ࡱ> #`  bjbj5G5G 1W-W-§.$.8DD@ h@RL@N@N@N@N@N@N@$Bh?Er@F""FFr@@FnL@FL@6.0\ t` l/TP3 @0@/EV$E800E0 F r@r@z@FFFFDDDDDD_(4DDDDDD(  Martin V. Pusic MD MA Teaching Portfolio  Statement of Teaching Philosophy My medical education teaching philosophy is actually quite simple: I enjoy it. To this day, I can remember my first experience in the role of medical teacher when, as a July 1st intern I carefully explained, to the July 1st medical student, that when evaluating an ankle sprain it is very important to expose the non-affected ankle. While my first teaching script might not have been earth-shattering, it was the first step in a fascinating trip through the worlds of medical education, clinical research and now education research. As I progressed through my clinical training first in Pediatrics and then Pediatric Emergency Medicine, I became more and more fascinated with the problems of teaching and learning in the hectic emergency department environment. It gradually became clear to me that there was a certain underlying order to the process that was no less rigorous than that in a classroom setting. The scholarship of David Irby and others demonstrating the science of teaching in ambulatory settings was a revelation. I believe that the process of learning in ambulatory settings can be bolstered through explicit attention to instructional design and the interleaving of programmed instruction into the cognitive apprenticeship of medical learners. I have had significant roles in all levels of medical education. I have directed a Fellowship program at two different institutions, been a fourth year course director, actively taught in residency and clerkship programs and have organized and participated in a number of CME courses. In each I have tried to structure my teaching according to the principles of adult learning first espoused by Knowles. Specifically, I have anchored the design of learning activities in the clinical context believing that relevance and a problem-centered focus are important not only in CME but also for the clinical clerkship. I began my clinical career at the same time that the PC revolution began. It was impossible not be excited by the possibilities that this new tool brought to all areas of clinical care but not least for education. I have been designing learning interventions ever since, believing that, if we can find the correct context for them, computer learning interventions can significantly improve the efficiency and effectiveness of learning in clinical settings. While I have done a number of clinical research studies, my scholarly focus has been on the development and evaluation of educational learning interventions in ambulatory clinical learning environments. I have actively looked for opportunities where the new technologies could improve learning without detracting from patient-centered learning. There have been a number of important influences on my work. Richard Mayers studies show that properly designed multimedia learning activities can decrease cognitive load and increase uptake. Lave and Wenger and Dan Pratt have shown the importance of the Apprenticeship perspective in medical education while Ruth Bowen and David Irby have made this explicitly relevant to education in ambulatory settings. Bordage, Norman and Columbias Hillary Schmidt and Vimla Patel have explained many of the cognitive underpinnings of this process. I first came to Columbia in 2000 to get a one-year Masters Degree in Informatics. While my perspective was always educational, I gained a wonderful appreciation of how computer science can benefit the Health Care enterprise and specifically just how numerous the opportunities are for embedding educational material in the clinical process. I also was bitten with a desire to learn more about the intersection between clinicians and knowledge. In 2004 I returned to Columbia to work with the inspiring Hillary Schmidt, Steve Miller and John Black. While it has not all worked out, I have been fortunate to make excellent progress in the PhD program under the supervision of Dr. Black. I have found that the deeper I delve into the theories of education and the more I learn about how to answer the questions that arise, the more clear it is that the opportunities for development and evaluation in ambulatory care teaching still seem boundless. Teaching Responsibilities and Pedagogical Approach Courses Taught: 1. Medical Students a) University of B.C. Effective Learning Skills for Medical Practice INDE 453 is a multi-disciplinary course that will illustrate the importance of, and develop skills related to: question formulation, information gathering, and critical evaluation of the literature, decision-making, as well as advanced communication in relation to clinical practice. Assimilation and effective dissemination of medical knowledge is a pervasive theme of all components of the course. The course strives to help students acquire predispositions and skills that will enable them to effectively begin their medical practice, and to continue learning and developing throughout their careers. (10 Credits) I have skills in Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) having completed the McMaster Course, attended a Cochrane Collaboration Meeting and have been a collaborator with an AHRQ funded EBP Center. I taught Evidence-based Practice in this course one year and was asked to run the course the next year based on positive feedback from the students. I am still involved in the redesign of this learning through an oversight committee. As course director, my responsibilities were to develop over-arching objectives for the 10 week course and to recruit and support component captains. SessionCourseScheduled ClassHours TaughtNumberHoursSizeLecturesTutorialsCommentWinter 2002INDE 453Individual Week Tutor11classes x 12 students10 x 4hrsEBP Tutor for PediatricsWinter 2003INDE 453Course Director124 Students210 x 4 hoursAdministration and oversight of >6 subsection captains b) Columbia University: Clinical Preceptor I work 16-18 clinical hours per week in the CHONY Pediatric Emergency Department where I precept medical students during my shifts. I seek to make the students comfortable in what can be a daunting environment. My teaching model is based on the one-minute preceptor method espoused by Irby and others. A key component is that the students take ownership of their patients and see themselves in an active role that includes committing to a clinical management plan and effectively communicating that plan to both their colleagues and the patient. c) Columbia University, University of B.C., McGill University, University of Calgary: PEM Computer Tutorials. Over the years, I have developed a suite of sixteen computer tutorials for medical students and novice residents on a wide variety of situations that they may encounter in the PED. The tutorials are meant to be done in conjunction with seeing a patient either as an advance organizer before seeing a patient with a relevant condition or afterwards as an opportunity to reflect and organize their thoughts. At McGill we performed an impact evaluation of the tutorials which is appended to this teaching portfolio as is a link to a demonstration site. In the most recent calendar year, the tutorials were used over 1000 times at Columbia and at a similar rate in the other institutions. The nature of this student-patient-preceptor-computer tutorial interaction will be the subject of my PhD Thesis. 2. Residents a) Columbia University: PEM Computer Tutorials. Many of the tutorials described above are directly relevant to residents either when they are just beginning their program (e.g. Asthma Treatment) or in specialized situations (Interpretation of Cervical Spine X-rays in Trauma). b) Columbia University PEM Didactic Program. When I took up my appointment in 2004 there was no regularly scheduled teaching for residents on rotation in the PED (Pediatric Emergency Dept). The first year I developed a Mock Code Teaching round each Tuesday morning that involved having the residents role play the management of simulated critical care cases, the type that come in to the PED only rarely but are extremely important when they do. During the year I expanded the role of our fellows in presenting these cases so that by the second year they were exclusively running the Mock Codes. This past year we introduced a new Didactic program in which, every Thursday morning, we modeled for the residents (and interested students) optimal knowledge retrieval skills placing an emphasis on the principles of Evidence-based Practice. Using a case based approach, we would generate a clinical question to which no one had a ready answer. The residents then went off to search for answers. During the search Dr. Maria Kwok and I would coach them on optimal literature searching strategies and which resources are best. We emphasize that this is an important clinical skill at the level of interviewing or physical examination skills. It too, needs to be developed and practiced. c) Columbia University Pediatrics Morning Report. Our Department Chair approached us to lead an effort to inject the principles of EBP into the residency program. Again working with Dr. Maria Kwok, one of our junior faculty members, I developed a 4-session one hour critical appraisal series which we delivered weekly for a year. The sessions are entitled Question, Diagnosis, Therapy and Prognosis, major areas of discussion in EBP. These are learner-centred sessions where the residents on ward rotation developed a question in the first session and then looked at diagnosis, therapy and prognosis aspects in subsequent sessions. After a year of leading the sessions, we transitioned to a Chief Resident lead model in which they lead all of the sessions with fading support from us. The sessions have been very successful so much so that recently the Chiefs approached us to help generate new sessions on more advanced concepts. d) University of B.C., University of Montreal, Columbia University Tablet Computer Radiology Teaching File. In this funded project, we are developing an image database for learning support of residents as they view x-rays for their patients. The Tablet computer, mounted right beside the PACS machine, presents fully labeled x-rays along with normal age and pathological variants. A simple version is presently implemented at U.B.C and, with programmers in Montreal, we are expanding the number of cases in the file to over 300. We plan a formal evaluation. See IRB protocol in Appendix. e) Columbia University, University of Toronto. Repetitive Practice for Learning X-ray Interpretation. We have collected authentic x-rays on consecutive patients from the PED at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto. We have more than 400 cases each for Ankle, Forearm and Chest x-rays which we will use for a Flash Web application that presents the cases as unknowns to resident learners. Currently, in a typical rotation, a resident may learn from 5-7 cases over month. By affording the opportunity to practice on 100s of x-rays, we anticipate improving the efficiency of learning of this important skill. f) Columbia University. Mentorship of Senior Resident Chief of Service Presentations. We review the residents every other weekly Chief of Service presentations making certain that the presentation is as evidence-based as possible. 3. Pediatric Emergency Medicine Fellows a) American Board of Pediatrics Section on Pediatric Emergency Medicine:  HYPERLINK "http://www.pemfellows.com" www.pemfellows.com This site has been primarily the inspiration of our Senior Fellow, Dr. David Schnadower who has organized a collaborative site where Fellows in PEM across the nation can communicate, share files and links, and store all sorts of digital resources online. I am the lead faculty member on the development team. b) Columbia University, Pediatric Emergency Research Canada. Online Research Methods Course.  HYPERLINK "http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.html" http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.html This 11-module course takes a beginning clinical researcher through the entire process of writing a grant. Funded by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada and more recently a Canadian Institutes of Health Research Team Grant, this resource will be a core text for the research training in at least 7 PEM fellowship across Canada and in our institution. I do monthly research methods for our three PEM fellows, using the online course as the core material. Student Mentorship: Graduate Students Supervised Student NameProgram TypeYearMy RoleStartFinishSeamus NortonPediatric Resident20012004Research SupervisorPublished work Academic Gen Pediatrics FellowshipKaren BlackPEM Fellow 20002001Research SupervisorPublished workMichelle ClarkPEM Fellow20032004Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM, VancouverSimi BharyaPEM Fellow20022004Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM, Vancouver; Medical Education RoleAmal YoussifPEM Fellow20022004Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM in Saudi ArabiaMatar Al-HajoojPEM Fellow20012003Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM in Saudi ArabiaZoe LeatherbarrowPEM Fellow20022004Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM VancouverFahad Al-HammadPEM Fellow20012003Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM in Saudi ArabiaSaleh Al TamimiPEM Fellow10/0106/02Fellowship Director; Research SupervisorChair, Emerg Medicine, Riyadh; Published workSamina AliPEM Fellow07/0006/02Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM Edmonton; Fellowship DirectorLisa EveredPEM Fellow07/9806/00Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM Edmonton; Research Director; Published WorkTimothy Lynch PEM Fellow07/9807/99Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM London, Ont; Fellowship DirectorHelen KarounisPEM Fellow07/9806/00Fellowship DirectorAttending PEM Montreal; Fellowship DirectorJoseph ZorcPEM Fellow07/9605/98Research SupervisorAttending PEM Philadelphia; Published Work Undergraduate Students Supervised: I have funded and directly supervised 22 summer students for the development and evaluation of computer tutorials destined for clinical learning environments: Nursing Students: 3 Medical Students: 11 Computer Science Students: 3 Education Students: 1 Pharmacy Students: 3 Teaching Evaluation Forms: 1. Medical Students Clinical Precepting of Medical Students 2005-2006 College of Physicians and Surgeons at Columbia University Childrens Hospital of New York Only seven evaluations available table includes all info available Every text comment listed. AspectMean Rating 1-4 Scale 3= Above average 4= ExceptionalEasy to Understand3.4Ability to identify important aspects3.4Ability to organize and summarize3.6Ability to Direct3.6Accessible3.4Range of Knowledge3.4Ability to Integrate3.6Scientific Information3.4Ability to anticipate problems3.4Can make situation interesting3.4Relates well w patients3.6Demonstrates clinical acumen3.4In contrast to other teachers you have encountered, how would you evaluate this faculty memberss ability to teach? 8.4 / 9 Free Text Comments (all included): Dr Pusic was very helpful with getting me involved in hands on care in the ER and teaching practical skills Dr. M. Pusic is an extraordinary preceptor Dr. Pusic is a great attending a good physician with good clinical judgement. He is always pleasant to work with and always willing and eager to teach 2. Residents No attending specific evaluation forms are available to me. Most Recent Resident Lecture: Pediatric Radiology Feb 19/ 2006 Columbia University Dept of Emergency Medicine Residency Lecture Series 15 Evaluation Forms Received Lecturer appropriately used evidence from research: n/a -1; Agree 8; Strongly Agree 6 Lecturers presentation skills were: Good 3; Excellent 12 Organization style was: Just right 15/15 Free Text comments (all) Excellent! I really like the new teaching program youre working on Great lecture, I learned a lot; Dr. Pusic is very knowledgeable on lecture topic Excellent organization, informative, succinct Great examples; great presentation Great visual aids Please do more lectures I really enjoyed this lecture and feel it was useful to my practice Attending Comment Great job Case-based visual stim is great way to learn/teach A part two would be welcome 3. PEM Fellows Our Fellowship program is too small (3 fellows) for blinded unbiased feedback. 4. Continuing Medical Education Most Recent Grand Rounds Presentation: Patient Education as Wonder Drug April 22, 2005 University of B.C. Dept of Pediatrics Grand Rounds combined with PEM Update Course 31 Evaluation Forms Received Overall Rating: 1 Poor; 4 Good; 13 Very Good; 10 Excellent Relevance to Practice 1 Poor; 5 Good; 14 Very Good; 8 Excellent Delivery and AV 1 Fair; 5 Good; 10 Very Good; 12 Excellent References: 1. Dr. Elizabeth Wedemeyer, Pediatric Residency Program Director, Columbia University  HYPERLINK "mailto:eaw1@columbia.edu" eaw1@columbia.edu 212.305.8504 Can discuss my impact on the Pediatric Residency Program 2. Dr. Meredith Sonnett, Director Pediatric Emergency Department, Columbia University  HYPERLINK "mailto:fs84@columbia.edu" fs84@columbia.edu 212.305.9825 My director; can discuss educational impact on the Division 3. Dr. Peter Dayan, PEDNET (Pediatric Emergency Department Northeast Team) Principal Investigator, Columbia University.  HYPERLINK "mailto:psd6@columbia.edu" psd6@columbia.edu 212.305.9825 Research Director; can discuss research aspects of my program Course Development and Instructional Delivery I first became interested in medical education research during my Pediatric Emergency Medicine Fellowship where my research project was a randomized controlled trial of an interactive text-based computer tutorial compared with a standard lecture on ENT emergencies in children. I found that even a rudimentary text-based tutorial could increase test scores as much as a lecture. As a junior faculty member of the Johns Hopkins Children's Center, I obtained an Ambulatory Pediatrics Association Special Projects grant to develop computer tutorials to be implemented in the Pediatric Emergency Dept (PED). This has been a central theme of my academic activities ever since. This project resulted in two publications. The first was a survey of 75 pediatric residents to assess their attitudes towards Computer-aided Instruction (CAI). We found that the residents were generally positively disposed towards CAI though they rarely purchased such materials on their own. While they valued any learning format that included a human teacher more highly than CAI, computer tutorials were preferred to other supportive materials such as textbooks and journals,. Encouraged by these results, I wrote and installed two one-hour computer tutorials in the Johns Hopkins PED. These tutorials were meant to supplement a didactic lecture series that had been inconsistently attended by residents due to scheduling difficulties. We tracked use of the tutorials using computer log files. Over a 9 month period, the tutorials delivered 49 hours of instruction to individual residents. Over 25% of the interactions occurred during evenings and weekends when regular didactic teaching was not available. One of the most important lessons was that 60-minute tutorials are too long for a resident to complete in a busy clinical environment. The residents generally took 2-3 sessions to complete a given tutorial. However, these tutorials remain in use at the Johns Hopkins PED to this day. Playing a form of career leapfrog, my wife and I moved first to Halifax and then Montreal where I continued to do CAI projects. In Halifax I created a novel e-mail teaching intervention that solved a unique teaching problem. I presented Mock Codes each Monday morning in which residents would role-play leading the resuscitation of a critically ill child. As usual, attendance was a problem. In addition, the trainees had little time to reflect on their learning before picking up their clinical duties for the day. To amplify the residents' learning, I created an e-round in which I e-mailed the residents with a summary of the day's case and its main learning points. In addition, I sent out a second e-mail with a provocative question meant to extend the discussion beyond the content of the Mock Code. Each Friday, the residents' responses were collated with an "expert" commentary. At the end of the academic year, I carried out a modest survey of the 16 residents. Their attitudes towards the eround were universally positive with the majority of the residents reading the e-mails. Interestingly, they rated the e-mail summary of the morning's code more highly than the subsequent discussion. Many of the residents saved the e-mails and referred to them later. A description of the intervention and the results of the survey were published in the Journal of Emergency Medicine. However, a more telling endorsement of the technique lies in the fact that the residents voted me to receive the Dalhousie Universitys highest residency teaching award. In Montreal, I resumed my study of the use of computer tutorials in the PED. I created a suite of six tutorials on common PED problems. Learning from my Hopkins experience, I shortened and focused the tutorials so that they would take a trainee only ten minutes on average. In addition, I envisioned developing a delivery mechanism in which the tutorials would be a supplement to the clinical encounter. That is, instead of being an optional activity to be done in down time in a place removed from the main clinical activity, I hoped that the tutorials would become an integral part of the workflow of the trainee. For example, if the trainee were to see a patient with a fracture, after the clinical encounter, they would do a 10-minute tutorial on the classification of growth-plate injuries to reinforce their learning. The tutorials were designed for medical students and were presented on a dedicated computer in the central nursing station of the PED. We evaluted the impact of the tutorials using utilization tracking and a randomized controlled trial. The students used the tutorials a great deal 539 times over a 9-month period. In addition residents and allied health professionals also availed themselves of the tutorial. The student's attitudes towards the tutorials were uniformly positive and they rated them more highly than scheduled didactic sessions that were allotted three times more time. The students gained knowledge from the tutorials that supplemented their learning from other sources. When exposed to a tutorial on a given topic, a student showed a 56% greater gain in test score on a corresponding question when compared with their scores for questions for which they were not exposed to a tutorial (overall effect size 0.39). Only a small percentage of the tutorials were used in a "just-in-time" fashion ie within 8 hours of seeing a relevant patient. This is likely because of the paucity of tutorials (students were randomized to only three of the six available tutorials) and the large number of preceptors who were not aware of the specific content of the tutorials despite the investigator's best efforts. However, on an subgroup analysis, tutorials done in this coupled manner seem to be even more effective. In subsequent years, I dedicated myself to expanding the number of tutorials available. With the considerable aid of medical, nursing, education and computer science students, we have developed a suite of sixteen tutorials on a whole series of PED topics ranging from Seizure Classification where a series of clinical videos of different seizure types are presented to Oral Rehydration Solutions where, using animations, we explain the molecular basis for why rehydration solutions are preferable to, say, juices in cases of dehydration. Our emphasis has been on bringing complementary instructional content and strategies to the clinical environment. In contrast to the situated cognition movement where authentic messy contexts are brought to the classroom to increase the transferability of abstract concepts, I have tried to bring the best of the classroom to the clinical setting in an effort to scaffold the learners development of robust mental models that can help them develop clinical reasoning skills. These tutorials have been successfully installed in the PEDs in Montreal, Vancouver, Calgary and the Childrens Hospital of New York. In the latter institution, they were used 1000 times in the last calendar year. An overview is appended. We are preparing the tutorials for publication. In addition, this installed base will serve as the platform for my Thesis research (described below). In 2001 I completed a Master's Degree in Medical Informatics at Columbia University. The core curriculum in medical informatics presents computer science theories and methods as they specifically apply to Health Care. In addition, I took elective courses in the Faculty of Education in Cognition, Instructional Design and Educational Technology in order to better understand how to implement CAI in clinical environments. While there I worked with two cognitive psychologists to perform a cognitive task analysis of learning to interpretation of x-ray films. This resulted in a case-demonstration abstract that is currently being prepared for submission. Collaborating with Dr. Steve Miller of the Dept of Pediatrics and Dr. Vicki LeBlanc, then at the Center for Education Research and Evaluation, I carried out a two-site RCT comparing two different presentation formats for computer tutorials on the topic of x-ray interpretation. The first presentation format is a 65 screen linear presentation analogous to a PowerPoint didactic lecture. This tutorial has embedded within it 5 unknown cases that the trainee can attempt to solve by clicking on the area of suspected pathology directly on an image. The second presentation format uses exactly the same 65 screens but presents them in a goal-based scenario based on the 5 unknown cases. The other 60 screens are available to the student behind hypertext links that the student can access in any order they wish. We randomized 139 students' to one or other of the tutorials with the main outcome being the difference between pre- and post-test scores interpreting a set of x-rays. We found there was no difference in the knowledge gain between the two groups but that the web group was more efficient. University of B.C. In October 2001 I took up an appointment at UBC where I was appointed to 35% clinical activities in the Division of Pediatric Emergency Medicine with the rest of my time protected for educational and research activities. My projects spanned the range of medical education from undergraduate through to faculty development. I was a co-investigator for a systematic review carried out by the Alberta Research Centre for Health Evidence looking at the use of information systems meant to translate health evidence into better clinical outcomes. This group has considerable experience in the creation of systematic reviews which was complemented by my informatics background. The main result of the study was the finding that, across a broad range of information systems, clinical outcomes could be improved by an often modest amount. Specifically, physician adherence to guidelines was increased from 52% to 58% -- far from ideal! I was the course coordinator for INDE 453: Effective Learning Skills for Clinical Practice. The goal of this course is to allow all UBC medical students in their final 4 months of training to return to the classroom to solidify their evidence-based medicine techniques and to synthesize their knowledge before moving on to residency. I took over this course one month before its start and was able to create four online tutorials on the subjects of literature searching, bibliographic software, evidence-based practice online resources and systematic reviews. From afar, I continue to be involved in the re-design of this course, something I had pushed for! I was a co-investigator on a project lead by the Molson-McGill Medical Informatics group which also includes investigators from McMaster and the University of Ottawa. The goal of the project was to develop an integrated e-learning tool using an object-driven template to facilitate the creation of on-line interactive medical cases. This template includes interfaces that: a) permit easy, user-friendly development; b) uncomplicated access to shared learning object repositories (National Medical Digital Repository, the eduSourceCanada network of repositories and HEAL); and c) straightforward integration of multimedia objects located in these repositories. Project development is ongoing. For postgraduate trainees, I spearheaded a UBC resident effort to create a Learning Management Site in support of the pediatric residency program. Goals and Objectives, Faculty Presentations, Web Resources, Readings, Assignments, Schedules, Forms and even take-out menus are featured on this password protected site. I was also active in Faculty Development being a member of the UBC Faculty Development Steering committee. I also originated and coordinated both the monthly UBC Medical Education Grand Rounds and the Medical Education Research Special Interest Group. Both activities continue to this day at UBC. PhD Training at Teachers College In 2004, my wife and I had the opportunity to return to New York to wonderful career options: she as a reconstructive surgeon at Memorial Sloan-Kettering resuming a program of research in patient-reported Quality of Life while I was able to take on a role in the Division of Pediatric Emergency Medicine which allows me to progress on a PhD track under the supervision of Dr. John Black, a pioneer in the field of Cognitive Studies of Human Learning using educational technology. I have completed essentially all the coursework, passed my Certification Examination and completed my Empirical Paper requirement. I am now intensively working on my dissertation proposal which will look more closely at one of the key findings in the McGill computer tutorial study (see Figure 2 in the appended manuscript) in which it appears that students may learn more from a computer tutorial if it is timed to coincide with a relevant patient contact. I hope to have the proposal approved this spring and begin data collection over the summer. Plans for a Medical Education Research Career As I wind down my PhD studies in the coming year, I hope to take on a role at Columbia University which will allow me to continue my studies into the nature of learning in clinical environments. I can envisage a coherent program of research where we can use computer Learning Probes to better define clinical learning. We would deliver carefully defined standardized instructional packages at various points in the instructional/clinical process to contrasting effects. There are many questions we can look at including: Can we empirically evaluate ambulatory teaching models like the one-minute preceptor using standardized pieces? Can we augment the student-patient-preceptor interaction to include: Repetitive practice? Protected time for reflection? Meta-cognition? Are there order effects? Which is more powerful an advance organizer? a post-encounter opportunity for generalization? a blend? Which pieces of knowledge need to be learned and which are simply fodder for a clinical decision, to be forgotten once the decision is made? What is the nature of the interaction between Clinical Decision Support Systems and medical education? What are the curricular implications of this? What are the implications for Information System design? How much do the computer tutorials encumber the legitimate peripheral participation of medical students? Is their participation in authentic activities diminished? How do they perceive their roles with and without the added infrastructure? What are the faculty development implications? In this distributed cognition model, what teaching should remain with the preceptor and what can the technology help with? Can we involve the patients? I could go on and on (and, in fact, hope to.) Educational Leadership and Research Membership in Professional Education Associations: American Educational Research Association: 2004 present Canadian Association of Medical Educators: 2000 present Society for Academic Emergency Medicine: 2001 present American Association of Medical Colleges RIME 2001 present Association of Medical Educators of Europe 2002 -- present + various clinical memberships: CAEP, APA, AAP Education Meeting Attendance: 2007 Association of Pediatric Program Directors*, AERA (April), SAEM* (May), CAEP*(June) 2006 SAEM, Pediatric Emergency Research Canada* 2005 AERA, Slice of Life*, AAMC* 2004 CAME*, SAEM*, AAMC, Slice of Life * denotes presentation given Relevant Publications: Pusic MV. Pediatric residents: are they ready to use computer-aided instruction? Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998 May;152(5):494-8. Pusic MV, Johnson K, Duggan A. Utilization of a pediatric emergency department education computer. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2001 Feb;155(2):129-34. Pusic MV, Taylor BW. E-mail amplification of a mock code teaching round. J Emerg Med. 2001 Apr;20(3):307-14. Pusic M. Health Informatics. In Moyer V, Elliott EJ, Davis RL, Gilbert R, Klassen T, Logan S, Mellis C, Williams K, editors. Evidence-Based Pediatrics and Child Health, 2nd Edition. BMJ Books, London. Chapter 15, pp 139-150;2004. Pusic MV, MacDonald WA, Pachev GS. Embedding Medical Student Computer Tutorials into a Busy Emergency Department. Acad Emerg Med 2007 Feb; 14(2);138-148 Recent Abstract Presentations: Pusic M, LeBlanc V, Miller S. Linear versus Web-style Layout of Computer Tutorials: Which is Better? Plenary presentation at Slice of Life Conference for Medical Multimedia Educators June 2005; Oral presentation at AAMC Annual Meeting November 2005. *Athwal K, Esani K, Youssif A, Pusic M. Learning X-ray Interpretation in Context: A Tablet PC Resource for the Emergency Department. Plenary presentation at Slice of Life Conference for Medical Multimedia Educators June 2005; *Medical Student Pusic M, Joubert G, Reed M. A Prototype Tablet Computer for Learning Emergency Department X-Ray Interpretation. Innovation in Emergency Medicine Education Exhibit, SAEM Annual Meeting, Boston, June 2003. Pusic M, LeBlanc V, Patel V. A Cognitive Task Analysis Facilitates the Design of Computer-Aided Instruction. Case Demo at the Amercan Medical Informatics Association Annual Meeting, 2001. Recent Invited Presentations: 2007 MayAssociation of Pediatric Program Directors. Workshop Teaching Evidence Based Practice to Pediatric ResidentsToronto, Ontario2007 JanuaryPediatric Emergency Research Canada Annual Meeting. Open Access PublishingBanff, Alberta2007 JanuaryPediatric Emergency Research Canada Annual Meeting. A National Research Methods CourseBanff, Alberta2006 DecemberUniversity of Western Ontario Pediatric Emergency Medicine Grand Rounds. Research Methods for PEM FellowsLondon, Ontario2006 DecemberColumbia University Division of Pediatric Emergency Medicine Symposium. The New RSI: Rapid Sequence Internet for PediatriciansNew York, NY2005 OctoberPediatric Grand Rounds, McGill University Computer Aided Instruction in Medical EducationMontreal, QC2005 April Pediatric Grand Rounds, University of B.C. Patient Education as Wonder Drug Vancouver, BC2004 June Pediatric Grand Rounds, University of B.C. Knowledge Translation for CliniciansVancouver, BC Teaching Awards: IWK-Grace Health Center Pediatric Resident Teaching Award. 1998Dalhousie University Resident Teaching Award. 1998Childrens & Womens Health Centre of B.C. Attending of the Year Award. 2003 Columbia University Dept of Pediatrics Residency Program Runner-up Attending of the Year Award 2006 Peer Reviewed Competitive Fellowships: Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada Medical Education Travelling Fellowship. 2000Fonds de la recherche en sant du Qubec Training Fellowship. 2000Canadian Institute of Health Research Training Fellowship. 2000 Educational Committee Service (Member): U.B.C. Dept. of Pediatrics: Pediatric Education Executive Committee, 2001-2004U.B.C. Dept. of Pediatrics: Faculty Appointments, Reappointments, Promotions and Tenure, 2001-2004U.B.C. Faculty of Medicine: Information Technology Management Committee, 2002-2004U.B.C. Faculty of Medicine: e-Learning Steering Committee, 2002-2004U.B.C. Faculty of Medicine: Undergraduate Curriculum Evaluation Committee, 2002-2004U.B.C. Faculty of Medicine: Faculty Development Steering Committee, 2002-2004B.C. Childrens & Womens Research Institute: Research Education Committee, 2002-2004U.B.C. Faculty of Medicine: Year 4 Restructuring Committee Representative Workshops Given: "Developing a Computer Based Education Station for Pediatric Residents". Ambulatory Pediatric Association Annual Meeting, New Orleans, Louisiana. May 1998. Designed and Presented the Workshop"Creating Multimedia Computer Tutorials for Pediatric Residents". Ambulatory Pediatric Association Annual Meeting, New Orleans, Louisiana. May 1998. Designed and Presented the Workshop"Developing a Computer Based Education Station for Pediatric Residents". Ambulatory Pediatric Association Annual Meeting, San Francisco, CA. May 1999. Designed and Presented the Workshop"How to Practice Evidence-Based Child & Womens Health". Sponsored by UBC Dept. of Peds and Cochrane Child Health Field, Vancouver, B.C. Mar 2002. Designed and Presented the WorkshopScientific Chairman, 166th North Pacific Pediatric Society Conference, Vancouver, B.C. Mar 2003. Arranged all conference speakers for this 150 clinician 3-day conferencePutting Evidence Into Practice Workshop, Emergency Medicine Small Group Session Designer and Leader, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, October 2003Creating Interactive Computer Tutorials for Students or Residents, University of B.C. Faculty Development, Vancouver, B.C. Mar 2003. Designed and Presented the WorkshopRapid-Sequence Internet: The New RSI for Clinicians, 2006 Steven Z. Miller Annual PEM Symposium, Columbia University, New York, NY Dec 2006. Designed and Presented the Workshop Grants Received: Granting AgencySubjectCOMP$ Per YearYearPrincipal InvestigatorCo-Investigator(s)Ambulatory Pediatrics AssociationComputer Tutorials in the Pediatric Emergency C10,0001995Martin PusicKevin Johnson Anne DugganCanadian Association of Emergency PhysiciansPredictors of Sequelae Post ConcussionC50002000Martin PusicSamina AliCIHR Training GrantJust-in-time Learning in the PEDC68,0002000Martin PusicJames CiminoFRSQ Training GrantJust-in-time LearningC89,0002000Martin PusicJames CiminoRoyal College Medical Education Travelling GrantJust-in-time Learning in the PEDC21,0002000Martin PusicJames CiminoB.C. Childrens & Womens Research Institute Establishment Award NC50,0002001-2002Martin Pusic Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical ResearchComputer-based delivery of health evidence: a systematic review of the impact on clinical practiceC69,9982002Terry Klassen, Alberta Research Centre for Child Health EvidenceMartin PusicMcGill Molson Medical Informatics ProjectJust-in-time Learning in the PEDNC21,0002002Martin PusicWendy MacDonald David FleiszerAssociation of Canadian Medical Colleges - CIHR Medical Education GrantConstructivist versus Behaviourist Strategies for Learning X-Ray InterpretationC16,0002002Martin PusicVicky LeBlanc, Steve Miller, Columbia UniversityUBC Teaching and Learning Enhancement FundJust-in-time Learning in the Pediatric Emergency Dept. C49,0002002Martin Pusic Royal College of Physicians and SurgeonsA Problem-Based Online Research Methods Course for Subspecialty FellowsC23,3472002Martin PusicMorrison Hurley, Ruth Milner, U.B.C.Michael Smith Foundation for Medical Research Research Unit FundingCxx?2003Shoo LeeNikki Shaw, Mark Ansermino, Martin Pusic UBC Teaching and Learning Enhancement FundJust-in-time Learning in the Pediatric Emergency Dept. C42,0002002Martin PusicJoan Fraser, Sandra Whitehouse, Navid Deghani, Deborah HewesRoyal College of Physicians and SurgeonsClimbing the Learning Curve: A New Approach to Teaching Non-radiologists Radiology InterpretationC50,0002005Martin Pusic Kathy BoutisUniversity of Toronto Deans Excellence FundClimbing the Learning Curve: A New Approach to Teaching Non-radiologists Radiology InterpretationC50,0002006Kathy Boutis Martin PusicCanadian Association of Emergency PhysiciansA Tablet Computer For Interpretation of Pediatric Emergency X-raysC5,0002006Michel RoyMartin Pusic Teaching Activities with Groups Outside the University 2006-present.  HYPERLINK "http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.html" Pediatric Emergency Research Canada Fellow Research Methods Course.  We developed a successful online research methods course (see Course Development Section) at the University of B.C. We have modified the 11-module course to be presented to PEM Fellows in all 9 training programs across Canada. The development of the course is described earlier. For this multi-center project, I am the overall coordinator responsible for identifying local champions and editing/revising/updating the course in response to Fellow suggestions. 2006-present.  HYPERLINK "http://www.pemfellows.com" www.pemfellows.com I am the faculty sponsor of a fellow-developed website dedicated to improving the communication of PEM fellows across the >40 Fellowship programs in the U.S. and Canada. The site includes a number of functions including sharing of presentations, EBP materials, web links, web discussions, information sharing etc. Sponsored by the section of Emergency Medicine of the American Board of Pediatrics and by the MS-CHONY. APPENDICES TO TEACHING PORTFOLIO 1. Descriptions of Medical Student Computer Tutorials 2. Curriculum Vitae Standard 4-Page Version 3. Online Teaching Portfolio Demonstrations and Downloadable Material 4. Key Article Embedding Medical Student Computer Tutorials Into a Busy Emergency Department  Pusic MV. Pediatric residents: Are they ready to use computer-aided instruction? Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998 May;152(5):494-8.  Pusic MV, Johnson K, Duggan A. Utilization of a pediatric emergency department education computer. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2001 Feb;155(2):129-34.  Pusic MV, Taylor BW. E-mail amplification of a mock code teaching round. J Emerg Med. 2001 Apr;20(3):307-14.  Pusic MV, MacDonald WA, Pachev GS. Embedding Medical Student Computer Tutorials into a Busy Emergency Department. Acad Emerg Med 2007 Feb; 14(2);138-148  A demonstration of the tutorials can be downloaded at  HYPERLINK "http://www.pusic.org/cv/TP/TP-Appendix.htm" www.pusic.org/cv/TP/TP-Appendix.htm  Pusic M, LeBlanc V, Patel V. A Cognitive Task Analysis Facilitates the Design of Computer-Aided Instruction. Case Demonstraction at the Amercan Medical Informatics Association Annual Meeting, 2001.  Pusic M, LeBlanc V, Miller S. Linear versus Web-style Layout of Computer Tutorials: Which is Better? Plenary presentation at Slice of Life Conference for Medical Multimedia Educators June 2005; Oral presentation at AAMC Annual Meeting November 2005.     Martin Pusics teaching portfolio is available with all hyperlinks at:  HYPERLINK "http://www.columbia.edu/~mvp19/TP.htm" www.columbia.edu/~mvp19/TP.htm ,-./01QRS  2 4 ng`VRNRNRNRFRFRh<hH*hDNhh imHnHsH hh hh i#h CJOJQJfHq hIrh CJaJmHsHh 5CJaJmHnHsHjh UhIrh 5CJaJmHsHhu\hIrCJ aJ h 5CJ$\aJ$mHsH"hIrhIr5CJ$\aJ$mHsHh 5CJ$\aJ$#jh{hqZ5CJ$U\aJ$,-/01RSl m J K !gdgd igdgdOg':$a$:gdIr:¯^  Q   b J K N !EPq*Z[ǿvove^ hT~hFhT~hF5CJ hDN5CJhT~hT~5CJhT~hFCJhT~hFCJ\hT~hF5CJ\hm 5CJ\ hFhFhFhF5hFhFhDh ih imHnHsH hQJ5hQJh{1h5 h{1hhDNh5hDNh hDNh$!'4 $$Ifa$gdzgdB|gdFgdFgdDgd i/;45cFGast! "#&#|###3$$,%-%=%W%n%%%n&&w'((*b+|++-U/}/%1C1b1d1e11ƾƵưưƬƬѨї}сh6hdT h>5h>hmM" hmM"5h7hXhX5 hX5hXhsiH hm 6 hm 5hFhm hm 5hm hB|hB|hDN hDN5h)LQ h)LQ5hB| hFhFhT~ hT~hT~ hT~hF/456=CHQ[cxlllllll $$Ifa$gdzkd7$$Ifl4rW w%'G%4 laf4cdkpyRIIIIIII $Ifgdzkd8$$Ifl4֞W ww%' G%4 laf4Ikd9$$Ifl4֞W ww% '  G%4 laf4 $IfgdzEFGt!!ID???gdm gdB|kd:$$Ifl4֞W ww% '  G%4 laf4 $Ifgdz! "$$,%-%<%=%U&V&((c+d+//c1d13344444t566A9C9gdm 111a2f23334'4B4M4444555\5]5^5p5q566r666 7 7<7=7>7`7a7b7c78@9A9B9C9E9Z9[9}vrni hv46hFhOI hm hm hm hahDN hah\haha0J3j<hahaU hahajhahaU ha5hahih\0J3j;h\Ujh\U h\5h\h\5h\hDNh6hdT hdT5)C9D9Y9Z9w9x999999 $$Ifa$gdF 0^`0gdF gdv4gdF [9w9x9999999::$:%:k::::::=?> ? ??/?0?1?2?X?Z?????????@@1@2@G@H@e@f@{@|@@@@ A A.AOAPAlAnAAAûѳh=\hKxyh h)LQh hB|>*h h)LQ>*hFhI5hIhB|hB|5>*hB| hB|5 hv45 hB|6 hv46hHhv4 hF5hF hF6;99999999xllllll $$Ifa$gdzkd=$$Ifl4ruUJ%T)%4 laf49999999:$:e\\\\\\\ $Ifgdzkd>$$Ifl4ֈuU J%*T)%4 laf4$:%:1:=:B:G:[:j:e\\\\\\ $Ifgdzkd@$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4j:k:z::::::e\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdA$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4::::::: ;#;e\\\\\\\ $Ifgdzkd,B$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4#;$;1;<;A;F;Z;x;e\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdBC$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4x;y;;;;;;;e\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdXD$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4;;;;;; <<$<e\\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdnE$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4$<%<5<@<E<J<^<|<e\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdF$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4|<}<<<<<<<<e\\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdG$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4<<====3=B=L=`=e\\\\\\\\ $IfgdzkdH$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4 `=a=m=x=~======e\\\\\SSS $Ifgdv4 $IfgdzkdI$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4 =======>>*>\SSSSSSS $IfgdHkdJ$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4 $Ifgdv4 *>>>?>N>Y>_>e>y>>\SSSSSJ $Ifgdv4 $IfgdzkdL$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4 $IfgdH>>>>>>>>>>\SSSSSS $Ifgdzkd2M$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4 $Ifgdv4 >> ? ? ? ? ?1?2?\KKKKK 0^`0gdFkdVN$$Ifl4ֈuU J% *T )%4 laf4 $Ifgdz2?????@2@H@I@J@e@f@{@|@@ APAlAmAnAgdB|gdIgdB| gdB| & F gdB| 0^`0gdF ^gdHnAuAAAAAAA[H$Ifgd=\lCzkdzO$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 la$$Ifa$gd=\lC$IfgdB|lCAAAAAn[E$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdO$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 la$$Ifa$gd=\lCAAAABB+B/B;B?BSBWBmBqBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCCCCC\DDDDDE EFEbEzEEEFFFNHHHHH III0I1I2IþȯȪȡhQJhQJ5 hQJ5hQJ hF6 hI6hH hMh{*hM hF>* h{*>*hIhj0hFhI5h h 6 hnK6 h 6h)LQh{*h=\h h ^J9AAAAq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkd>P$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laAABBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdP$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laBB+B/Bq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdQ$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 la/B0B;B?Bq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdmQ$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 la?B@BSBWBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdQ$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laWBXBmBqBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkd7R$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laqBrBBBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdR$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laBBBBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdS$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laBBBBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdfS$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laBBBBq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdS$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laBBCCq[$$Ifa$gd lC$Ifgd=\lCzkd0T$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laCCCCq[$$Ifa$gd=\lC$Ifgd=\lCzkdT$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laCCCCCqq[$$Ifa$gd=\lC$IfgdB|lCzkdT$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laCCCCq[$$Ifa$gd=\lC$IfgdB|lCzkd_U$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 laCCCCC-D.D[D\DDDE EEEvvvvvqqqqgd{*^gd gdB|zkdU$$Ifl0r$ t0$644 la EEFEEEEELFFFFFGqGGGGGNHZHHHHHHII1IgdQJgdH^gdIgd{*1I2IIIIIFJJJJJJ?KKKKLmLLLMrMM & F gdB| & F gdj0gdggdB|^gdMgdM & FgdM2I|IJJ@KAKgKhKiKzK{KKKL LFLGLHLYLZLmLLMMMM$M'M(MNMOMPMaMbMqMrMMMMMMMM۶ۋ|x|nhdmHnHsHhdh ihF hB|hB|hj0hihj00J3jWhj0Ujhj00JDUhj0hj00JDj WhgU hj00JDhihg0J3j)VhgU hg0JDjhg0JDUhghB|hMhMhM>**MMMM^O_OUU[[bb}d~djjllppArBrtt5w6wygd0gddgdF 0^`0gdFMMMN!N#NRNTNNN]O_OOOaPcPxPP#Q$Q%Q(QpQwQQQQRRR&ReRfRRRRRiSwSTTUUUU#V$VyVzVWWWWWWCXDX0Y1YZ[`[b[r[[[[[[[[[[C\E\Z\[\\\]]m_z_____SbbhH hQGhHjh00JFU hQGh0h0Xbbbdminiiij]j`jjjjjjjkkfljlxlllllAmnnoooNpmppppp q qqq2q3q4q8qqqqqqq@rCrssssssssttttuuvvv7w8w;wwwxxyyzzzz({+{,{/{R{ h05h'&'hp&jh00JFUh0 hQGh0Xyy){*{T|U|V|y|z|łƂ8}ۃ :C & F *$gd0 & F *$gd0 & F *$gd0gd0R{X{{{{{ |U|w|x|C~Y~Ă89^`%&ORĈۈ܈KLVij¸|h mHnHsHhU=mHnHsHhemHnHsHh@mHnHsHh7mHnHsHh{bmHnHsHhLmHnHsHhtTmHnHsH h 5hdhdmHnHsHhKIh05 h>1h0hKI h05 hQGh0h0,C҄9g F>]^_`&b܈gd@gdLgdLgdtTgdgddgd0 & F *$gd0 & F *$gd0܈KLjʼnCcd{|gdKIgd-Pgdgxgdu?xgdZ|gd gd gd gdU=gdegdLĉʼn̉Љ%&,-Cbcdmpz{|˷˷췪|||oe[hKIhu?>*^Jh ^JmHsHhgh ^JmHsH h ^Jh0Bh >*^JhtTmHnHsHh mHnHsHh{bmHnHsHh h g9mHnHsHh g9mHnHsHhU=mHnHsHh mHnHsHhU=hU=mHnHsHh{mHnHsHh<mHnHsHh2FmHnHsH#Yfvwύ͎Ԏsz123ɽzpzpjpd^ZhD h-^J hl^J hm!^JhKIhKI>*^J hKI^J hg^Jhghg^JmHsHhKIhKI>*^JmHsHhKIhKImHsHh-mHsHhr<h-^J h^J h|o^Jh[*hr<^Jh[*h[*^J h[*^J hr<^Jh0Bhr<>*^Jh[*hu?^J hu?^J"s12QR[͑ޑߑ:I|fkdX$$IflF9# t6    44 la P$Ifgdzgd gd-Pgdg 39:BPQRޑߑ9:HJΒϒ;<KMZ[ݓޓTUacno˔͔הؔ)*79:;L  Iý鳭h(hxhVhh ^JmH sH  hh ^Jh0h05\ hK^J h^JhmHnHsH hhh]fdhD^J hD^Jh h-h-h h-h )EMpkfaSSS$P$Ifa$gd gdze5gd-gdyAkdc$$Ifl,#64 lap P$IfgdyAkdc$$Ifl,#64 lap 45ܠݠ=> |}ޥߥ 678<=֨ר9:;<GHab3 h h h  hKI^J hze5^Jhhze5^Jhho/k^J ho/k^Jhho/k5^J hze5hze5LMR]blyDkdNd$$IflX֞Tm#Y64 la$P$Ifa$gd ޠ$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd AhjotRGG999$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd kd(e$$Ifl=֞Tm#Y64 lat¡ġ9kde$$Ifl|֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd ġˡСݡ9kdf$$Ifl0֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd #0=$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd =>oRGG999$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd kdg$$Ifl|֞Tm#Y64 la9kdxh$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd  QLkdLi$$Iflֈm#2Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd £;9kd j$$Ifl$֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd ;\_fkx$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd 029>RGG999$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd kdj$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la>K|}9kdk$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd '9kdl$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd 'oqx}$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd ަߦRGGGGGG P$Ifgd kdZm$$Ifl|֞Tm#Y64 la 567 P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd 78cRGG999$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd kd.n$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la9kdo$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd 9kdo$$IflS֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd ר:<CHUbc$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd cdԩ֩ܩRGG999$P$Ifa$gd  P$Ifgd kdp$$Ifl֞Tm#Y64 la94/gd gd-kd~q$$IflE֞Tm#Y64 la P$Ifgd $P$Ifa$gd 45\]gdKrt & FgdKrtgdKrtgdKrt^gdwgd<^gd#ggdBvgd gd 345EFvwxKUpǬȬɬ۬ܬ߬꿻{qgqh8ymHnHsHhKrtmHnHsHhKrthwh+h<0J3j!sh<Ujh<Uh<hh#ghHhBvh>[mhQVh !yhuXhKIhuX0J3hKIh;30J3jRrhKIhKI>*U hKI>*jhKI>*Uh;3h h-'[\¯ïįɯIJKP2VWXY/0ױ|k`TjhP;OJQJUh=chP;OJQJ!jh=chP;0JFOJQJUjhP;0JFUhhP;mHsHhP;hhP;>* hhP;jhhP;0JFU-hKrthKrt5CJ\]^JaJmHnHsHhKrt5CJaJmHnHsH#hKrthKrt5CJaJmHnHsHhKrtmHnHsHhKrthKrtmHnHsH]¯HIVW[\\]^`acdfgiPgd0Egd0gd0^gdKrt  & FgdKrt0CQhij\]]^_abdeghjk{|ncnTjh';whP;OJQJUhP;5OJQJ\hOChP;5OJQJ\#hP;5OJQJ\mHnHtHu2jhOChP;5OJQJU\mHnHtHujhP;UhVhP;jhP;0JFUhihP;0J3OJQJjhP;OJQJU#j thihP;OJQJUh=chP;OJQJhP;OJQJij >gdOg'$a$gdOC$a$gdy ÿ-hKrthKrt5CJ\]^JaJmHnHsHhVhP;h';whP;0J3OJQJjh';whP;OJQJU#j5uh';whP;OJQJUh';whP;OJQJ /1h;0/ =!"T#$8% 7Dd , Z\0  # Abf7<KhpWpB7Dn:7<KhpWpPNG  IHDR]HVsRGB6IDATx^}}̥u~x7`^dVcRᣭ* K1"R,#6H(VeHm@ U l?BV%cjj n6nش0 ,w잝83<>Zs~3sΜ>CǷO?|_߾y8ǎ@;ګzMG @o|sQp\-l-_W!{(*1 eab/pc>]d4/8k+^}k:x+$Vv+ǻv%#A;> .yH֢;8? O}ւ'pxWQea mn` -l /~Hʞ\.F7~)Ft!-YY5cPՇwPR x^֙Qca]("A~U`+\xGuBUB^{*O*WO5O>YǦqDz1G`db9*TBgC<)k14~b}~>1Ut$ɨIJ&ZQkٰK5@!@mj*pAG4PQy`h\Ojs{Zd8!0OU8|n'Y7P^b+6LVh|* D5zU>XU>Sx5WJ)qP; Z#Lfah/eV=S raẌ*N4s Gtp@-n0S%I cJ$ZG LzH Dv[A` h4^2uȹ\m{Sª ]ޯtV̕#e; /b45r@)s %/< M[Q@drR/*otiRwGhϪy;A`SH A¶b095Q%j ZD/N4ojSh'hV2k9 -C6,MQM1f+E/>ɧx/ iBůha9x-L-#UfS/s:2M9[O>Z(A :ZȠlhFlD33RT%|Y!4gV匥|SHf%#079p+Bፁgo#a|>r%@d|qj "^+2OyA!#΋()Dz4h3^X2sS'g05z{t1H4n#b1qJx*_R?TkKm2i*D|=' Whh!SD' _q"nj$yIG`My2ڍùrCu\K4B8XD^gnv'tNd[:9@F#0sS!R:bgd.v͟ԮrXvFhX:f_2MLРQPݑS̓^gۑ~oXs{# Bi7B@D x ڇDXB|,J#-^kEۈTPŻu<_᯻*J=9z޵E!qHGP |Ix0D#bw hO؋9ܔǺt5 ID'&>x-`82NjC=8k:7}  'OG`Mpʁ R-7XB>Jo@H悏#0V>UVTxvpjd;=p\y pP 8g9ʀ<zQD5?1pՊr45NJ=bW9hy5F-  ASt ~6s ʣ ވ#86k[Gp ʣ ވ#8ncmi[߰Y:#_<=Olk;;zkmS^pG`R(qS߾*IyG?Ogܺw=)#W)S TǞ[ ]W~>x9[gM8byn>I.h͕`_z%1CNR>ɎEs欖B4idesKGJ 5~Bm )~-b\6gt9}?!#Q͎]ObϏ߸]*|eh  oMhs$ qe }nZ5XbSYÄwa[Nsnk`sK*4ϕ6iSD gQ/U/w[Mb Oot!j Mf3zZcVFt#ts]^}/I,*^`wj'Hl:g|/mtRockg JZ$36"p{6譭 C@>`.C lVʷ<Bx ȅ|d_z`>wtP?LU}P eBh& W"/ -uU{gxiQ.06r#_~ke\-Nyw 5Z^>!9X2+  % 5Z|'}毛tFfT-Pn LzAÆM^h$lmLEd]8_2wޝ#8aސ;6ϵwtL.RW9MT]d:>K##/sy'.Ju^Кh* OR2Su5%^h #(NZ 1zL' %GjrxJy@ċmxft4Hh9q2? Y;ςW]hE@0'k-AyXLp<H&?pjc=3C SҸXŹ-b*wޥ rq`TXG6va+] +jtdsH.uBDS=aX̨X@wH E/q^/l+n>}=G^o:P|yK#ڄSR 觪m?`*Q tgiP5 YQ`(k=zXkO5z4ZZk8:1zR1 #F?p\3eϏ7s޻Js,6xQZ2x @ rM cJՈ*\+رn[z&QtGGܗzdf& p/ɀj/ɧ=npLe-3`XoL5;"aٌԯڎY^?CqQySKFG#fw|ze.P@Ag_w`0x[KOgi]{GUQxǩ:WloU7\qwU /7ϊ{=scs?&'.o Hߘ`rXs}юú\(-Տ6_D| d.|mQ_!4k1GAc?Fc,l[)l^/ˁ"K.@jcɝzw؅xہ'^]hpe6j͡O*egR5l[`J/~:1b)9k) Xr1:jt yo~橁ֆ`L2}+-@umF(b1e _IҗW`Ru9I$~)y4N/dJL>7? IeCݿN޲@@Q$eX j30^^':Aa3Ƅ/+uU [^Y |4lHƑsњt+.Ƴ48^[FN4Qb1yC_`:ڏ]XNM xc-"kj )ɆZ\NG-iEvbÆyd'JLy~2Ӡ(E]z$ dqt|"):dNXN r W*Ԃw=L .7~ZT%n7=t/\lރ#ءU* Ǜ8#0 9#>wA;#"Sy{km^pG`\ɟ}u_:ʚ_Pj*o8Wԓu, 1?ser#@]^z~t<_]DeM=S8o"@{ [ԥ hས4޹h f êɆ_78^%:+,kgxזzX氠eE Qқ,镌&!xGr%̦STWORΆ͑}Q<pcb{.mذbț-1ŝT[oowY8ܺfKٗIљ1 8|(] Zv.#Q(⽵MyC`s`jmxO׿du[z`lBTmTMІZU^hF xwn]| qYXpA0Ȱ ZtCT443v^eY~-wR~#4l%H4v|VSaCw4d^‚-XfEu3XISBnsT?n@_S1zQvt󗧎a:6TGL?s[O|-\,:L?Z;2yݡ+s^cВT*LBv,VuSEO2 mTYQ3y!%\*‘XQԸ lZ<]@v塥9ӡT7*H} zT|ak:'?(yͺ ̣G3GjP#iH6#f[wFA!y ۪(;VoKZch ?61#3ZN2ڣ/GGSBuMoJOpj . 33v27l׎ ٹ$س1vVMiÞT`0 qYꝎ5,T"ΩQ`gjģBb6O!&DLuסCېBpk5i^BVyS]ёk­Q׶ꩋc- vP\+^j^K 7am4 S>[ gF kU # +eHFa0gPE#p/}8TDn)+j9YvWx5xl_#IL2:-*D!$hh܎a۬kAPjo"2bg}v8m-Do8<M'5HszK1 y2AKFS(9&Qs#"S Zkyt3Wyދ3mlp5=W\QŖ(GL.fR0EbaWAFF z(b;|#E1Ac h׽95"a08*:XzaqqW@1~ lW~h9 j0hφ>{!ƥ4όc_ݩ2-GSXƺcXZeqJ[3BmYQ!EƔ-| Uvq[yF9F3oo  "ѫT*갂ٱra4mmJFĊ&p1Z@;|9Fq_Rז9,e)NQVQn+yAG* dD/ 2TLJwҌ4 шh!ꆍ.ԑ?z߿B;~ի%zF" ^`Jc[1Nfi~7{f-'؋]Q5cٿXÔ2,=2sErȎ$5󭊪! ubYNx&/"9 J0*#{*<*6j۬ ޶ꨖ1gHUuO'M|b=mnѥeV|Xeȟ~N3m, m ecZ*ޕFMcr÷D'm9&6Մ ` zqCf3X]|#L=gAKaK\2.hR3CuzB1sv*ǣqaGm%X(:$eb?3 D)ԋo~yIwԋRF d 6&x-`4\Eb77pλR)=tQ!猘+>:@S-)ƈ)ODVU`GQRE+ݎUyP9_YkyEGpz!P醷cr[> 77;gp@yir1qL#zԞ 8N#>lQ{v$ݬIyhsɼǹs""K͎"b] 4*GopͲ;]SOvYyp G`@ )Nr,mn}v<=Kh)Gŷ.S`yD*w1u#xCםxßޥ78@wpx{כ`qULkG,C.2,S'd;y#;luwG@Nyy#83@ <ӂi1apGX/<֋pG` xc {# W#tVn=|x %I]is)/mb|N̴eDhuvx D!C'PL禌cɾDMuw<*ޣ/QflC kC>ǟ9j6À[(zK#I<*8NYgnWĐ@Cx!H~JnW좌*n l-k z6ͷ^5P&`ëm__/yklՌ ?S./~2B\"Zz2$P'*}6-SySlMfM@' |ߌrM`y @vos c؅rZO"z_Q7}Iu+ڠ^{uĠ/0޷ m^ EHݗ_J`AoI[F9ߩ: ."Eg 葊 zi"nYP%TT!YܝZjN*(,&):~*F_(y ˓ F\`C .=sC;  d1=5z"7*ܗXFtJiĉ: JgR(\!|-/ànf,PأG(" !5EP.b꼀Zait =h) S"߯V],dNSU1X9P~n+"j7D19R? c=Ө J] =oi"IsSDz8MfbEGp/ ,o`9?ᮜAUQ'^`775 ERUAmZ[>Y ҉aЗh*$G),]@jJQˢ!z03a`raBEZza/l^@/ [gVQ5B$rb_XsfpLVZsp_j޾@Rd07/Z(q=U63XdX[YKfkyw@oEyØi00R?E"xIk_gx1暉jNzWNMSn +`@(\ҟl0X24+0?`V0o!S;Tƚ(ߐCV2K (y=[0.跖5#tlN.9^RX{y(g _rBXHfR u6, m2Q2sMfO̭:p6 3[;.Y/_Ld9^eWJe) 5JFY}v-:k`3:"`VN:!0S`Zñԩ%~yQ$^T_\o0MV7[aſc _j6SJ^R7B˒bFXMy}gjۤQH;Q[Xshk)]FgʏzX|!̲63Z#VkT pj!ogTֱlGG֛ԷI w*l)dG"ŝER4 #:vIkя7E-U=@ϒ˔g2ڠnwޓQԍ u B<7 Zc<LzW1JR1k`S 'fj>5 JcS/;Jźz Qs;kG6)jqVLK(W; OpGؙ`gq_;c>b^Ʈ :I`Q!5h3z`j=[5lfJYm*[6e#,$uZ l|U3o4Vկ0搳,Q<:\f| [a`z+ ֚!WĐEwcDgYVF&؁7˙2nwHEnQJqwMގmʀh'ENY,5˙=ْ'nL9XOprB1yW//NI8'=G1 jܾ5Aٍ-Ƈ|!-/LI4I/q }z#<)vk 2ΒAt-;+xi@Rh 7a0*% _%;$D„deQPqJaX؅Xz0| :eoz P`o/z-MQZhb`0xńb́ę+ ?yU@ERSn:4;)K _\BVv;cGqfu o9>pB~Ϫ9]졔8bEЌ ZQ *Kt@RRR0,1f곍tߘ fH 1a2xGd]59,y0OW <-'(QA{K1uF 7B2yQWH[ \y A:(&GuϛsZpU+r^gZo?ny[t9;L+{IG`<[o(#(%&['8DR0}4 X\܍IENDB`$$If!vh55555'#v#v#v#v':V l4G%5555'/  /  / /  4af4$$If!vh5555555' #v#v#v#v' :V l4G%5555' / /  /  / / / /  / 4af4$$If!vh5555555' #v#v#v#v' :V l4G%5555' /  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh5555555' #v#v#v#v' :V l4G%5555' /  / / / / / /  4af4DyK www.pemfellows.comyK Nhttp://www.pemfellows.com/yX;H,]ą'cDyK #http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.htmlyK ^http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.htmlyX;H,]ą'c$$If!vh55555T#v#v#v#v#vT:V l4)%,55555T/  /  / /  / 4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/ / / / /  / 4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / /  4af4"$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / / /  4af4"$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / / /  4af4"$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / / /  4af4"$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / / /  4af4"$$If!vh555*555T#v#v#v*#v#v#vT:V l4)%555*555T/  / / / / / /  4af4]$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$655c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55c$$If!vh55#v#v:VCl t$6,55DyK eaw1@columbia.eduyK Jmailto:eaw1@columbia.eduyX;H,]ą'cDyK fs84@columbia.eduyK Jmailto:fs84@columbia.eduyX;H,]ą'cDyK psd6@columbia.eduyK Jmailto:psd6@columbia.eduyX;H,]ą'cs$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 s$$If!vh555 #v#v#v :V l t6555 X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p X$$If!vh5<(#v<(:V l,<(5<(4p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p [$$If!vh5Z$#vZ$:V l,654p $$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V lX6,5555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l=65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l|65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l065555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l|65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh5A50555F5;#vA#v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65255555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l$65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l|65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V lS65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V l65555555Y4$$If!vh55 50555F5;#v#v #v0#v#v#vF#v;:V lE65555555Y4DyK yK ^http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.htmlyX;H,]ą'cDyK www.pemfellows.comyK Nhttp://www.pemfellows.com/yX;H,]ą'c+DyK $www.pusic.org/cv/TP/TP-Appendix.htmyK nhttp://www.pusic.org/cv/TP/TP-Appendix.htmyX;H,]ą'cDyK www.columbia.edu/~mvp19/TP.htmyK dhttp://www.columbia.edu/~mvp19/TP.htmyX;H,]ą'cGP@P LNormal$*$1$A$a$OJQJ_HmH sH tHL@L  Heading 1$ & F@&5CJ mHsHh@h tT Heading 2@& & F & F<$5CJOJQJ\]^JaJP@P Heading 3$ & F<@&5CJOJQJDA@D Default Paragraph FontVi@V  Table Normal :V 44 la (k(No List 2O2 WW8Num1z0OJQJ6O6 WW8Num1z1 OJQJ^J2O2 WW8Num1z2OJQJ2O!2 WW8Num2z0OJQJ6O16 WW8Num2z1 OJQJ^J2OA2 WW8Num2z2OJQJ2OQ2 WW8Num3z0OJQJ2Oa2 WW8Num4z0OJQJ2Oq2 WW8Num4z1OJQJ2O2 WW8Num4z2OJQJ2O2 WW8Num5z0OJQJ2O2 WW8Num5z1OJQJ2O2 WW8Num5z2OJQJ2O2 WW8Num6z0OJQJ6O6 WW8Num6z1 OJQJ^J2O2 WW8Num6z2OJQJ2O2 WW8Num7z0OJQJ2O2 WW8Num7z1OJQJ2O2 WW8Num7z2OJQJ2O!2 WW8Num8z0OJQJ2O12 WW8Num8z1OJQJ2OA2 WW8Num8z2OJQJ0OQ0 WW8Num9z0>*54Oa4 WW8Num10z0OJQJ4Oq4 WW8Num10z1OJQJ4O4 WW8Num10z2OJQJ4O4 WW8Num11z0OJQJ4O4 WW8Num11z1OJQJ4O4 WW8Num11z2OJQJ4O4 WW8Num12z0OJQJ4O4 WW8Num12z1OJQJ4O4 WW8Num12z2OJQJ4O4 WW8Num13z0OJQJ4O4 WW8Num13z1OJQJ4O4 WW8Num13z2OJQJDA@!D Default Paragraph Font6U@"16 Hyperlink B*ph>*FV@"AF FollowedHyperlink B* ph>*NObN Heading 5x$CJOJPJQJ^JaJ2B@b2 Body Text6CJ(/@ar( List7^J<"@< Caption8$<a$CJ.O. Index9 $^J0>@0 Title:$a$CJ0:J@b: Subtitle;$a$CJ056P@6 Body Text 2<CJ4@4 Header = !4 @4 Footer > !RY@R Document Map?-D(M OJQJ^J`C@` Body Text Indent"@ 8]^8`CJjR@j Body Text Indent 2"A <]^ ` CJ6]jS@"j Body Text Indent 3"B@ <]^@ ` CJ6]n@3n =\ Table Grid7:VC0C*$OA glgP@RP 0 Footnote TextE*$OJQJ\]^JtH @&@a@ 0Footnote ReferenceH*#ILRWmadh "5       z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z! e)E17<EUdVt3V# pj#.M 0 $   !,-/01RSlmJK ! !'456=CHQ[cdkpyEFGt ,-<=UV c#d#''c)++,,,,,t-..A1C1Y1Z1w1x11111111111111111112$2%212=2B2G2[2j2k2z222222222222 3#3$313<3A3F3Z3x3y333333333333 44$4%454@4E4J4^4|4}444444444555535B5L5`5a5m5x5~55555555555566*6>6?6N6Y6_6e6y666666666666 7 7 7 717277777828H8I8J8e8f8{8|88 9P9l9m9n9u999999999999999:::+:/:0:;:?:@:S:W:X:m:q:r:::::::::::::;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;-<.<[<\<<<= =E=F=====L>>>>>?q?????N@Z@@@@@@AA1A2AAAAAFBBBBBB?CCCCDmDDDErEEEE^G_GMMSSZZ}\~\bbdhhAjBjll5o6oqq)s*sTtUtVtytztxxxxxzz8{}{{{{{{ |:|C||9}g}} ~F~~~>]^_`&b܀KLjŁCcd{|s1QR[͉މ߉:IJWϊ<LM[ދUbcǒ͌،*89:;LÍč~ NO tuː̐mnUVWXxy<=tu !ij !45>EMR]blyޘAhjot™ę˙Йݙ#0=>o Q›;\_fkx029>K|}'oqx}ޞߞ 5678cנ:<CHUbcdԡ֡ܡ45\]§HIVW[\\j #O####V#####v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v: #v:#v:#v:##v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:v:8v:8v:v:Ov:u:v:8v:8v:v:v:v:Ov:u:v:v:8v:8v:v:v:v:Ov:`v:v:8v:8v:v:v:v:Ov:`#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v: #v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:###v:#v:v:v:v:v:|v:u:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:u:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:tv:v:Rv:v:v:|v:tv:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:tv:v:Rv:v:v:|v:tv:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:tv:v:Rv:v:v:|v:tv:v:Rv:v:v:v:|v:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:|v:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:|v:|v:K$ v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:|v:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:|v:v:v:Rv:v:v:|v:|v:|v:`#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#[#[#[#[#[#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:v:Fv:Fv:Fv:Fv:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:Fv:u:v:v:Fv:`v:Fv:u:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#[#v:#v:#v:#[#v:#v:#v:#[#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v: #v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#Y#v:#v:#v:#v:#[#v:#v:#v:#v:#Y#v:#v:#v:#Y#v:#v:#[#v:#[#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:###v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:v:v:D v:uv:v:D v:[;v:v:D v:uv:v:D v:uv:v:D v:uv:v:D v:uv:v:v:v:D v:`v:v:v:D v:t#v:#v:#d'v:d'v:d'v:d'v:#v:#v:d'v:d'v:d'v:#v:#v:##v:d'v:d'v:d'v:d'v:d'v:d'v:d'v:d'v:#v:#v:##v:#v:u#v:[;#v:[;#v:[;#v:[;#v:[;#v:[;#v:[;#v:#v:v:v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:nv:cv:v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:cv:T v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:lv:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:lv:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:d5 iv:iv:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:cv:v v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:\v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:v v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:lv:v:v:v:v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:cv:cv:+ v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:v v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:nv:cv: v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:nv:cv:W v:v:Xv:v:v:nv:cv:6#v:#v:#v:##v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:###v:##v:##v:####v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#v:#]#],-/01RSlmJK ! !'456=CHQ[cdkpyEFGt ,-<=UV c#d#''c)d)++,,,,,t-..A1C1D1Y1Z1w1x11111111111111111112$2%212=2B2G2[2j2k2z222222222222 3#3$313<3A3F3Z3x3y333333333333 44$4%454@4E4J4^4|4}444444444555535B5L5`5a5m5x5~55555555555566*6>6?6N6Y6_6e6y666666666666 7 7 7 7 717277777828H8I8J8e8f8{8|88 9P9l9m9n9u999999999999999:::+:/:0:;:?:@:S:W:X:m:q:r:::::::::::::;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;-<.<[<\<<<= =E=F=====L>>>>>?q?????N@Z@@@@@@AA1A2AAAAAFBBBBBB?CCCCDmDDDErEEEEE^G_GMMSSZZ}\~\bbddhhAjBjll5o6oqq)s*sTtUtVtytztxxxxxzz8{}{{{{{{ |:|C||9}g}} ~F~~~>]^_`&b܀KLjŁCcd{|s12QR[͉މ߉:IJWϊ<LM[ދUbcǒ͌،*89:;LÍč~ NO tuː̐mnUVWXxy<=tu !ij !"45>EMR]blyޘAhjot™ę˙Йݙ#0=>o Q›;\_fkx029>K|}'oqx}ޞߞ 5678cנ:<CHUbcdԡ֡ܡ45\]§HIVW[\\]^`acdfgij :0:0:0:0:0000 0010101010101010101010101010101 00( 0000( 00000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000000000000000000000000000000000( 0( 0( 00Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y10Y10Y10Y10Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y1 0Y10Y10Y1( 00J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J8 0J80J80J80J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J80J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J8 0J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J80J8(001A01A01A01A01A01A01A01A( 00B0B0B 0B0B0B0B 0B0B0B0B 0B0B( 00E00E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E0E 0E 0{E 0L|E 0L|E 0L|E 0E 0|E 0|E 0|E 0|E 0E 0W}E 0W}E 0W}E 0E 0~E 0~E 0E 0E 0E0E0E0E0E0E0E 00( 00ˀ0ˀ0ˀ0ˀ0ˀ0ˀ0ˀ( 00`0`0`0`0`( 0( 00x0x0x0x0x0x0x( 0000000( 00F0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F 0F0F0F 0F 0F 0F 0F0F 0F 0F 0F0F( 00O 0O 0O 0O 0O0O 0O 0O0O0O 0O 0O 0O 0O 0O 0O0O( 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00( 00l0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l 0l( 0 060606 06 06 06 06 0606 06 06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06@06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06@06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 06 06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06@06 @06 06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 @06 0606060606 06 06 06 06 06 060606 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 0606 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 0606 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 060606( 0 000000000 000 0 00 00 00) 0)000E00E00E00E0E0E00E00E000000000000@>00 (,-/01RS!'456=CHQ[cpyEw1x11111111111111$2%2222222#3$3<3A3x3y3333333$4%4|4}44444445555`5a5m5x5~5555>6?6N6Y6_6e66666666 7 799999::/:0:?:@:W:X:q:r:::::::::;;;;;EEEE_GMMytzt&b܀KLjŁCcd{|12QRމ߉IJLMbč͌89:;LÍč~ NO tuː̐mnUVWXxy<=tu !ij !"5>EMR]blyޘAhjot™ę˙Йݙ#0=>oQ›;\_fkx029>K|}'oqx}ޞߞ 5678cנ:<CHUbcdԡ֡ܡ\§HIVW[\\ @:0:0:0:0:0000  0010101  00@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0@0@0@0@0@0 @0 @0 @0@0@0@0@0 @0@0@0@0@0@0@0@0@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 0$0b%L 0%0_&h @0 @0 00M T(@0 @0 @0 00M|T(@0 @0 @0 00$@0 @0 @!6| 00$@!6|' @0 @!6| 0$0M@!6|' 00$@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 j00 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 0000X+00  00 +0000 +0000 +0000 8+000 0 p+000 0 +0000+0 000+0 000P+0 000+0 000+ @0 0 0T000U00@0@0 @ 000030000@0 @0@00  00* 00000000* 000000* 0* 00000000* 00000* 00 00 $@0b02@0b02@0 00t@000 t@00 0 t@0b02@0b02@0 0 0 * 00  0  0  0  0 0  0  0 0 0  0  0  0  0  0  0 0 * 00_ 0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_  0_ 0_ * 00$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$$ 0$* 0 00 0 0 0 0 00 0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0@0@0@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0@0@0@0@0@0@0 @0@0@0@0@0@0@0@0@0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0 @0@0@000@000@000@000@00 0@0J  1[9A2IMbR{3430 [^`fh|4c!C999$:j::#;x;;$<|<<`==*>>>2?nAAAAB/B?BWBqBBBBBCCCCEE1IMyC܈ILb̔8Õ ˘nUuiMtġ=;>'7c]i \_abcdegijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{}~ ]4-]-p- /=/`/@ChCzCDGDYD'EOEaEEwȤۤ XXXXXXXTXmX@  @ (  TB  c $D?< C (  TB  c $D$?- $t }$t OLE_LINK1 _Hlt160938348 _Hlt160938349 @@, 2u찉2u촉2u2u쳉2u춉2u,2ul2u2u,2ul2u,2u,2u2ul2u2ul2u2u2ul2u,q3ulr3us3u,u3uDuv3ul4uDu,4ul5u5u5u,5ul5u5u5u,X6ulDu`6u,a6ulc6uDud6u$7ul%7u7uDuL7u8u8u8uLDu}q^Du2u2uL2u 2uL2u 2u 2uL2u 2u2u,2ul2u2u츋2u,q^lq^2u칋2u,2ul2u2u캋2u,2ul2u2u컋2u,2ul2u2u켋;u,2ul ;u!;u콋";u,;ul;u;u쾋;u,;ul;u=u Du,=ulG@ulI@u@uJ@u,@ulM@u@uN@u,P@ul@uQ@u@u,S@ulT@uU@uW@u,@ulX@uZ@u@u,[@ul]@u Du,^@ul_@u@ua@u,c@ul@ue@u@u,f@ul2u Du2u, Dul2u2u2u,2ul2u2u2u,3ul3u3u3u,3ul3u3u3u,3ul 3u  3u,  3ul  3u  3u 3u, 3ul 3u 3u 3u, 3ul 3u 3u 3u,3ul3u3u3u,3ul3u3u3u,3ul 3u!3u"3u,#3ul$3u%3u&3u,'3ul(3u,)3ul*3u+3u,3u,-3ul.3u/3u03u,13ul23u33u43u,53ul63u73u83u,93ul:3u;3u<3u,=3ul>3u?3u@3u,A3ulB3uC3uD3u,E3ulF3uG3u,H3ulI3uJ3u숧K3u, DulM3us^쉧s^,s^ls^s^슧s^,s^ls^s^싧s^,s^ls^s^쌧s^,s^ls^s^썧s^,b3ulc3ud3u쎧e3u,f3ulg3uh3ui3u,Cu,DulCu KKTAAJZZch#h#q#'#')'7'A'A'J'((i)r)~)~));*;*+++....00k3k33344o4o444B5B55566666688889@:@:I:===AAA+C+C4C D DDEEEMMMNNrSrS|SSSFTFT``````HbHbQbhhhooorryyȳ̄``͉͉։ ::Attϊϊ<<D[[dދދUU_Ɍ**5LLV]ӎӎvv44))ΗΗ>>D ›țțћhhq""0zccm       "!#$%&'(*)+,-/.0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKMLNOPQRTSVUWYXZ\[]^`_abcdefhgijklmnoprqsutvxwy{z|}~   S^^ITTbmmp#{#{#'''3'?'I'T'T'((q)|))))B*B*+++....00w3w333#4#4{4{444J5J555#6#66666888 9 9E:R:R:===AAA3C>C>CDDDE$E$EMMM"N"N{SSSSSMTMT````aaPb[b[bhhhooorr yyy҄҄ffԉ݉݉?HHzzBKKcnn""]aanjˌˌ377U\cc((ََ ǓǓ==ŕŕ 22CKK''ϛϛ؛؛p{{ ,44~loo   "!#$%&'(*)+,-/.0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKMLNOPQRTSVUWYXZ\[]^`_abcdefhgijklmnoprqsutvxwy{z|}~B*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagscountry-region9**urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace8%*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity9}*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsState=&*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceType=)*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceName>$*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PersonName P-}}}}}}}}}}}}}}}}$}}1:;Qy -%4%--22$3(3)303y3~3333333%4*4.444}444444f5l5%6(6E6M66688p;y;<<m@q@BCQQpWxWZZ]^O^Z^``?qNq%&OSĀǀۀ܀KLijāŁЁҁ%(,/CHbdzԂۂ܂krszT[hn gklqυ†Ɇ;L<IOW6<^hțϛ&֟۟ܟNT[]§#$+Ũ2VqwΩҩөة$^{ 1Q! $ V{!!d##((e))))+++',... /00y==.>6>y>>>>{AABBdBhBBBE%EbJdJmWW\!\hh{{ | |:|;||||%&abۀ܀JLijāŁBFbdz|!d%ӄdr{υsz׆4‡0;K$5Bx[]§ħͧ9=KilӨר2UY{}˩Zë!(^ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::1S566#d#4-q-E1Z3y333^4}44435a555*6>6y6667|8Q9u99999:;;;==>>A2AAABB@C{CCDZDmD'EbErEEEEN Ozz}{ |:|C|LjF|g2[͉!Wϊ[Uo،Lč IOXyEuו!:jޘh™> ›\0Ko :dԡEܤ§2W/^ §^  ^v-:ZrBG.nd]=5:LXkf`x$^`^`^`^`^`^`^`^`^`88^8`OJQJ ^`OJQJ^Jo  ^ `OJQJ  ^ `OJQJ xx^x`OJQJ^JoHH^H`OJQJ^`OJQJ ^`OJQJ^Jo^`OJQJ^`OJQJ pp^p`OJQJ^Jo@ @ ^@ `OJQJ^`OJQJ ^`OJQJ^Jo^`OJQJ^`OJQJ PP^P`OJQJ^Jo  ^ `OJQJ^`OJQJ pp^p`OJQJ^Jo@ @ ^@ `OJQJ^`OJQJ ^`OJQJ^Jo^`OJQJ^`OJQJ PP^P`OJQJ^Jo  ^ `OJQJhh^h`>*5.h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hH^`o(. ^`hH. pLp^p`LhH. @ @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PLP^P`LhH.^`OJPJQJ^Jo(-^`OJQJ^Jo(hHopp^p`OJQJo(hH@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hH^`OJQJ^Jo(hHo^`OJQJo(hH^`OJQJo(hH^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoPP^P`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHhpp^p`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHhPP^P`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh  ^ `OJQJo(hH^`o(. ^`hH. pLp^p`LhH. @ @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PLP^P`LhH.h^`OJQJo(hHh  ^ `OJQJ^Jo(hHoh  ^ `OJQJo(hHhxx^x`OJQJo(hHhHH^H`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hH kfG.]=5:xLXv- WW8Num1WW8Num2WW8Num6WW8Num9                   C                                   8g {zOC0W   DysW6|oVv4 FZ|iLfh m!mM"p&'&'Og' ){*i#-j0;3S4 5ze5|5 g9W^:r<>u?KAB2FFsiHKIXIQJKMxP{P)LQ^TdTEUVQV=\u\a{b1b^qhcjo/k ll.l>[mKrt{}v';w\x y !yKxyB|OP;AIqZ63wd[*L8yw>NIrBvU=4-@g tTmrEgm OIeRADN- i7(HnKg+ <% <q.\7txL"a0@#g3B#0XHuX@o800-T~ !'456=CHQ[cdpyEFw1x1111111111111111111$2%212=2B2G2[2j2k2z222222222222#3$313<3A3F3Z3x3y333333333333 4$4%454@4E4J4^4|4}44444444555535`5a5m5x5~5555555556>6?6N6Y6_6e6y66666666 7 7n9u999999999999:::+:/:0:;:?:@:S:W:X:m:q:r:::::::::::::;;;;;;;;;;;;PER[͉މ߉:IJWϊ<LM[ދUbcǒ͌،*89LÍč~ NO tuː̐mnUVy<=tu !ij !5EMR]byޘAhjot™ę˙Йݙ#0=>o Q›;\_fkx029>K|}'oqx} 78cנ:<CHbcdԡ֡ܡ _g@0000 @Unknowngz Times New RomanTimes New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial9Garamond?5 z Courier New;WingdingsG  MS MinchoMS ??5& zaTahomaBAh(3F)3F 3F U0X8!>4dm  3QHX)? !Teaching Portfolio - Martin PusicDr. Martin PusicAndrea & Martin PUSIC8         Oh+'0   @L l x  $Teaching Portfolio - Martin PusicDr. Martin Pusic Normal.dotAndrea & Martin PUSIC3Microsoft Office Word@ @0R`@حv`@q` ՜.+,D՜.+,\ hp  Columbia University0Um "Teaching Portfolio - Martin Pusic Title` 8@ _PID_HLINKSA6-&http://www.pemfellows.com/ra#http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.htmlN? mailto:psd6@columbia.eduLu mailto:fs84@columbia.edu[9mailto:eaw1@columbia.edura#http://www.pusic.org/rmc/home.html-&http://www.pemfellows.com/.*+http://www.pusic.org/cv/TP/TP-Appendix.htmWO&http://www.columbia.edu/~mvp19/TP.htm  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F#%`Data Lv1Table-FWordDocument1SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjq  FMicrosoft Office Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q