34.0 $ 48.3 PLUS DEPRECIATION 79.2 108.0 36.0 16.8 OPERATING CASH FLOW $ 82.1 $ 96.1 $ 70.0 $ 65.1 SALVAGE VALUE 25.0 TAX ON SV (40%) (10.0) RECOVERY OF NOWC 20.0 NET CASH FLOW ($260) $ 82.1 $ 96.1 $ 70.0 $100.1 CUMULATIVE CASH FLOWS FOR PAYBACK: (260.0) (177.9) (81.8) (11.8) 88.3 COMPOUNDED INFLOWS FOR MIRR: 109.2 116.3 77.0 100.1 TERMINAL VALUE OF INFLOWS: 402.6 NPV AT 10% COST OF CAPITAL = $15.0 IRR = 12.6% MIRR = 11.6% YOU HAVE BEEN ASKED TO ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS. G. 1. WHAT ARE THE THREE LEVELS, OR TYPES, OF PROJECT RISK THAT ARE NORMALLY CONSIDERED? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-23 THROUGH S12-26 HERE.] HERE ARE THE THREE TYPES OF PROJECT RISK: 1. STAND-ALONE RISK IS THE PROJECT'S TOTAL RISK IF IT WERE OPERATED INDEPENDENTLY. STAND-ALONE RISK IGNORES BOTH THE FIRM'S DIVER-SIFICATION AMONG PROJECTS AND INVESTORS' DIVERSIFICATION AMONG FIRMS. STAND-ALONE RISK IS MEASURED EITHER BY THE PROJECT'S STANDARD DEVIATION ((NPV) OR ITS COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION OF NPV (CVNPV). 2. WITHIN-FIRM (CORPORATE) RISK IS THE TOTAL RISKINESS OF THE PROJECT GIVING CONSIDERATION TO THE FIRM'S OTHER PROJECTS, i.e., TO DIVERSIFICATION WITHIN THE FIRM. IT IS THE CONTRIBUTION OF THE PROJECT TO THE FIRM'S TOTAL RISK, AND IT IS A FUNCTION OF (A) THE PROJECT'S STANDARD DEVIATION OF NPV AND (2) THE CORRELATION OF THE PROJECTS' RETURNS WITH THOSE OF THE REST OF THE FIRM. WITHIN-FIRM RISK IS OFTEN CALLED CORPORATE RISK, AND IT IS MEASURED BY THE BETA OF THE PROJECT'S ROA VERSUS THE FIRM'S ROA. 3. MARKET RISK IS THE RISKINESS OF THE PROJECT TO A WELL-DIVERSIFIED INVESTOR. THEORETICALLY, IT IS MEASURED BY THE PROJECT'S BETA, AND IT CONSIDERS BOTH CORPORATE RISK AND STOCKHOLDER DIVERSIFICATION. G. 2. WHICH TYPE IS MOST RELEVANT? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-27 HERE.] BECAUSE MANAGEMENT'S PRIMARY GOAL IS SHAREHOLDER WEALTH MAXIMIZATION, THE MOST RELEVANT RISK FOR CAPITAL PROJECTS IS MARKET RISK. HOWEVER, CREDITORS, CUSTOMERS, SUPPLIERS, AND EMPLOYEES ARE ALL AFFECTED BY A FIRM'S TOTAL RISK. SINCE THESE PARTIES INFLUENCE THE FIRM'S PROFITABILITY, A PROJECT'S WITHIN-FIRM RISK SHOULD NOT BE COMPLETELY IGNORED. G. 3. WHICH TYPE IS EASIEST TO MEASURE? ANSWER: BY FAR THE EASIEST TYPE OF RISK TO MEASURE IS A PROJECT'S STAND-ALONE RISK. THUS, FIRMS OFTEN FOCUS PRIMARILY ON THIS TYPE OF RISK WHEN MAKING CAPITAL BUDGETING DECISIONS. THIS FOCUS IS NOT THEORETICALLY CORRECT, BUT IT DOES NOT NECESSARILY LEAD TO POOR DECISIONS, BECAUSE MOST PROJECTS THAT A FIRM UNDERTAKES ARE IN ITS CORE BUSINESS. G. 4. ARE THE THREE TYPES OF RISK GENERALLY HIGHLY CORRELATED? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-28 HERE.] BECAUSE MOST PROJECTS THAT A FIRM UNDERTAKES ARE IN ITS CORE BUSINESS, A PROJECT'S STAND-ALONE RISK IS LIKELY TO BE HIGHLY CORRELATED WITH ITS CORPORATE RISK, WHICH IN TURN IS LIKELY TO BE HIGHLY CORRELATED WITH ITS MARKET RISK. H. 1. WHAT IS SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-29 HERE.] SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS MEASURES THE EFFECT OF CHANGES IN A PARTICULAR VARIABLE, SAY REVENUES, ON A PROJECT'S NPV. TO PERFORM A SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS, ALL VARIABLES ARE FIXED AT THEIR EXPECTED VALUES EXCEPT ONE. THIS ONE VARIABLE IS THEN CHANGED, OFTEN BY SPECIFIED PERCENTAGES, AND THE RESULTING EFFECT ON NPV IS NOTED. (ONE COULD ALLOW MORE THAN ONE VARIABLE TO CHANGE, BUT THIS THEN MERGES SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS INTO SCENARIO ANALYSIS.) H. 2. DISCUSS HOW ONE WOULD PERFORM A SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS ON THE UNIT SALES, SALVAGE VALUE, AND COST OF CAPITAL FOR THE PROJECT. ASSUME THAT EACH OF THESE VARIABLES DEVIATES FROM ITS BASE-CASE, OR EXPECTED, VALUE BY PLUS AND MINUS 10, 20, AND 30 PERCENT. EXPLAIN HOW YOU WOULD CALCULATE THE NPV, IRR, MIRR, AND PAYBACK FOR EACH CASE. ANSWER: THE BASE CASE VALUE FOR UNIT SALES WAS 100; THEREFORE, IF YOU WERE TO ASSUME THAT THIS VALUE DEVIATED BY PLUS AND MINUS 10, 20, AND 30 PERCENT, THE UNIT SALES VALUES TO BE USED IN THE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS WOULD BE 70, 80, 90, 110, 120, AND 130 UNITS. YOU WOULD THEN GO BACK TO THE TABLE AT THE BEGINNING OF THE PROBLEM, INSERT THE APPROPRIATE SALES UNIT NUMBER, SAY 70 UNITS, AND REWORK THE TABLE FOR THE CHANGE IN SALES UNITS ARRIVING AT DIFFERENT NET CASH FLOW VALUES FOR THE PROJECT. ONCE YOU HAD THE NET CASH FLOW VALUES, YOU WOULD CALCULATE THE NPV, IRR, MIRR, AND PAYBACK AS YOU DID PREVIOUSLY. (NOTE THAT SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS INVOLVES MAKING A CHANGE TO ONLY ONE VARIABLE TO SEE HOW IT IMPACTS OTHER VARIABLES.) THEN, YOU WOULD GO BACK AND REPEAT THE SAME STEPS FOR 80 UNITS--THIS WOULD BE DONE FOR EACH OF THE SALES UNIT VALUES. THEN, YOU WOULD REPEAT THE SAME PROCEDURE FOR THE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS ON SALVAGE VALUE AND ON COST OF CAPITAL. (NOTE THAT FOR THE COST OF CAPITAL ANALYSIS, THE NET CASH FLOWS WOULD REMAIN THE SAME, BUT THE COST OF CAPITAL USED IN THE NPV AND MIRR CALCULATIONS WOULD BE DIFFERENT.) EXCEL AND LOTUS 1-2-3 ARE IDEALLY SUITED FOR SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS. IN FACT WE CREATED A SPREADSHEET TO OBTAIN THIS PROJECTS' NET CASH FLOWS AND ITS NPV, IRR, MIRR, AND PAYBACK. ONCE A MODEL HAS BEEN CREATED, IT IS VERY EASY TO CHANGE THE VALUES OF VARIABLES AND OBTAIN THE NEW RESULTS. THE RESULTS OF THE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS ON THE PROJECT'S NPV ASSUMING THE PLUS AND MINUS 10, 20, AND 30 PERCENT DEVIATIONS ARE SHOWN BELOW. WE GENERATED THESE DATA WITH A SPREADSHEET MODEL. 1. THE SENSITIVITY LINES INTERSECT AT 0% CHANGE AND THE BASE CASE NPV, AT APPROXIMATELY $15,000. SINCE ALL OTHER VARIABLES ARE SET AT THEIR BASE CASE, OR EXPECTED, VALUES, THE ZERO CHANGE SITUATION IS THE BASE CASE. 2. THE PLOTS FOR UNIT SALES AND SALVAGE VALUE ARE UPWARD SLOPING, INDICATING THAT HIGHER VARIABLE VALUES LEAD TO HIGHER NPVs. CONVERSELY, THE PLOT FOR COST OF CAPITAL IS DOWNWARD SLOPING, BECAUSE A HIGHER COST OF CAPITAL LEADS TO A LOWER NPV. 3. THE PLOT OF UNIT SALES IS MUCH STEEPER THAN THAT FOR SALVAGE VALUE. THIS INDICATES THAT NPV IS MORE SENSITIVE TO CHANGES IN UNIT SALES THAN TO CHANGES IN SALVAGE VALUE. 4. STEEPER SENSITIVITY LINES INDICATE GREATER RISK. THUS, IN COMPARING TWO PROJECTS, THE ONE WITH THE STEEPER LINES IS CONSIDERED TO BE RISKIER. THE SENSITIVITY DATA ARE GIVEN HERE IN TABULAR FORM (IN THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS): CHANGE FROM RESULTING NPV AFTER THE INDICATED CHANGE IN: BASE LEVEL UNIT SALES SALVAGE VALUE k -30% ($36.4) $11.9 $34.1 -20 (19.3) 12.9 27.5 -10 (2.1) 13.9 21.1 0 15.0 15.0 15.0 +10 32.1 16.0 9.0 +20 49.2 17.0 3.3 +30 66.3 18.0 (2.2) H. 3. WHAT IS THE PRIMARY WEAKNESS OF SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS? WHAT ARE ITS PRIMARY ADVANTAGES? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-30 AND S12-31 HERE.] THE TWO PRIMARY DISADVANTAGES OF SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS ARE (1) THAT IT DOES NOT REFLECT THE EFFECTS OF DIVERSIFICATION AND (2) THAT IT DOES NOT INCORPORATE ANY INFORMATION ABOUT THE POSSIBLE MAGNITUDES OF THE FORECAST ERRORS. THUS, A SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS MIGHT INDICATE THAT A PROJECT'S NPV IS HIGHLY SENSITIVE TO THE SALES FORECAST, HENCE THAT THE PROJECT IS QUITE RISKY, BUT IF THE PROJECT'S SALES, HENCE ITS REVENUES, ARE FIXED BY A LONG-TERM CONTRACT, THEN SALES VARIATIONS MAY ACTUALLY CONTRIBUTE LITTLE TO THE PROJECT'S RISK. THEREFORE, IN MANY SITUATIONS, SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS IS NOT A PARTICULARLY GOOD INDICATOR OF RISK. HOWEVER, SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS DOES IDENTIFY THOSE VARIABLES THAT POTENTIALLY HAVE THE GREATEST IMPACT ON PROFITABILITY, AND THIS HELPS MANAGEMENT FOCUS ITS ATTENTION ON THOSE VARIABLES THAT ARE PROBABLY MOST IMPORTANT. I. ASSUME THAT YOU ARE CONFIDENT ABOUT THE ESTIMATES OF ALL THE VARIABLES THAT AFFECT THE CASH FLOWS EXCEPT UNIT SALES. IF PRODUCT ACCEPTANCE IS POOR, SALES WOULD BE ONLY 75,000 UNITS A YEAR, WHILE A STRONG CONSUMER RESPONSE WOULD PRODUCE SALES OF 125,000 UNITS. IN EITHER CASE, CASH COSTS WOULD STILL AMOUNT TO 60 PERCENT OF REVENUES. YOU BELIEVE THAT THERE IS A 25 PERCENT CHANCE OF POOR ACCEPTANCE, A 25 PERCENT CHANCE OF EXCELLENT ACCEPTANCE, AND A 50 PERCENT CHANCE OF AVERAGE ACCEPTANCE (THE BASE CASE). 1. WHAT IS THE WORST-CASE NPV? THE BEST-CASE NPV? ANSWER: [SHOW S12-32 AND S12-33 HERE.] WE USED A SPREADSHEET MODEL TO DEVELOP THE SCENARIOS (IN THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS), WHICH ARE SUMMARIZED BELOW: CASE PROBABILITY NPV (000s) WORST 0.25 ($27.8) BASE 0.50 15.0 BEST 0.25 57.8 I. 2. USE THE WORST-, MOST LIKELY (OR BASE), AND BEST-CASE NPVs, WITH THEIR PROBABILITIES OF OCCURRENCE, TO FIND THE PROJECT'S EXPECTED NPV, STANDARD DEVIATION, AND COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION. ANSWER: [SHOW S12-34 HERE.] THE EXPECTED NPV IS $14,968 (ROUNDED TO THE NEAREST THOUSAND BELOW). E(NPV) = 0.25(-$27.8) + 0.50($15.0) + 0.25($57.8) = $15. THE STANDARD DEVIATION OF NPV IS $30.3: (NPV = [0.25(-$27.8 - $15)2 + 0.50($15 - $15)2 + 0.25($57.8 - $15)2]1/2 = [916]1/2 = $30.3, AND THE PROJECT'S COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION IS 2.0: CVNPV =  EMBED Equation.3  PAGE 6 Answers and Solutions: 12 - Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright 2000 by Harcourt, Inc. PAGE 7 Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright 2000 by Harcourt, Inc. Answers and Solutions: 12 - Integrated Case: 12 - PAGE 14 Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright 2000 by Harcourt, Inc. Integrated Case: 12 - PAGE 8 Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright 2000 by Harcourt, Inc. Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright 2000 by Harcourt, Inc. Integrated Case: 12 - PAGE 9 Solutions to Appendix Problems: 12 - PAGE 26 Harcourt, Inc. items and derived items copyright 2000 by Harcourt, Inc. The Dryden Press Solutions to Appendix Problems: 12 - PAGE 23  EMBED WPWin6.1  MIRR = 9.6% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% ;NPIJKNkl  $%89:;  ./01HI\]^_j>*CJCJ j|EHU%j-; OJQJUVhmHnHu jEHU%jˠ%< OJQJUVhmHnHu jUH* jsH*@H*@H* js@@56>*\] 5>*\CJ>*:;<NOPHI$ P0d1$a$ P0`d1$^``$ P08d1$a$$a$"#<=>sss;$ \`08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$$ P08d1$a$$ P081$a$ P01$$ P0d1$a$2FGD<$ _08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$?$ \0p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./^a$> Y0p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I0d./^`0G`abP9$ G0T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I@[./]^[`a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id.Z/Za$9$ _08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$nvx   " $ , . 6 8 @      ' ? G I Q S [ ] e g o q y z      >* jH*>*H*>*CJ>*CJCJ\Ng551$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08TdP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$A 4 5 ii63$ J08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T z `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$5 ) z { m2;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$1$ G08T,  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$.$ 808T`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$1$ G08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a${  kkS$ P08,4d1$a$$ P08x4d1$a$$ P08pd1$a$$ P08 d1$a$$ P08d1$a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ B f    ` m n }($ ;08Tp @ xHd1$a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$$  P0Bd1$a$$  P0Bd1$a$ 5=?GIQS[]e$&.08:BDLdlnvx"x>*>*CJ>*CJCJ` !"c03$ J08TdP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$7$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$"sfYii1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T z `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$YZNl:1$ G08T,  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$.$ 808T`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$1$ G08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$$q:7$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$($ ;08Tp @ xHd1$a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$=$ Y08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF ITd./^Ta$$Ddeg551$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08TdP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$XKii63$ J08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T z `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$"$,.68@BJU]_giqs{}(02:<DFNPXZb (*24<>FZbdlnvx>*>*CJ>*CJCJ`?m2;$ \08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$1$ G08T,  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$.$ 808T`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$1$ G08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$de7$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$;$ \08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$dGg551$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08TdP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$G:ii63$ J08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T z `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$."#m2;$ \08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$1$ G08T,  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$.$ 808T`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$1$ G08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$ !",5@HJRT\^fhp %'/19;CEMOWowyS]mx j>*>*>*CJ>*>*CJCJ]#67NOttttt($ ;08Tp @ xHd1$a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$;$ \08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ ,-c03$ J08TdP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$7$ J08T,dP. `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$-~ qdii1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08T z `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$1$ G08Tx zX `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$deYl:1$ G08T,  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$.$ 808T`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./]^[a$1$ G08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$3$ J08Tx  X `'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I[./^[a$ O3$ # 08p Pd1$a$9$ Y08Tp P!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$;$ \08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$;$ \08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ 5^xy( = > sKKK($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$+ 808p @ xH0d1$^`0($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$$ # 08p Pd1$a$$ # 08p Pd1$a$xyz}& ' * + / !!!!!!!""""""######|$$$$$%%%%%%%%&%&&&9&:&;&<&J&K&M&N&a&b&%j4.; OJQJUVhmHnHuCJ jEHU%j'; OJQJUVhmHnHu jUjUhmHnHu>*>*H*H* jsE> c d e f a)$ ;08p @ xH81$`8a$%$ ;08p @ xH1$a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$ !*!L!n!!!!!X)$ ;08p @ xH81$^8a$,$ ;08p @ xH8d1$`8a$%$ ;08p @ xH1$a$-$ ;08p @ xH81$^8`a$ !!"E"u""""b#c#d#W,$ ;08p @ xH8d1$^8a$*$ 808p @ xH8d1$^8a$,$ ;08p @ xH8d1$`8a$%$ ;08p @ xH1$a$ d#e#####%$T$$$UUUUUUU;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$C$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I0d./^`0a$,$ ;08p @ xH8d1$`8a$ $$ %T%%%&&"&#&=&>&J&8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ J&K&e&f&r&s&TT?$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$3 Y08@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./b&c&d&r&s&t&u&&&&&&&&& ( (((n(o() )/)4)))y,,,,,,,,,,,-B-I---1.9.....////////////0000!0'0)0/0107090?0E0I011jUhmHnHu>*>* jH* j EHU%jl.; OJQJUVhmHnHuCJ jU j5EHULs&&&&&&SSS;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$9 \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./^&((D(y(z())DD<$ _08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$C$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$)Y))).*BD$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./1$^8`a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$<$ _08Tp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$.*z*{*+++EEEC$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$?$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8a$+++%,`,,,,-J-R9$ _08p@ P J!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I@./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ J-K-T-j---9.:.z.{.... !;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$ .2/R/h///@0A0V0W0X0W;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$5$ V08p@ H&f!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$ X0Y0Z0[0\0]0^0_0`0a0}0~000;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$ 111 1&1)10131=1*212q2y2223 3444 4"4(4*4042484Q4W4Y4_4a4g4i4o4q4w4}44<5C5F5L5O5U5X5^5`5h556?6G6667 7 7 7 7 77777777777777788888"8%8*8-82858:8@8C89 jCJH*jUhmHnHu>*>*Y0=1I111122y2z22R;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$9$ _08p@ P J!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I@./a$ 2223F3f3|33394x4y444444=$ V08p@ H&f!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I0./^`0a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$4$5j5x556G6I6m6n66668$ \08p@ P J!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$ 6+7I7_777;8<8R8U:$ Y08p@ P !`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./]a$8$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$6$ Y08p@ H&f!$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I./a$R8S899999999jjjjj.$ 808p @ xH0d1$^`0a$*$ 808p @ xHd1$^a$;$ \08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ 99: : : : :K:L:rr%$ ;08p @ xH1$a$?$ `08x$&@#$$d%d&d'd./NOPQa$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$9:: :: :J:K:L:aAcAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA B'B.BLBSBqBxBBBBBBB:C@CCCICLCRCUC\CDDD!D$D*D-D3DZD`DcDiDlDrDuD|DDDDDDDDE`EͿͿͿͿͿͻͿͿͿͿͷͻͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿͿ5>*565>*56CJOJQJ5OJQJ CJOJQJ6CJOJQJ CJOJQJ5CJOJQJOJQJ5CJOJQJHL:;=>@bAcAAAwue$ H1$a$($ ;08p @ xHd1$a$0$ ;08p @ xH8hd1$^8`ha$0$ ;08p @ xH8d1$^8`a$AAAA Bq:7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$$ & 08~ X f!$d1$a$ B/BTByBBBBBCV7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$C]CCCC4D}DDECEEE;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$ `EfEiEoErExE{EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEkFrFFFFFFFFFFFGG G GGGGG%G(G2GXGYGGGGLHMHzH{HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH jU jH*UH*jUhmHnHu j5U565>*55>*REEEF*FsFFFFVVVV;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$F&G'G3G;GCGLGXGGxxxxx^$ 088d1$^8`a$$ 08d1$a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$GG H!HLHxHIIQQQ9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$ d1$` a$=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$HHHIJ%K,KHLLLLMMMMNN*O+O_O`OOOOOOOOOOOO?PAPHPQQQQ=RARSSSSSSVT]T_TfThToTqTxTzTTTT&U,UJUPUSUlUUUUUUUUUVVVVVVVV WWWWW656CJOJQJ CJOJQJ5CJOJQJ>*>* j5H*UIIIIJJ$KQK9 @8d1$`d1$=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8a$$K%KFLGLHLLLMMMMMNNN5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$d1$NNNO;OpOOOOOWWWWW8$ S08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$`8a$ O@PAPQQQQQSSOO<$ S08p @ xHP X !(#8d1$^8`a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$ SSSS T9T:Tll $ # 08~ X f!$d1$^a$$ & 08~ X f!$d1$a$$ ) HP X !(#1$a$9$ S08p @ xHP X !(#81$^8`a$:TTTTX7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$TTT U-URUSUmUUV7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$UUFVWVVV0WxWWXQXX;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$ W%W(W/WWWWWWWWW%X+X.X4X7X=X@XFXIXPXnXtXwX}XXXXXXXYYYYYYY Z ZZZZ Z#Z)Z,Z2Z5Z;Z>ZDZ5[?[[k\m\t\\\P]]]^^<_>_E_|__&````cd!d(d=e>e}e~e3f4fGfjUhmHnHu5 jU6>*>*UXXXYIYYYYYT7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$YEZFZ[ZZZ3[RRR6$ 0 X $d1$^a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$3[4[@[R[e[x[[[[l\m\x5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$<$ S08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$$ 08d1$a$ m\N]O]P]]]^^^=_>_$`%`&```c5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$cccc d!d*>*jUhmHnHu jU jv EHU%j-y; OJQJUVhmHnHuK-fKfLffff gXXX9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$`8a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$6$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$81$`8a$ gKggg+hlh}hhh}}}G5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$`8a$$ #8d1$`8a$6$ P08p @ xHP #$8d1$`8a$hhhhhi9imiiiTTTTTT;$$$ S08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$`8a$ ij j6jP9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$`8a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d`1$`8a$;$$$ S08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8a$6jjjjj{k|kmmmQQ=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8a$ mnnqqqqqkM$ & 08~ X f!$d1$a$$ ,HP X !(#$1$a$5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$=$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$8d1$^8`a$qrArBrrrQ5$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$9$ V08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$$ & 08~ X f!$d1$a$ $ # 08~ X f!$d1$^a$rrrrs5sZs[sussV7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$ ssssstttttttttuuu$u'u-u0u6uuuuuuuuu,v2v5v;v>vDvGvMvPvVvtvzv}vvvvvvvvwwwwwwwxxxxx%x(x.x1x7x:x@xCxIx:yDyyyzzzzzzz{){m{5>* 5>*sH56OJQJOJQJsH5sH5 jU6>*>*TstNt_ttt7uuuvWvv;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$ vvvwOwwwwwT7$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$wJxKx`xxx8yRRR6$ 0 X $d1$^a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$7$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$a$;$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$d1$`a$8y9yEyWyjy}yyyyz{;$ \`08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$4$ Y0h8p @ xHP X !(#$1$a$$ 08d1$a$ zzzzz){`3$ M`08p@ $D%0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$$ & 08~ X f!$d1$a$$ ,HP X !(#$1$a$, E@8@ $D%0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./){m{|{{{{dd6- G@p8r$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./2$ J`08r$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$3$ M`08@ xX $`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$5$ P`08p@ xX $`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$m{{{{||||||||||||}} }}}b}h}i}o}p}v}w}~}}}}~~~ ~~~~%~)~+~1~2~8~9~?~@~G~]^IYYZ]/=X߄&yEH jssH>* 5OJQJ5>* 5>*sH55>*sH5sHU{{{|A|v|||}N}~}}}h3$ M`08J#`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$2$ J`08J#`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$0$ G`08&X $`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ }}~G~H~^~eee2$ J`08J#`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$3$ M`08M0m!#`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$3$ M`08JX #`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$^~~~~~~~gg3$ M`08p@ $`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$2$ J`08J#`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$2$ J`08J#`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$9]^Fs`s$ @d./a$$ 8d./^`a$$ @d./^`a$$ 88d./^8`a$;$ \`08p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ VWX{|n$ 8d./a$$ 88d./^8`a$$ @Xd./^X`a$$ 8Xd./^X`a$$ 8d./^`a$$ @d./a$ xy{$ 8./a$$ @d./a$$ 8`d./^``a$$ 8`d./^``a$$ @./a$$ 88d./^8`a$?@$ V8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$@$ V8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$@$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF IXd./^X`a$ H@$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF IXd./^X`a$>$ S8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$8$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ deŕ1 ؗ>q8)*>?@CDLOӡաۡ$5CJOJQJ CJOJQJ6CJOJQJ0JmHnHu0J j0JU jEHU%jܳ< OJQJUVhmHnHuEHEHH*EHH* jssH>*>*sHsH jU5< v#VWK8$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$<$ V@8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8a$@$ V8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$W01$%єҔdL:$ S@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8a$8$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$@$ V@8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./^`a$1m!]֗חؗ6$ S@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$8$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$ ؗ67sA=$ V@8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./1$^8a$@$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF IXd./^X`a$@$ V8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$M=$ Pp@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I0d./^`0a$=$ P8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I8d./^8`a$8$ V@p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF Id./a$~4opqyyyyyyy$ @d./a$$ 88d./^8`a$$ @Xd./^X`a$>$ S8p@ P !$`'0*-/2p5@8;=@CPF I0d./^`0a$ q01ϠРDYZ$ @./a$ 88dO./^8$ @d./a$$ @d./a$$ @Xd./^X`a$$ 88d./^8`a$ %&12 yz{d$ $a$  !d&`#$$ @8./^8a$$%&'-./012|¢  %&+,-./xy{ţףܣݣ ԜԜ5CJOJQJmHnHuj5CJOJQJU5OJQJmHnHuj5OJQJU 5OJQJOJQJ 6OJQJCJ5CJOJQJ6CJOJQJ CJOJQJ0JmHnHu0J j0JUCJ8ghiäĤФѤҤӤԤդ٤ڤۤߤ$ $a$dgiz¤źź jUj2B< UV jU5OJQJmHnHuj5OJQJU 5OJQJ 6OJQJOJQJ CJOJQJ5CJOJQJmHnHu5CJOJQJj5CJOJQJU$ @8./^8a$ 0PRVPRV&P/ =!"#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =! "#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =! "#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =!"#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =!"#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =!p"#$%: 00PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%70PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%: 00PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%: 00PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%: 00PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%: 00PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%70PRVPRV&PP/ =!"#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =!"#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =! "#$%3 0PRVPRV&P/ =!"#$%3 0PP&P/ =!"#$%`!闲0àt-=WP*+xah[UϽ%i҄u8KP߆m&L_uZ'~[ھQdsE&w2gW'SN_ؠ[q2Ax}swO={il|PmW0ʯzΩ?`R=Vs4'b5S'X0ic5t&8MNHS$XIҜ՜'ytV9xTɪ[Kox:Iymz j%leV^>xc ΪD<-wBd7ddEr@N9"9eOR`6@r'ɳH ,$C,+pA$聒AG_) YY`\3sͻ~OQϓy3MsqM7@c3h!cyv<}CQ|'q*ǩ85ѠSkzK | 4ѩG*Gkõm.>m2\h%-״ {ܫ{j{+Spfݺҥ|~ZZֹy+s n͊Xfܺ˵ p,ε(a { Vş1Lz^ A82噚[w9jivJ;RjS ]IuDB^jU9m,CE:~B1;˫] ܈"ͭ;4;aDaν"z}Q}~lL4+hV<MK|4;ۣ ||4CFO8sI,DPq*5-==RT 艧lOmsՕR!ѳ=kqrvNC7\ϗyE\ׁyȬRq',tBO.2s'kAŦux\\:kuƌs'x8zrά\u\z>6΅\a8zr׎ v!^nfQM'}ֽˑ_$7i=biUwD]գ~!'w|Dd0B  S A? 2iF$Z0<:D(`!iF$Z0<:)kx}R=KA<01UDΰw$V DR((#1*,ďޟ B/lV*wh yof.49#A32i"c0 C)x4{8O'g8 uO ֶz;8@!FQT<ޱ7CX9jweEoͤ^uwl#82H[YGK1)I^5g$dY8ҲȚJ+fJfTsV+}Kg0$Y bt zK?YBjU g"AWy[H_oow ʀNe60>Q[-2dٺ I C,6 * ;ZEDd B  S A? 2Oβ5yz`!Oβ5yzX`j:QxeKP.a@B `].g JJN%R2Oq nZ/\#l5UT& jx4O ijCh\:͒uH9|ʼn^՞xUK G˓m 0^tTF}iUSV~)g ~x׏GLuy,lI-晫ځN+W+2>0w /TZ/hVdnonE[2DRΐu=O5'9K3Yiv̭8rs2P5|( ]#Q7}kXHQtDd 0B  S A? 2SV[Ջ]s`!SV[Ջ]s,kx}R=KA3j.9#D)TbHk, IOo@>$Dbm'b_wDcv! `l#b$LF$D a(*NQij̀4G'  d 6pxbeeTO="rxT'n BmX;WaPлW4?pIP٬¸F5'u+'Gl?`ь%:z̃OibiI^ jf99.!Vk^WU@K \Un!rKKf"S#nתC|^j>MD"_Էm!e6Q!$ʻNڐuߪfXDd4B  S A? 2 Or~_2y`!Or~_2H %H9xtx}J@g'Q?bVЖ"-F{AE/PVlEz 'zPwϊ ;t &l37߮v#Ā9BH. q&#F93"PGS&&'e4;cQ2i\H}$DaeQ?pΩh_A+13GmY;5hidT]|bp.x'٥{\u `o.;6 3-ԜY?p+; z88s88_g5KVeԩ_(~v-2*;E07Mz4@Jj-oO4}cr;DdlB  S A? 2E  {V\ `!E  {V\+0Dxtx}RJQ;n.`!FIȃM6 v+Q0FHHEl3-Vjezgf5<N| t"YyQm=fObp'|JNHk7S`Su+MJV pA:t\1-~hd^s|'fTs7Y#˔V/J*>dZi7kfdځ+d}.X!U*2̈?R p/`]a U[\u&XJ-˽4[1lYo[Pu+qЍnh?͖Ҍ}ڝ,xwa<eK&1*^;3]rYpŕa|*.p|iLit;?{Tt[jDc7 k)Dd0B  S A? 2UAPOm_~9k…o `!gUAPOm_~9k…'P=k5x}kSAg'm^~c+䌭2ֿ>yvrucqomf^NY=t%ԇH,m(ET!}65QR+Z}Lgƚ1F=7o1z8ns?'jV7Nqy"sr/n7>N\ɐ~|8.W^Hst|ulG9A/'XLS؉s\f)9 8RFob;:B฾}l<:n&}'ΝӤQܕ:>R*QeOTÝ}_c8K@ зGB0j]pz$X\i>AFT?cDd B  S   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~ Root Entry- F3mData WordDocument,ʞObjectPool/ P 3m3m_1009098955FP 3mP 3mOle CompObjfObjInfo  !$'()*+.123458;<?BCDEFGIJKLN FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS Equation Equation.39qp hIbI CV= NPV E(NPV)=$21,750,227.59$18,540,000.00=1.17.Equation Native _1002974479 FPB3mPB3mOle  CompObj f FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS Equation Equation.39q?hcIgI CV=$23.622$3.0=7.874.ObjInfo Equation Native  _1002972935F\3m\3mOle  FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS Equation Equation.39q?cIgI CV=Standard deviationExpected value= NPV Expected CompObjfObjInfoEquation Native _1002974772Fj3mj3mNPVour FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS Equation Equation.39q?cIgI  A =(("$750) 2 (0.2)+($0) 2 (0.6)+($Ole CompObjfObjInfoEquation Native $750) 2 (0.2) = $474.34. FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS Equation Equation.39q?,ThI|I  B =(("$7,650) 2 (0.2_1002974828'F`3m`3mOle "CompObj#fObjInfo%Equation Native &H_997793069F3m3mOle ,CompObj -f)+($900) 2 (0.6)+($10,350) 2 (0.2) = $5,797.84. FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS Equation Equation.39qObjInfo!/Equation Native 0t_1018420423$F3m3mOle 6X hIbI "$260+$79.7(1+IRR) 1 +$91.2(1+IRR) 2 +$62.4(1+IRR) 3 +$89.7(1+IRR) 4 =0.2  FMicrosoft Equation 3.0 DS EqCompObj#%7fObjInfo&9Equation Native :_1018249778")?xpL3mL3muation Equation.39q0܈cIgI  NPV E(NPV)=$30.3$15=2.0. ?xpWordPerfect 6.1 Embed Source WPWin6.19qOle =WP61 (*/CompObj+>^ObjInfo@     !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLM/WPCN. /E,?(y3`_b\,@B͊[kkKĎ2 N!~"DROq\Eߗ@WT`x'H\,iiInjrDs ^@'d/ӔDy+yܓسRX$Vc-%YƞQ#g~Z*pEc#x&3wyw@I0Βq%(Cg$mcI$z'XoJ8- c u{ʅB,K&6L?"3r6M #.|coIƄ^أ*PRr o4> :׮P`}V |FTqE^1ls燆t+~bxQd,i(X)ڔF,ǒ~gWJYx [w[֮JVYPBoȊI~B>\dMTr4h5s*%UL %, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , # 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 0= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 0g B& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & @C o" U U U U U UFw,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w,w, AM, - 0K- D3.<p`(4Line Draw 12cpiFull-PEHP LaserJet 5P/5MP PostScriptPSCRIPT0nLH(Z2 P$ Z+=!  'X4` XX'   (?+=$  'X4` XX'   dvG.WPGWPC%$%$9JJ513+ ' ! @!@ ! ! Q!Q ! !     OO   k!k! -9\fffG%2`HelveticaG 70 xfffG%2`HelveticaG 60 gfffG%2`HelveticaG 50 ,>fffG%2`HelveticaG 40 #s~gggG%2`HelveticaG 30 #~gggG%2`HelveticaG 20 # ~gggG%2`HelveticaG 10  | gggG%2`HelveticaG 0 gggG%2`HelveticaG -30% ` gggG%2`HelveticaG -20% <EgggG%2`HelveticaG 10% gggG%2`HelveticaG 20% y /gggG%2`HelveticaG -10% gggG%2`HelveticaG 0% o xx"gggG%2`HelveticaG 30%  !fffG%2`HelveticaG NPV f| fffG%2`HelveticaG (Thousands) FQ  s#gggG%2`HelveticaG CostofCapital Ts"vgggG%2`HelveticaG SalvageValue egggG%2`HelveticaG UnitSales ! . !t_#G%2`HelveticaG SensitivityGraph p "     YY   gggG%2`HelveticaG -10  BgggG%2`HelveticaG -20 gggG%2`HelveticaG -30 bgggG%2`HelveticaG -40 ! XfffG%2`HelveticaG  p o51XfffG%2`HelveticaG  na0fffG%2`HelveticaG  _ fffG%2`HelveticaG  nf fffG%2`HelveticaG  f fffG%2`HelveticaG  ><fffG%2`HelveticaG  DfffG%2`HelveticaG   G( fffG%2`HelveticaG  ufffG%2`HelveticaG  I"fffG%2`HelveticaG  wfffG%2`HelveticaG   \fffG%2`HelveticaG  W2fffG%2`HelveticaG  QfffG%2`HelveticaG  3 AV fffG%2`HelveticaG  $!GfffG%2`HelveticaG  !4fffG%2`HelveticaG  V !=  ! ! fffG%2`HelveticaG  K !K <L4 9Z .Courier New Regular=A<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5( $ Figure  1  [[[['dxd !   TS {   US  TS uN>:z , p`%$@E5 p'5 p TS {   US  TS Oh+'0  0 < H T`hpx Chapter 11hapCollege of BusinessollNormal Rohan Chambersn3haMicrosoft Word 9.0@F#@h@Nnj@hmA? 2 :bl<M3`! :bl<M3`(8:ox}R;KAK.˙c!VD4! Vb|Dph$+KK $ i73w7;"XdGTM؊IAGVN\E? "VFY72ߥiQt[ם 3_u"Zޒ #8Ɵ܏/Ÿx2Ę_wv'˾Š¶VH+d#=/]4ZW@nx7:˸R;߰-@g!&E eknm@sjC~SDd#g0  # A2A闲0àt-D`!闲0àt-=WP*+xah[UϽ%i҄u8KP߆m&L_uZ'~[ھQdsE&w2gW'SN_ؠ[q2Ax}swO={il|PmW0ʯzΩ?`R=Vs4'b5S'X0ic5t&8MNHS$XIҜ՜'ytV9xTɪ[Kox:Iymz j%leV^>xc ΪD<-wBd7ddEr@N9"9eOR`6@r'ɳH ,$C,+pA$聒AG_) YY`\3sͻ~OQϓy3MsqM7@c3h!cyv<}CQ|'q*ǩ85ѠSkzK | 4ѩG*Gkõm.>m2\h%-״ {ܫ{j{+Spfݺҥ|~ZZֹy+s n͊Xfܺ˵ p,ε(a { Vş1Lz^ A82噚[w9jivJ;RjS ]IuDB^jU9m,CE:~B1;˫] ܈"ͭ;4;aDaν"z}Q}~lL4+hV<MK|4;ۣ ||4CFO8sI,DPq*5-==RT 艧lOmsՕR!ѳ=kqrvNC7\ϗyE\ׁyȬRq',tBO.2s'kAŦux\\:kuƌs'x8zrά\u\z>6΅\a8zr׎ v!^nfQM'}ֽˑ_$7i=biUwD]գ~!'w1Table"SummaryInformation(.ADocumentSummaryInformation8H8CompObjMj՜.+,0 hp  University of Florida11B  Chapter 11 Title  FMicrosoft Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q i@@@ Normal1$OJQJ_HhmH sH tH  Heading 1X$$ `08x$&@#$$d%d&d'd./@&a$5CJOJQJ@ Heading 2s$$ Y08p @ xHP X !(#$d1$@&a$6CJp@p Heading 3@$$ ,HP X !(#$1$@&a$ 5OJQJ Heading 4T$$ `08$&@#$$d%d&d'd./@&a$5CJ$OJQJZ@Z Heading 5%$$ H1$@&a$5CJOJQJ<A@< Default Paragraph Font4&@4 Footnote Reference.. Style0^`0FOF ICQ%$ `0@pdNa$5CJ" CaptionS$ `08xw#&`$d%d&d'd./a$5CJOJQJ,@2, Header  !, @B, Footer  !lCRl Body Text Indent5$ `080d1$^`0a$CJvRbv Body Text Indent 2;$ 08d1$^`a$CJSr Body Text Indent 3_$ ;08p @ xHd1$^`a$CJ88 1$CJOJQJ_HhmH sH tH B>@B Title $1$a$5CJ0OJQJ\aJhJJ@J Subtitle $1$a$5>*CJ$OJQJ\aJh&)@& Page Number$%&'(-.38@EFGHM  $%&'(-.38@EFGHMP     $"?"g",0H255J_fmuќ2gі;w(d٘Cx;<NOPHI"#<=>2FG`abNA45)z{Bf   ` m n  ! " s  f  Y Z N $DdeXK?dG:."#67NO ,-~ qdeY 5^xy(=>cdef*LnEubcde% T !T!!!""""#"=">"J"K"e"f"r"s""""""$$D$y$z$%%Y%%%.&z&{&'''''%(`(((()J)K)T)j)))9*:*z*{****2+R+h+++@,A,V,W,X,Y,Z,[,\,],^,_,`,a,},~,,,=-I----2.y.z..../F/f/|///90x0y000000$1j1x112G2I2m2n2222+3I3_333;4<4R4S45555555556 6 6 6 6K6L679:<b=c====== >/>T>y>>>>>?]????4@}@@ACAAAAAB*BsBBBB&C'C3C;CCCLCXCCC D!DLDxDEEEEEFF$G%GFHGHHHHHIIIIIJJJJJK;KpKKKKK@LALMMMMMOOOOO P9P:PPPPPP Q-QRQSQmQQQFRWRRR0SxSSTQTTTTUIUUUUUEVFV[VVV3W4W@WRWeWxWWWWlXmXNYOYPYYYZZZ=[>[$\%\&\\\____ `!` !d#$J&s&&).*+J-.X00246R89L:A BCEFGI$KNOS:TTUXY3[m\c=e-f ghi6jmqrsvw8yz){{}^~ WؗqVXYZ\]^_`bcdefgijklmopqrstvwxyz{}~W$8:H\^%"9";"M"a"c"t"""BBDDDDDDDDDDDDDD VV3bGbIbccd#dtt:::::TTTTTTTTT:TTT: u|~ tz|+13agj!t!t!!!!!P:l,2$闲0àt-(@n  (  \  3 " \B  S D"\B  S D" \  3  "   \B  S D" \  3  "   \B  S D" \B  S D"\B  S D"2\B  S D"w\B  S D"lnB @ 0D"nB  0D"nB  0D"nB  0D"RB  s XD.@TT"\  3  "  \  3  "  \B  S D"\B  S D"\B  S D"\  3 " V  C A ?"\  3 "( B S  ?**./ /22LD=a}abbKcLcMcNccc+dldmdd/d tTtvtVz!Vgt5AGtVVtag"at a;at =t8 t !tA , t tttstwttte Yt  t6 t#g4$;++ڝڝ&01%.ܟ 24dl$;CEai  = MP !**Heg'mu ! !;!B!$$2%4%>(D(z(}(((o)s)A*D*j+n+,,,,----~//Y0g011>1A133a3e3X99~<<==>?AABBDDJJ$K*KYK_KKKKKOP%P-PLPZPQQVS\SSSSSnTtTU VVVVVW2WXWcWlWvWWW6Z;Z_'_aac#cddn n-n5nTnbnoo]qcqqqqqtrzrsttttt u7u]uhuqu{uuuuvw(wmw{w~wwwwwwwwx@xBxuxvxxxxxyyMyNy}y~yyyyyyyzzFz0{7{T{[{|E|F|I||}}}2~4~eĒԒ֙}NΜӜCEX\ڝڝ&01%.ܟ 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333;<NN$;V,`,ڝڝ&01 %.ܟSusan Purcell Whitman1C:\WINDOWS\TEMP\AutoRecovery save of Ffm9im12.asdSusan Purcell Whitman1C:\WINDOWS\TEMP\AutoRecovery save of Ffm9im12.asdHBCP1C:\windows\TEMP\AutoRecovery save of Ffm9im12.asdHBCP@\\FTWHBCPFS\SOFTDEV\Sdg\Brian M\testing\Brigham CIM\Ffm9im12.docRohan ChamberseC:\Documents and Settings\rchambers\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\AutoRecovery save of Ffm9im12.asdRohan ChambersIC:\Internet\Courses\COF\01. Capital Budgeting - Other topics\Ffm9im12.docRohan ChambersUC:\Internet\Courses\COF\01. Capital Budgeting - Other topics\Tutorial-1-Solutions.docRohan ChambersUC:\Internet\Courses\COF\01. Capital Budgeting - Other topics\Tutorial-1-Solutions.docRohan ChambersbC:\Internet\Courses\COF\01. Capital Budgeting - Other topics\Tutorial-1-Solutions - Chapter 12.docRohan ChambersbC:\Internet\Courses\COF\01. Capital Budgeting - Other topics\Tutorial-1-Solutions - Chapter 12.doc*4 `*\b@ 0^`0OJQJo(!@\\grant\hp4000psNe01:winspoolHP LaserJet 4000 Series PS\\grant\hp4000psS odXXLetterPRIV0''''\KhC]J \\grant\hp4000psS odXXLetterPRIV0''''\KhC]J Xt@@UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial71CourierGLine Draw 12cpi?5 z Courier NewkWP TypographicSymbolsCourier New# ha,aDB$ d2Q  Chapter 11College of BusinessRohan Chambers