ࡱ> xzw bjbjqq 4Dee11111EEE8},Eq<555554q6q6q6q6q6q6qsov6q16q1155KqVVV^15154qV4qVVn4p5 ȵEnFHp> qaq0qp>IwIw|pIw1p\V6q6qVqIw : Document Based Question (DBQ) Rubric Score of 100-90(5/4)Score of 89-80 (4/3)Score of 79-70 (3/2)Score of 69-60 (2/1)Thesis /10well developed provides a clear road map analytical accurate clearly addresses question comprehensivegood thesis; developed provides a road map with a few main points satisfactorily addresses question beyond simple restatement of questionthesis is limited confused; does not provide a clear road map inadequately addresses question simple restatement of questionno thesis thesis does not address the questionAddresses task /10all aspects of question are addressedthoroughly and evenlyall aspects of question are addressed, though not evenly or thoroughlymost aspects of essay question are addressedessay attempts or fails to address the taskAnalysis /10strongly supports thesis throughout evaluates in depth sophisticated Richly supported with relevant facts, examples and details uses comparisons, connections where appropriatesatisfactorily supports thesis adequate more descriptive than analytical (but attempts to include some analysis) good/complete includes relevant, facts, examples and detailslimited support of thesis over generalized; lacks analysis simplistic includes some facts and detailsinadequate support of thesis incorrect or inaccurate no analysis is present includes no use of accurate or relevant facts and detailsUse of Documents /10 strongly supports thesis with appropriate evidence from documents All the information from documents is cited correctly uses info from documents persuasively as evidence; student understands the meaning of documents careful, insightful analysis and synthesis uses at least 4 documents satisfactorily supports thesis with appropriate evidence from documents Most of the information from documents is cited correctly uses info from documents as evidence, but student only understands basic meaning of documents satisfactory analysis uses some documents (at least 3 used)limited support of thesis unclear references/citations of documents Students uses quotes from documents instead of paraphrasing general or simplistic use of documents because students has limited understanding of documents meaning limited use of documents (uses 2 documents)inadequate support of thesis No documents cited has little or no understanding of documents ineffectual use of documents or no documents usedAccuracy /10 may include few minor historical errors that do not detract from quality of essaymay include minor errors that somewhat detract from quality of essaymajor errors and/or omissions substantial factual errors and/or omissionsOutside Information /10strongly supports thesis substantial/relevant outside information All outside info is cited correctly (OI) satisfactorily supports thesis some relevance but connection is not completely clear Most outside info is cited correctly (OI)limited support of thesis inaccurate or irrelevant examples Citation of outside info is unclearinadequate support of thesis no use of outside information shownOrganization /10Includes a well developed intro and conclusion that appropriately sets up the themes well developed consistently demonstrates a clear and logical plan of organization clearly writtenIncludes a satisfactory intro and conclusion that sets up basic themes/ideas satisfactorily developed demonstrates a clear and logical plan of mostly clearly written Intro and conclusion are present but do not relate to topic and/or are confusing Essay may be missing an intro or conclusion poorly organized lacks focus grammatical and spelling errors throughoutNo intro or conclusion present no plan evident considerable grammatical and spelling errors Total: /70     $&z{  0 1 R S & :  & I J \ ] j k G H U V h_h6CCJaJh h6C5CJaJh_hr?CJOJQJaJh hr?5CJaJh_hr?CJaJh_hr?5CJaJh hr?CJaJmH sH "h h`5:CJaJmH sH "h hr?5:CJaJmH sH 4%&;Pez $$Ifa$$qq$If]q^qa$&$$d%d&d'dNOPQa$z{SBBBB$qq$If]q^qa$kd$$Ifl4r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2 1 S y % & F$If` & F$If` & F$If` & F$If`% & 0 5 6 : SBBBB$qq$If]q^qa$kd$$Ifl4r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2: v   & F$If`gd6C & F$If`gd6C & F$If`gd6C & F$If`gd6C  ! " & P????$qq$If]q^qa$kd$$Ifl4r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2yt)& J ] k H V  7 q & F $If` & F $If` & F $If` & F $If`gd\} & F $If`    6 7 r  5cd,1EP  GHn  7ĵĭĵ梓h_h$cSCJOJQJaJh_h$cSCJaJh^JCJaJh_h\}CJOJQJaJh_h\}CJaJh hr?CJaJh hr?5CJaJh_hr?CJOJQJaJh_hr?CJaJ:q r SBBBBB$qq$If]q^qa$kd$$Ifl4P r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2 d, H 8j & F$If`gd^J & F$If` & F$If` & F$If` & F $If`78Cikvyz{^x;e~op~һҊ{odhhr?CJaJhCJOJQJaJhkw>hkw>CJOJQJaJhkw>CJOJQJaJh_h#XCJOJQJaJh_h#XCJaJh_h$cSCJaJh hr?CJaJh h)5CJaJh hr?5CJaJh^JCJaJh_hr?CJaJh_hr?CJOJQJaJ%jktuvz{SBBBBB$qq$If]q^qa$kd$$Ifl4P r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2{1] & F$If` & F$If` & F$If` & F$If`]^frstxP?????$qq$If]q^qa$kd$$Ifl47r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2yt)x;e & F$If` & F$If` & F$If` $Ifgd#X & F$If` SF555$qq$If]q^qa$ q$If]qgd_kd$$Ifl4r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2p 9d| A`p & F$If` & F$If` & F$If` & F$If`gd & F$If` 89cds|  A_`op˼˼˨娙˼˼˨˼~rWIh_h_5:CJaJ5h hr?B*CJPJ_HaJmHnHphsHtHh hr?5CJaJh h)5CJaJhhCJOJQJaJhkw>hCJOJQJaJhCJOJQJaJhCJaJh_hr?CJOJQJaJh_hr?CJaJhkw>hkw>CJOJQJaJhkw>CJOJQJaJhhr?CJOJQJaJSQOOOOOOOkd$$Ifl4r_ o^ )_ 244 laf4p2 h_h_5:CJaJhjZbhjZbB*PJphh#jh#U 21F:p / =!"#$%HH $$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4,5_55 55/ 2af4p2$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4,5_55 55/ 2af4p2$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4,5_55 55/ 2af4p2yt)$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4P ,5_55 55/ 2af4p2$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4P ,5_55 55/ 2af4p2$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l47,5_55 55/ 2af4p2yt)$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4,5_55 55/ 2af4p2$$Ifl!vh5_55 55#v_#v#v #v#v:V l4,5_55 55/ 2af4p2^ 2 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p8XV~_HmH nHsH tHN`N Normal%B*CJPJ_HaJmH phsH tH DA D Default Paragraph Fontdi@d  Table Normal.a44l44l (k (No List PoP Free Form!B*PJ_HmHnHphsHtHPK![Content_Types].xmlj0Eжr(΢Iw},-j4 wP-t#bΙ{UTU^hd}㨫)*1P' ^W0)T9<l#$yi};~@(Hu* Dנz/0ǰ $ X3aZ,D0j~3߶b~i>3\`?/[G\!-Rk.sԻ..a濭?PK!֧6 _rels/.relsj0 }Q%v/C/}(h"O = C?hv=Ʌ%[xp{۵_Pѣ<1H0ORBdJE4b$q_6LR7`0̞O,En7Lib/SeеPK!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xml M @}w7c(EbˮCAǠҟ7՛K Y, e.|,H,lxɴIsQ}#Ր ֵ+!,^$j=GW)E+& 8PK!Ptheme/theme/theme1.xmlYOo6w toc'vuر-MniP@I}úama[إ4:lЯGRX^6؊>$ !)O^rC$y@/yH*񄴽)޵߻UDb`}"qۋJחX^)I`nEp)liV[]1M<OP6r=zgbIguSebORD۫qu gZo~ٺlAplxpT0+[}`jzAV2Fi@qv֬5\|ʜ̭NleXdsjcs7f W+Ն7`g ȘJj|h(KD- dXiJ؇(x$( :;˹! I_TS 1?E??ZBΪmU/?~xY'y5g&΋/ɋ>GMGeD3Vq%'#q$8K)fw9:ĵ x}rxwr:\TZaG*y8IjbRc|XŻǿI u3KGnD1NIBs RuK>V.EL+M2#'fi ~V vl{u8zH *:(W☕ ~JTe\O*tHGHY}KNP*ݾ˦TѼ9/#A7qZ$*c?qUnwN%Oi4 =3ڗP 1Pm \\9Mؓ2aD];Yt\[x]}Wr|]g- eW )6-rCSj id DЇAΜIqbJ#x꺃 6k#ASh&ʌt(Q%p%m&]caSl=X\P1Mh9MVdDAaVB[݈fJíP|8 քAV^f Hn- "d>znNJ ة>b&2vKyϼD:,AGm\nziÙ.uχYC6OMf3or$5NHT[XF64T,ќM0E)`#5XY`פ;%1U٥m;R>QD DcpU'&LE/pm%]8firS4d 7y\`JnίI R3U~7+׸#m qBiDi*L69mY&iHE=(K&N!V.KeLDĕ{D vEꦚdeNƟe(MN9ߜR6&3(a/DUz<{ˊYȳV)9Z[4^n5!J?Q3eBoCM m<.vpIYfZY_p[=al-Y}Nc͙ŋ4vfavl'SA8|*u{-ߟ0%M07%<ҍPK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 +_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!Ptheme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] D  7  z% :  & q j{]x !8@0(  B S  ? $&1Sy&:kHV7rd k { ^  e   p  9 d | ApsNtNuNvNwNxNyNzN {N |N }N ~N NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhph^h`pCJOJPJQJpho(EHh@ h^h`@ CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHhh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EHohh^h`CJOJPJQJpho(EH _6C#kw>r?$cSjZb` D^J)#X\}@@UnknownG* Times New Roman5Symbol3. * ArialcLucida GrandeTimes New Romanc0000҉0 Pro W3Times New Roman?= * Courier New;WingdingsA BCambria Math#AheG G31 1 !xr#QP(r?2!xx5DOCUMENT BASED QUESTION (DBQ): Generic Scoring Rubric Todd DavisThe Bronx H.S. Of Science|                       Oh+'0 8D d p | 8DOCUMENT BASED QUESTION (DBQ): Generic Scoring Rubric Todd DavisNormalThe Bronx H.S. Of Science17Microsoft Office Word@@Rf@V@,01 ՜.+,00 hp  Department of Education 6DOCUMENT BASED QUESTION (DBQ): Generic Scoring Rubric Title  !"$%&'()*,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefhijklmnpqrstuvyRoot Entry FIȵ{Data #1Table+wWordDocument4DSummaryInformation(gDocumentSummaryInformation8oCompObjy  F'Microsoft Office Word 97-2003 Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q