%PDF-1.3 % 53 0 obj <> endobj 68 0 obj <>stream 2007-08-24T09:07:03Z QuarkXPress(tm) 6.5 2007-08-24T09:26:57-04:00 2007-08-24T09:26:57-04:00 QuarkXPress(tm) 6.5 %%DocumentProcessColors: Cyan Magenta Yellow Black %%EndComments application/pdf uuid:8045c079-b555-5840-a5e5-d18f8388b188 uuid:96587e4a-ea69-f242-b923-a7116e774bf3 endstream endobj 49 0 obj <> endobj 12 0 obj <>]>> endobj 50 0 obj <>/ColorSpace<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageC/ImageI]/ExtGState<>>>/Type/Page>> endobj 51 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]/ExtGState<>>>/Type/Page>> endobj 52 0 obj <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]/ExtGState<>>>/Type/Page>> endobj 67 0 obj <>stream q 0 0.64 585 782 re W n 1 g /GS0 gs 0 782.64 0 0 re f Q BT 0 0 0 1 k /GS1 gs /T1_0 1 Tf -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 11.5 0 0 11.5 55.5 596.14 Tm [(practically)85(, impossible. I)6(f the goal is mor)9(e modest\321)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(to make W)10(ikipedia mor)9(e r)10(eliable than it is\321then it)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (seems to me that any changes must come at the)Tj 0 -1.087 TD [(expense of its open-sour)6(ce natur)10(e. S)11(ome sor)-7(t of)]TJ T* [(accountability for editors, as w)6(ell as for the origina-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(tors of entries, would be a first step)16(, and that, I)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(think, means that editors must leav)6(e a r)10(ecor)13(d of their)]TJ T* [(r)10(eal names. A mor)10(e rigor)5(ous fact-checking system)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(might help)16(, but ar)9(e ther)10(e enough v)6(olunteers to co)16(v)6(er)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (1.6 million entries, or would checking be in effect)Tj 0 -1.087 TD [(r)10(eser)-18(v)6(ed for popular entries? )]TJ 1.043 -1.087 Td [(Can one mo)17(v)6(e bey)6(ond the world of cut-and-dried)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td (facts to check for logical consistency and r)Tj 0 Tw 15.926 0 Td (easonable)Tj 0 Tc 3.59 0 Td (-)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw -19.516 -1.087 Td [(ness of interpr)10(etations in light of what is kno)12(wn)]TJ T* [(about a par)-8(ticular society in a par)-8(ticular historical)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(period? Can it be done without exper)-8(ts? I)6(f y)6(ou r)9(ely)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(on exper)-7(ts, do y)6(ou pay them or depend on their v)6(ol)-1(-)]TJ 0 Tw 0 -1.087 TD (untarism? )Tj -0.0101 Tc 1.043 -1.087 Td (I)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.593 0 Td [(suppose I should no)12(w go fix the W)10(ikipedia)]TJ -1.636 -1.087 Td [(entr)-18(y for O)6(gyu S)12(orai \(en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O)6(gyu_)]TJ 0 Tc T* (S)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.467 0 Td (orai\). I hav)Tj -0.0101 Tc 4.161 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (been waiting since J)Tj 0 Tw 7.513 0 Td [(anuar)-17(y)]TJ 0.025 Tw 2.837 0 Td (to see ho)Tj 0 Tc 3.357 0 Td (w)Tj -0.01 Tc -18.985 -1.087 Td [(long it might take for the system to corr)14(ect it, which)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(has indeed been alter)10(ed slightly and is rather good)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(o)16(v)6(erall. B)12(ut the statement that O)6(gyu opposed the)]TJ 0 Tc 0 -1.087 TD (T)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.53 0 Td [(okugawa or)14(der is still ther)10(e and still highly mislead-)]TJ -0.53 -1.087 Td [(ing [2]. S)12(omeho)12(w the statement that equates the)]TJ T* [(samurai with the lo)12(w)6(er class in T)120(okugawa J)29(apan has)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(escaped the editors)40(\325 attention, though any)6(one with)]TJ T* [(the slightest contact with J)30(apanese histor)-18(y kno)12(ws it is)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(wr)6(ong. O)5(ne do)12(wn, 1.6 million to go)16(.)]TJ /T1_1 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 10 0 0 10 55.5 208.64 Tm (References)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 55.5 199.64 Tm (1. )Tj 0.015 Tw 1.016 0 Td (Rosenzweig, R. Can history be open source? )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 17.37 -0 Td (Journal of American History)Tj 0 Tw -17.37 -1.125 Td (93, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 1.525 0 Td (1)Tj 0.025 Tw 0.775 0 Td (\(June 2006\), 117\320146. )Tj 0 Tw -3.316 -1.125 Td (2. )Tj 0.038 Tw 1.016 0 Td (Tucker, J. \(editor and translator\))Tj -0.01 Tc 12.807 0 Td (.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 0.518 -0 Td (Ogyu Sorai\325s Philosophical Masterworks.)Tj /GS2 gs /T1_0 1 Tf 0.083 Tw -13.325 -1.125 Td (Association for Asian Studies and University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu,)Tj 0.018 Tw 0 -1.125 TD (2006, 12\32013, 48\32051; while Ogyu sought to redefine the sources of T\ oku)Tj 0 Tc 27.657 0 Td (-)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.021 Tw -27.657 -1.125 Td (gawa legitimacy, his purpose was clearly to strengthen the authority of \ the)Tj 0.025 Tw -0 -1.125 Td (Tokugawa shogunate. )Tj ET 0 0 0 1 K 0.25 w q 1 0 0 1 55.5 126.265 cm 0 0 m 231.939 0 l S Q BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10 0 0 10 55.5 108.14 Tm (Neil L. Waters )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 123.0712 108.14 Tm (\(nwaters@middlebury.edu\) is a professor of )Tj -7.95 -1.177 Td (history and the Kawashima Professor of Japanese Studies in the )Tj 0 -1.177 TD (Department of History at Middlebury College, Middlebury, VT. )Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 55.5 75.265 cm 0 0 m 231.939 0 l S Q BT /T1_3 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 7 0 0 7 55.5 46.14 Tm (\251)Tj 0.025 Tw 1.075 0 Td (2007 ACM 0001-0782/07/0900 $5.00 )Tj ET 224.785 233.64 8 8 re f BT 0 0 0 0 k /GS3 gs /T1_4 1 Tf 0 Tw 9 0 0 9 226.8544 235.692 Tm (c)Tj 0 0 0 1 k /GS2 gs /T1_5 1 Tf 0.001 Tc 0.028 Tw 6 0 0 6 327.139 18.1581 Tm [(COMMUNICATION)1(S)-242(OF THE AC)1(M)]TJ /T1_6 1 Tf 0 Tc 0.02 Tw 16.478 0 Td (September 2007/Vol. 50, No. 9)Tj /T1_5 1 Tf 0 Tw 9 0 0 9 517.9596 18.1581 Tm (17)Tj ET q 1 0 0 1 -535.852 660.147 cm 0 0 m 827.014 0 l S Q q 1 0 0 1 291.5144 660.319 cm 0 0 m 0 -611.971 l S Q endstream endobj 1 0 obj <> endobj 63 0 obj <> endobj 64 0 obj <> endobj 65 0 obj <> endobj 20 0 obj <> endobj 44 0 obj <> endobj 24 0 obj <> endobj 48 0 obj <> endobj 16 0 obj <> endobj 36 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 26 0 obj <>stream HCEPDD+Gill-Bk@!   6?C4.0(C)1992 The Font Company Inc., ALL Rights ReservedGill-BookGill-*4")/&:FQUNCS7PM 15[A/h0Io.[lw(w.w  . d, d׮h7FSqƺxRFkP5=#IReajr_L_`KYgFKwL&wPPLL..Vww X . . w.w   |l. n%+aZ$aZw.wWW.kv/k'1<'ԝǯdFdJkYU^pw˪: /&('!ɵOwp>L21NF;n{is&2\tl[wytwq]t.B@^䲡)wFIeLeLQ.ObuMXhcNWjzW^ Mwn>տL2,KI/uo<{ܦ5*4\f~mexwo`xiWfl?^;zůݢ4 GWwXNɻQAZqPUBrhoglf[QtrPK:r$$O%;;NW$&&$XW%%%%X;w.l/|~Ew.wI.mn&w.wq.F?.!I10RG??Q#!$$!6w.w.hopiiooi;K# n˦@#{vKZU<:NP6_u]ww$җscjqqjkyf|vi};w|l_ueDYϽϽQ<}tpQdz%,11;fM}vpmhckr3OnM \ endstream endobj 35 0 obj <> endobj 33 0 obj <> endobj 34 0 obj <>stream XMPKSA+Gill-Blk@*   6@D4.0(C)1992 The Font Company Inc., ALL Rights ReservedGill-BlackGill$0.6/*"54')&L)cy7^a47b3aBiL ; Ǭe3-a=e*&^X( bܵ;;[[C$$QC99Q[^ [[ ^] ![\!]pw.wZZG..^ Z.Q9w9Q.Z u.^-;wbcr.cCXY@@XbK!i`HEw.w[[[!x~H.[&Dȟw.w``.`w*w__Usnr.\.w(/b/bS((Q:)!MZeޯ!j?OTurCCAhE-:CNcbsxnbmq\[fEw aavv zG/w%waaa.aa.a0! c`! Xw.w}V}V.V-3EZoت%H0zu-L̺dTS[aJgvb'Hw@EBeXXdcZXe,\aqMN56^(#- /% 6|Ьw(f.(z|/! J  endstream endobj 15 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 14 0 obj <>stream FAPNAD+Meta-BoldAt1   ;.71991 Erik Spiekermann FontShop InternationalMeta-Bold5D**iE'>":q'ngi`Y|tiOb^= :)!Njno~ltt}y Ǥ|rux8  ՠ  endstream endobj 47 0 obj <> endobj 45 0 obj <> endobj 46 0 obj <>stream UQPGDN+GaramondThree@;p    -Copyright (c) 1988 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.Garamond 3 is a trademark of Linotype AG and/or its subsidiaries.Garamond 3GaramondThree"$.&oUmq5R$*yݝ$yB!%DF!%BA"&ED"%A'*+(),*(#bc{leG%]匷ܣ_c}rtZH%=Y󷮔$*%}81ݻ-1#B)y];?I3ZVS`? "|bv|~*wwyYH3%#bZ .d///d/.*vQXpmbGsj}usezxgw "xp~wxN׆wrq~ "wlvϊ݊r-2KKdyܩ[<Oܪyntmsdc427 O +3g[}:7Kk=.k#Q\WL=wn\r{ "w{K~M1ΙĔpopT "|qE%ZCqqqtut "s|uojD|s|du| "|cri뒑A|*whh0c]~ "{zBP|Snl=0y~Ѡv3oO*y]OFeN ('3K*q|~$wQ4(D n\ h s},VHӺl8^ųҷ[EJcJ]hvwe\*vkۣ2.%=Ǣ~}\6k8 MMiatc|5 9 *翬vV xbeNlbT}+ -p@i^zEOd@Ќ*~،+=|R]55iyvq-{@n]yhxZuzyx|HzmV*UcԳpH(`~~9zh}{e}}҂cc]G /B#kqxЋҋel$}׮qtsrrstqya yXO  endstream endobj 23 0 obj <> endobj 21 0 obj <> endobj 22 0 obj <>stream MQEHZN+AGaramond-ItalicAJ~   #vCopyright (c) 1989, 1992, 1996 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.Adobe Garamond is a trademark of Adobe Systems Incorporated.Adobe Garamond ItalicAdobe Garamond(5IF#VSMJOHUP'1T /X:LN"B4C&DZQE+G)0.*Q-;z 5 5 w~#Iaj${])P(N}}kjMrc͠_}Mk%}}_d} $fYM}<ܟww}XCvaӵw'_hI}{}}uIRtǿϬx\T^pJh|||<~}|zv˶Ћ{_pk~gqgqWcE(ī}Y,ndcW7cLZSǵěe_rwgpv$tcwl~mlnfhlxIw$FͩCm$k%[w|} $խ\RrgZ[NVAQg}s>z|b6"W7Cn͠*yrݷaQhC`.vL̅wwt~\'fLTd|buywt)v۰GгܸsYNbWe~}!~tƽw~hytYf)vZvY~ڻ˱|}hn[jz7zd@(DzwVеk _,V\xb[Y_lGSHy}ylby}|zUz [?Ho7ëzQgdtq̀ж $}xxxwGHwouuz[5w]~vkh2SIjos}{}㲸v:탕wS(;}}-m}~|ejIW|}i,b^|YWGJf*M5\ˋרhDmhlV\_Pk`run} ٨ $wI$k%[l} $dX$ݡjexzlauw,FvorWܕےn[KNvxzy{z~}m-)vI~|[2k%[l} $gX!Yd4UAċ؛΋|cgL(IP`}ܻœu,~krn`fzndziaФclzksrsqm~tm|rn|zФtf$!s tw{u|xTPij|͞Ӌs\cw3A//}dwYz}}tr} $titۡœjIIT4_cɖt̪噙noefbh $yxyDm,<{zw&d쁰Mvy{z|||}y|`yQ}ŇwӦsoqxsm˺{qkplqڮËkx{|vtssYtNdSPbVfms~ׯsyuvjsv>dPhV>(^zevtMJI^l}t5d&*|kl_`qf $}ؤyMmOy{YwPi&}[g| $gXڔjqlild $}TFb[(ws^v CwC>tqpQuo|iox~~y˖}Q`fyowcmjind`Z}m}~tE>uvuhaoE]Szv~}ڒv۰G9Ĺܸ9,?-! CIt?V^[rz| tٿÿc5(tھлw}hywXc*vZvY~‹ڻ~}hn[jz7yeI?D+-CU wH[U␶foiz~q`OD>PnʶehfqjsvتܬmrsYvT21,Z_MHvd6/}XXxI_Lrvswy~{<uyyrrvͽ+~|nq|&vQuNnMjZލԊщX^stv!4jYc~m:Z~czhrN|btSu^΍֏׋bjش j׏1]xmrY_E[AH`S}~{|ޠvAz~k~D}wYҘ s{oNG ߾־MlC_%1*MIS}ZeB#ȮˋNvjlBuw{v~yVRjk|˝޾ыt]tlTL:a&{w~yuup{ $`r^Vg,Yѥm}^{X;xLwWqyq| $io~ؕlldpyz $y{d?)3aeZeXd\{șvsulk\ $|}{jk6{(n֋{(n֋  yXO  endstream endobj 43 0 obj <> endobj 41 0 obj <> endobj 42 0 obj <>stream ELYNGM+GaramondThree-BoldSC@;pq   :6[ Copyright (c) 1988, 1990 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.Garamond 3 is a trademark of Linotype AG and/or its subsidiaries.Garamond 3 Bold Small Caps & Old Style FiguresGaramond 33FGSODT/JM-8BUz@|h )$k X |>jwa\xu~|Qwڏ}MefEcvtzl "3`,{x)` "|}ą~m wz 22~bV:\SӇ?wSQqv9ۅUTU8S{ "v|qvyxyx{ "w|4"]bvp>syxyxzƫ "uuuuӇ?wSQou5~UUSWUa $q~nͫc*vvdJzzyzy "yyyy}|E|$E˩I=oiRYiu "x|ɯ_YMUqUxdvNGD{||~ "qy~~@򓂏pppppp "{kaq[Qatttttt "~u*{6qVӗ{_+5X3̀u?a6{2BtvBc݇-ymA-IU?B3[goJ |~nDvwww ] +TTzfn| "oLLJM,^Xn[{{oUket "tԇN}hÄeu"}}Ё]vVwxyyyy| "zzzzllllll "}}sbv2wlwwwwypxk5k}ggecmg "}x$- 0ljl{z̏ "譞tu,EtSv______ "p$jnmjkpljv wciptutvq "zkp*ꊇ7Dcxyxy{[x "~zu{P >5lnm_Pgz "z|{C ])smfnnye "~*Rcw~pNN␗0c{ib}|}| "`xs' E}{p{}z "||py*v.\ NJtyd}ypwxwxy "xwxwƝhuw{sXyLS ٟ   endstream endobj 19 0 obj <> endobj 17 0 obj <> endobj 18 0 obj <>stream UXTPEX+AGaramond-Regular@K   $ -Copyright (c) 1989, 1992, 1996 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.Adobe Garamond is a trademark of Adobe Systems Incorporated.Adobe Garamond RegularAdobe GaramondKIFDBTGPSOMJQVZENH8UL *WC "RX&K:5'Y)iw<>+.$[43o0( 76/#%1@!,M69XlGab5 ` [s8M%$R/D1X?g P !H!"X""##$C$%&''(D(\(q()n*Y+w$RwVCfrz $vg<˪`K#Cfwz $pg;i,X[sogfgx\|r}yP}j[S5 :$_\deoӤϬldoj PŞho~uA$},:?JZiiz֧խtimqQ Uًыqppdt}E 8Ktxtdorz|udBhCBDWɋYf]||ƟPv}l|wX}N,?ObBThjvr]`lvgRkz~jZxwՋѱ׋ZVhan_faHzԝuu^V(SERrsSMQ`vpgCftz $ggg8}, ,1:0 s>p/33b6҈*LʋwCfxz $geȇwrfelnhr|VqtydPVCfvz $yg-ϥaR)Cfxz $ug@i8X\rqaw|Rqtyd'w6gx\|r}yPXCftz $sg9Cfvz $vgHt|Rqtyd nrwjpuxm#؀v|#Cfvz $dg܉"J&KLb~qx\sqyd}:;#[?9vlwwޠv<u~}} wV3ud]}~L;:_Ƽbŕ}~o<uTc}J8l|~xukp?zhXX^FFBҝotrqmk $z~fuWiZcy|qQew[~t}yP;$5f;-kpzz$ kzutaWXrl{ѠǸڋ_hpwr0Wsy}vn{ $p`~n&|{~~zys{x}g%aoJy]}gusj{ #js+ups7pno-ـz;ʍ|}gj:%= )xCflz $nhAuu{_-K׶vr|jWvR!1;vbvjycWy àusxrrn ${~t|ac!~n{Uimlqkr $|u~~~kZ nzM-pnlmol $|SvI|zZ|*cwwpp>zab{ $abčqzTq7|}uG*}Ա& L+dmyn966eG@(cˡNk#%!#o6Ivzvw]*"|Rj{=ƭ䊉ؒ}qWphyun>3v{!|yd %zbrlaQm\~h\;Ӆ=PKP;bi`yƄ|#!v9yCga}{x{q~жәt|Rqtydnrwjpuxm$v`kzutaWXrl{ѠǸڋ_h2uiksriiv?e`؍˿iollng $}fGoWmQjQlVdffՆqċrg][gk $}I zS~TX }Ql{ $eU]±zfrܖ|qU)]j~c|K{^lS"|Rgzˍ $kQ$wvf}g^܉~QKLciayń}""~Qr{ $iP}yd %zcqkbGmn #ʳ)"E[to^Hvuyx}ytz $zr͒y@ynnz ${p{t.~ڳxltsqt ${zqvkjY[zdusrtd $z{u0+m!"Nx{ $sQő^idbi] $yƅ|"l[[ő`id`iZ $yz""Sz{ $nS!vm|» m~}xlLxU[FW_=~}xlLxU[FW_vh| Pdq|xzebdofzʞЋgb=dq|xzebdofzʞЋgb*  *2~ҋFՍҖfgfF**_BFfgfDAFAD~2]##U*t\}v}}}~v|nzw۬ƓcicaiQ $yƆvevllrɏjptrsm $|ȁ~LT68t(TIE}au| $edŎŏ]W]UZ)VCےl5K{Zn} $k\$Mѓʒljrwvi $]oT]0-SrXrWp\sut{t-0TZyӚ͒|tPR78fc-%=GВȆʊ\?U#.oRB?PY,v⩎whvrvomXdie _X|xp"R}szHqo{!HmW]Dwsh5{kI=ML;f[J[ؐÂ}~qglA>,9RjM\Z_ObT7b||\DuqߋĪu|*"~Qr| $vQu^Ff&ҾrprzGV;ֿh[]PM)FS{z,@BXEljV[lmuycj9fezx}@36Jo~~ss|xw\|*vɎwVm|Ў~֨ЈHT=Th{e|`pË*vIzZ*}XgO%8O%>[kIkFS6 ^LF轨ϴ>2AZϮjT<B^[D؎˵RNNi^]nLGů%{ &{U.'^D;{b*-\H3rYCT(oSF9Y1 {tp{,82ΒjidPTn $yɄ7ckyzf~M](+T*Vi֑DžlxΏzVR+(\EHMIo563*IDA;ji]mp%~xzy{m]v! aZaܧjljeeo $|vz`]mGuV`$lIY]]lzah_`kn $}vS{ ',T%-Y5lŐZjbciY $zņz# B_a~եǙÊgpadfe $~mMve^x.-iq`ei] ${m\jv{\YG*k w~z{yVa $|}tvo[}g{tp} $lrx{nu9l|(hz ^˩ec*"Vyz{ $H;U|ǧj`^OL.GU|yAmz3/<'Gc2mmxxG|f)-Tm%X*G9v3t +g",/w3[ A, v}Qi{{v`<<*"Qt\{<˃ݘGJD76:6{vEݗNN4VLeuz&wkfL*4dNw|Ĺi]\M88MV|y6"Qv{ $pKאvBQeR*@Y*}&ND+1>&&>1+ND&m_--___*kQsa>za^{ $qbKzU}{tLts/q}LzT}w{0j" r܀Xe}|lQ2Z`[`qù܀͘x~;CHP[PCzKytu݀rLy|6#SbQ(g@)9ؘj}YvCyF1 L 8Z'2!2A!q`t{/*"Vw| $pSwK1`ps}tz $pius=>,~úmihhch $~}ZXxy pr}ő`id^kZ $yņ{"{(n֋{(n֋ Փ  yXO  endstream endobj 62 0 obj <>stream q 0 0.64 585 782 re W n 1 g /GS0 gs 0 782.64 0 0 re f Q BT 0 0 0 1 k /GS1 gs /T1_0 1 Tf 9 0 0 9 55.5 18.1581 Tm (16)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 0.02 Tw 6 0 0 6 77.3005 18.1581 Tm (September 2007/Vol. 50, No. 9)Tj /GS2 gs /T1_0 1 Tf 0.001 Tc 0.028 Tw 14.243 0 Td [(COMMUNICATION)1(S)-242(OF THE ACM)]TJ ET 0 0 0 1 K 0.25 w q 1 0 0 1 49.508 660.147 cm 0 0 m 827.014 0 l S Q BT /T1_2 1 Tf -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 11.5 0 0 11.5 56.5347 596.14 Tm [(U.S., culminating in a stor)-18(y on NBC N)24(ightly N)30(e)-6(ws.)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(H)30(undr)9(eds of other ne)-5(wspapers ran stories without)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(inter)-18(vie)-6(ws, based primarily on the )]TJ /T1_3 1 Tf 0 Tw 13.103 0 Td [(T)40(imes )]TJ /T1_2 1 Tf 0.025 Tw 2.424 0 Td [(ar)-8(ticle. I)]TJ -15.526 -1.087 Td (r)Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 235.0848 571.14 Tm -15.214 -1.087 Td [(eceiv)6(ed doz)6(ens of phone calls, ranging fr)5(om lauda-)]TJ -0.312 -1.087 Td [(tor)-18(y to actionably defamator)-18(y)85(. A r)10(epr)9(esentativ)6(e of)]TJ T* [(the W)10(ikimedia F)35(oundation \(www)75(.wikipedia.org\), the)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(boar)14(d that contr)6(ols W)9(ikipedia, stated that he agr)10(eed)]TJ T* [(with the position taken b)6(y the M)12(iddlebur)-18(y histor)-18(y)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(depar)-8(tment, noting that W)10(ikipedia states in its)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (guidelines that its contents ar)Tj -0.0101 Tc 11.07 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (not suitable for acade-)Tj -11.721 -1.087 Td [(mic citation, because W)10(ikipedia is, like a print ency-)]TJ T* [(clopedia, a ter)-6(tiar)-18(y sour)6(ce. I r)9(epeated this)]TJ T* (information in all my subsequent inter)Tj 0 Tw 14.678 0 Td (vie)Tj 0.025 Tw 1.061 0 Td (ws, but)Tj -15.739 -1.087 Td [(clearly the publication of the depar)-8(tment)18(\325)80(s policy)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(had hit a ner)-18(v)6(e, and many ne)-6(ws outlets implied,)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(err)6(oneously)85(, that the depar)-8(tment was at war with)]TJ 0 Tc 0 -1.087 TD (W)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.94 0 Td [(ikipedia itself)16(, rather than with the uses to which)]TJ -0.94 -1.087 Td (students w)Tj 0 Tw 4.031 0 Td (er)Tj -0.0101 Tc 0.698 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.651 0 Td (putting it. )Tj -4.336 -1.087 Td [(I)12(n the wake of my allotted 15 minutes of Andy)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(W)88(arhol-pr)6(omised fame I hav)5(e tried to figur)10(e out)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (what all the fuss was about. Ther)Tj -0.0101 Tc 12.507 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td [(is a gr)10(eat deal of)]TJ -13.158 -1.087 Td [(uneasiness about W)11(ikipedia in the U.S., as w)8(ell as in)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(the r)10(est of the computeriz)6(ed world, and a gr)9(eat deal)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(of passion and energy hav)6(e been spent in its defense. )]TJ 0 Tc 1.043 -1.087 Td (I)Tj -0.0101 Tc 0.304 0 Td [(t)-265(is)]TJ -0.01 Tc 1.387 0 Td [(clear to me that the good stuff is r)10(elated to)]TJ -2.734 -1.087 Td [(the bad stuff)16(. W)10(ikipedia o)11(w)6(es its incr)10(edible gr)6(o)12(wth)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(to open-sour)6(ce editing, which is also the r)6(oot of its)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(gr)9(eatest w)6(eakness. D)6(edicated and kno)12(wledgeable edi-)]TJ T* [(tors can and do effectiv)6(ely r)10(ev)5(erse the pr)6(ocess of)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(entr)6(opy b)6(y making entries better o)15(v)6(er time. O)6(ther)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(editors, thr)7(ough ignorance, sloppy r)]TJ 0 Tw 13.555 0 Td (esear)Tj 0.025 Tw 1.795 0 Td [(ch, or)60(, on)]TJ -15.349 -1.087 Td [(occasion, malice or z)8(eal, can and do intr)8(oduce or)]TJ T* [(perpetuate err)6(ors in fact or interpr)10(etation. The r)9(eader)]TJ T* [(nev)6(er kno)12(ws whether the last editor was one of this)]TJ T* [(latter gr)7(oup; most editors leav)6(e no trace sav)6(e a)]TJ T* (whimsical cyber-handle. )Tj 1.043 -1.087 Td [(P)54(opular entries ar)10(e less subject to enduring err)6(ors,)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(innocent or other)-18(wise, than the seldom-visited ones,)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(because, as I understand it, the fr)13(equency of visits b)6(y)]TJ -0.0101 Tc -0 -1.087 Td [(a)-265(W)]TJ -0.01 Tc 1.599 0 Td [(ikipedia \322)61(policeman)70(\323 is largely determined, once)]TJ -1.599 -1.087 Td (again, b)Tj -0.0101 Tc 2.974 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.693 0 Td (algorithms that trace the number of hits)Tj -3.667 -1.087 Td [(and mo)16(v)6(e the most popular sites to a higher priority)85(.)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(The same principle, I hav)6(e come to r)10(ealiz)5(e, pr)6(ops up)]TJ T* [(the whole of the W)10(iki-world. O)6(nce a critical mass of)]TJ T* [(hits is r)10(eached, G)6(oogle begins to guide those who)]TJ 21.212 47.826 Td [(consulted it to W)10(ikipedia befor)9(e all else. A ne)-5(w but-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(ton on my v)6(ersion of F)34(ir)9(efo)6(x goes dir)9(ectly to)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(W)10(ikipedia. P)29(r)10(efer)10(ential access leads to y)6(et mor)10(e hits,)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (generating a still higher priority in an endless loop of)Tj T* [(mutual r)10(einfor)5(cement. )]TJ 1.043 -1.087 Td [(I)24(t seems to me that ther)10(e is a major do)12(wnside to)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(the self-r)10(einfor)5(cing cy)12(cle of popularity)85(. P)54(opularity)]TJ T* [(begets ease of use, and ease of use begets the \322)50(democ-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(ratization)70(\323 of access to information. B)12(ut all too)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (often, democratization of access to information)Tj 0 Tw 18.099 0 Td (is)Tj 0.025 Tw -18.099 -1.087 Td (equated with the democratization of the information)Tj 0 Tw T* (itself)Tj -0.0101 Tc 1.743 0 Td (,)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.505 0 Td [(in the sense that it is subject to a v)6(ote. That)]TJ -2.248 -1.087 Td (last mental conflation may hav)Tj -0.0101 Tc 11.645 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (origins that pr)Tj 0 Tw 5.387 0 Td (edate)Tj 0.025 Tw -17.682 -1.087 Td [(W)10(ikipedia and indeed the whole of the I)12(nternet. )]TJ 1.043 -1.087 Td [(The quiz sho)12(w \322F)48(amily F)35(eud)12(\323 has been a fixtur)10(e)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(of daytime television for decades and is wor)-8(th a)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (quick look. Contestants ar)Tj -0.0101 Tc 9.987 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td [(not r)10(e)-6(war)14(ded for guess)-1(-)]TJ -10.638 -1.087 Td [(ing the corr)11(ect answ)7(er but rather for guessing the)]TJ T* [(answ)6(er that the largest number of people hav)6(e cho-)]TJ T* [(sen as the corr)10(ect answ)6(er)59(. The sho)12(w must tap into)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (some sor)Tj -0.0101 Tc 3.335 0 Td (t)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.562 0 Td (of popular desir)Tj -0.0101 Tc 5.966 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (to democratiz)Tj -0.0101 Tc 5.186 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0 Tw 0.651 0 Td (informa)Tj 0 Tc 3.01 0 Td (-)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw -19.361 -1.087 Td [(tion. V)89(alidation is not conformity to v)10(erifiable facts)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(or w)6(eighing of interpr)9(etations and evidence but con-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(formity to popular opinion. E)6(xper)-8(tise plays practi-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(cally no r)7(ole at all. )]TJ 1.043 -1.087 Td [(H)18(er)9(e is wher)10(e all but the most hopelessly post-)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(modernist scholars bridle. \322F)48(amily F)36(eud)11(\323 is harmless)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(enough, but most of us believ)6(e in a r)10(eal, external)]TJ T* (world in which facts exist independently of popular)Tj 0 -1.087 TD [(opinion, and some interpr)10(etations of ev)6(ents, thor)-1(-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(oughly gr)7(ounded in disciplinar)]TJ -0.0101 Tc 11.692 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.693 0 Td (rigor and the w)Tj 0 Tw 5.837 0 Td (eight)Tj 0.025 Tw -18.222 -1.087 Td (of evidence, ar)Tj -0.0101 Tc 5.462 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (at least mor)Tj -0.0101 Tc 4.412 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (likely to be right than)Tj -11.176 -1.087 Td [(others that ar)10(e not. I tell my students that W)10(ikip)-1(edia)]TJ T* [(is a fine place to sear)6(ch for a paper topic or begin the)]TJ 0 Tc T* (r)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.312 0 Td [(esear)6(ch pr)6(ocess, but it absolutely cannot ser)-18(v)6(e subse-)]TJ -0.312 -1.087 Td [(quent stages of r)10(esear)6(ch. W)9(ikipedia is not the dir)10(ect)]TJ T* [(heir to \322F)48(amily F)36(eud,\323 but both seem to shar)9(e an)]TJ T* [(element of faith\321that if enough people agr)10(ee on)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(something, it is most likely so)18(.)]TJ 1.043 -1.087 Td [(What can be done? The answ)8(er depends on the)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td (goal. I)Tj -0.0101 Tc 2.369 0 Td (f)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.545 0 Td [(it is to make W)11(ikipedia a tr)-6(uly authoritativ)]TJ 0 Tc 16.268 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc -19.182 -1.087 Td [(sour)6(ce, suitable for citation, it cannot be done for)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(any general ter)-8(tiar)-18(y sour)6(ce, including the )]TJ /T1_3 1 Tf 0 Tw 15.717 -0 Td [(E)18(ncy)6(clopae-)]TJ 0.025 Tw -15.717 -1.087 Td (dia B)Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 481.2168 71.14 Tm -13.721 -1.087 Td (ritannica.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 3.823 -0 Td [(F)36(or an anonymous open-sour)6(ce ency-)]TJ -5.819 -1.087 Td (clopedia, that goal is theor)Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 367.3869 58.64 Tm 4.18 -1.087 Td [(etically)85(, as w)5(ell as)]TJ ET q 1 0 0 1 49.9647 660.2673 cm 0 0 m 0 -613.527 l S Q BT 0.5 0.2 0 0.1 k /T1_4 1 Tf 0.055 Tc 0 Tw 28 0 0 28 58.9275 672.6533 Tm [(Vie)15(wpoint)]TJ ET q 1 0 0 1 194.2457 687 cm 0 0 m 0 -26.5 l S Q endstream endobj 60 0 obj <> endobj 61 0 obj <> endobj 32 0 obj <> endobj 31 0 obj <> endobj 29 0 obj <> endobj 30 0 obj <>stream OCNYJC+GillSans@6z#   -|Copyright (c) 1990 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.Gill Sans is a trademark of The Monotype Corpration Plc.Gill Sans7JFXQPOU/M-8BSTIZ:V$LE.5DNGH )\+k&)CdQ:y dfY]vDw>*`sas)DCvUw).U2U0snnssnns?xJiWXwU5X}:? 5/ ׼vҗʲ`GЗv^wcUI ,\^Z^, *evqw&}(28.;U.4OK8onp)^$''$"%!;L4*PO-5P*v҂w\*U2U`IG6YYr`iт;;7:O쨻ugjkqez""v>wTV>/b=>\Cv>w.>2>4w@>)>*C  jppjjppjvw>*NjRj.QjPj)Dvts"/|wy{C0JZwbh*tSs2>`IJ3YYr`ihev;wJJU' &B-]v>wSK  *_vUw[xIU2bneucNl2J淿xRł$.DEm1,d#YԤY>7p>8-*0uZCvQQաqbiqvcktckbh?vUww`U![puy |y Y2> twwW>2gom..$0Q21$iᩢv+wLY>0wv/>ff]v>3hv?`hW5-(.ėw^ge/Oܲi vւwUUUUlBfGQ0K\f_dm\Ra`u]]$v.>=Xyeeggva3jL;:Тӛsz%HJ^F_W$`9UM @P+jotҀsx}`ornwyx؀=xhdIېƋ Z  yXO  endstream endobj 59 0 obj <>stream q 0 0.64 585 782 re W n 1 g /GS0 gs 0 782.64 0 0 re f Q BT 0 0.7 0.8 0.1 k /GS1 gs /T1_0 1 Tf 42.879 0 0 43.312 139.8525 433.64 Tm (T)Tj 0 0 0 1 k /T1_1 1 Tf 0.025 Tw 11.5 0 0 11.5 162.1076 458.64 Tm (he case for an online open-)Tj 0 Tw -0.011 -1.087 Td (sour)Tj 0.025 Tw 1.647 0 Td [(ce ency)12(clopedia is)]TJ -1.647 -1.087 Td (enormously appealing.)Tj -1.838 -1.087 Td [(What)18(\325)80(s not to like? I)23(t giv)6(es the)]TJ 0.098 -1.087 Td (originators of entries a means to)Tj 0.835 -1.087 Td [(publish, albeit anonymously)87(,)]TJ 0.154 -1.087 Td (in fields they car)Tj -0.0001 Tc 6.409 0 Td (e)Tj 0 Tc 0 Tw 0.671 0 Td (deeply)Tj 0.025 Tw -7.504 -1.087 Td [(about and pr)6(o)16(vides editors the)]TJ -7.999 -1.087 Td [(oppor)-8(tunity to impr)6(o)16(v)6(e, add to, and polish them, a)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(capacity not affor)16(ded to in-print ar)-6(ticles. A)]TJ 0 Tw 16.64 0 Td [(bo)16(v)]TJ -0.0001 Tc 1.396 0 Td (e)Tj 0 Tc 0.671 0 Td (all,)Tj 0.025 Tw -18.706 -1.087 Td [(open sour)7(cing marshals legions of unpaid, eager)64(,)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(fr)9(equently kno)12(wledgeable v)6(olunteers, whose enor-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(mous aggr)10(egate labor and energy makes possible)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(the cr)10(eation of an entity\321W)10(ikipedia, which today)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(boasts mor)10(e than 1.6 million entries in its E)5(nglish)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(edition alone\321that would other)-18(wise be far too)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(costly and labor-intensiv)6(e to see the light of day)85(. )]TJ T* [(I)12(n a sense it would hav)6(e been technologically)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(impossible just a fe)-6(w y)6(ears ago; open sour)6(cing is)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(democracy in action, and W)13(ikipedia is its most)]TJ T* (ubiquitous and accessible)Tj 0 Tw 10.045 0 Td [(cr)10(eation. )]TJ -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw -9.001 -1.087 Td [(Y)90(et I am a historian, schooled in the concept that)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(scholarship r)10(equir)9(es accountability and trained in a)]TJ T* (discipline in which collaborativ)Tj -0.0101 Tc 11.804 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td [(r)10(esear)5(ch is rar)10(e.)]TJ -12.455 -1.087 Td [(The idea that the v)6(ector-sum pr)6(oducts of tens or)]TJ T* [(hundr)10(eds of anonymous collaborators could hav)6(e)]TJ T* [(much v)6(alue is, to say the least, counterintuitiv)6(e for)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(most of us in my pr)7(ofession. W)78(e don)70(\325)80(t allo)11(w our stu-)]TJ 0 -1.087 Td [(dents to cite printed general ency)15(clopedias, much)]TJ -0 -1.087 Td [(less open-sour)7(ce ones. F)]TJ 0 Tw 9.044 0 Td [(ur)-8(ther)]TJ -0.0101 Tc 2.281 0 Td (,)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.505 0 Td [(while W)10(ikipedia)]TJ -11.83 -1.087 Td [(compar)10(es fav)5(orably with other ter)-7(tiar)-19(y sour)6(ces for)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(ar)-8(ticles in the sciences, appr)6(o)6(ximately half of all)]TJ T* [(entries ar)10(e in some sense historical. H)18(er)9(e the qualita-)]TJ T* [(tiv)6(e r)9(ecor)14(d is much spottier)60(, with r)10(eliability decr)9(eas-)]TJ 21.056 35.87 Td [(ing in appr)7(o)6(ximate pr)6(opor)-8(tion to distance fr)6(om )]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (\322hot topics)Tj -0.0101 Tc 4.116 0 Td (\323)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.659 0 Td (in American histor)Tj -0.0101 Tc 7.112 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.693 0 Td [([1]. F)36(or a J)]TJ 0 Tw 4.133 0 Td (apan)Tj 0.025 Tw -16.713 -1.087 Td [(historian like me to per)6(ceiv)6(e the positiv)5(e side of)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(W)10(ikipedia r)9(equir)10(es an effor)-8(t of will. )]TJ -0.0101 Tc 1.043 -1.087 Td (I)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.593 0 Td [(made that effor)-8(t after an innocuous series of)]TJ 0 Tw -1.636 -1.087 Td (ev)Tj 0.025 Tw 0.802 0 Td [(ents briefly and impr)6(obably pr)6(opelled me and the)]TJ 0 Tw -0.802 -1.087 Td (histor)Tj -0.0101 Tc 2.177 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.693 0 Td (depar)Tj 0.025 Tw 2.105 0 Td (tment at M)Tj 0 Tw 4.382 0 Td (iddlebur)Tj -0.0101 Tc 3.199 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.693 0 Td (College into the)Tj -13.249 -1.087 Td [(national, ev)6(en international, spotlight. While grad-)]TJ T* [(ing a set of final examinations fr)6(om my \322H)18(istor)-18(y of)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (Early J)Tj 0 Tw 2.525 0 Td (apan)Tj -0.0101 Tc 1.73 0 Td (\323)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.659 0 Td [(class, I noticed that a half-doz)9(en stu)]TJ 0 Tc (-)Tj -0.01 Tc -4.913 -1.087 Td (dents had pr)Tj 0 Tc 4.75 0 Td (o)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.46 0 Td [(vided incorr)10(ect information about two)]TJ -5.21 -1.087 Td [(topics\321the S)12(himabara R)12(ebellion of 1637\3201638 and)]TJ T* [(the Confucian thinker O)6(gyu S)12(orai\321on which they)]TJ 0 Tc 0 -1.087 TD (w)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.644 0 Td [(er)10(e to write brief essays. M)23(or)10(eo)16(v)6(er)59(, they used vir)-8(tu-)]TJ -0.644 -1.087 Td [(ally identical language in doing so)16(. A quick check on)]TJ T* [(G)6(oogle pr)6(opelled me via popularity-driv)6(en algo)-1(-)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(rithms to the W)10(ikipedia entries on them, and ther)10(e,)]TJ T* [(quite plainly)85(, was the err)6(oneous information. T)120(o)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD [(head off similar ev)6(ents in the futur)10(e, I pr)5(oposed a)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (policy to the histor)Tj -0.0101 Tc 7.207 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0 Tw 0.693 0 Td (depar)Tj 0.025 Tw 2.105 0 Td (tment it pr)Tj 0 Tw 4.158 0 Td (omptly)Tj 0.025 Tw -14.163 -1.087 Td [(adopted: \322\(1\) S)26(tudents ar)]TJ -0.0101 Tc 9.555 0 Td [(e)-265(r)]TJ -0.01 Tc 0.963 0 Td (esponsible for the accu)Tj 0 Tc 8.595 0 Td (-)Tj -0.01 Tc -19.113 -1.087 Td [(racy of information they pr)6(o)16(vide, and they cannot)]TJ T* [(point to W)10(ikipedia or any similar sour)6(ce that may)]TJ T* (appear in the futur)Tj -0.0101 Tc 7.126 0 Td (e)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.651 0 Td (to escape the consequences of)Tj -7.777 -1.087 Td [(err)6(ors. \(2\) W)9(ikipedia is not an acceptable citation,)]TJ T* [(ev)6(en though it may lead one to a citable sour)6(ce.\323 )]TJ 1.043 -1.087 Td [(The r)10(est, as they say)85(, is histor)-18(y)85(. The M)12(iddlebur)-18(y)]TJ -1.043 -1.087 Td [(student ne)-5(wspaper ran a stor)-18(y on the ne)-6(w policy)85(.)]TJ 0 -1.087 TD (That stor)Tj -0.0101 Tc 3.536 0 Td (y)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.693 0 Td [(was picked up online b)8(y)]TJ /T1_2 1 Tf 9.459 -0 Td (The B)Tj 0 Tw 2.248 0 Td [(ur)12(lington)]TJ 0 Tc -15.936 -1.087 Td [(F)34(r)]TJ -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.81 0 Td (ee P)Tj 0 Tc 1.455 0 Td (r)Tj -0.01 Tc 0 Tw 0.311 0 Td (ess, )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf -0.0102 Tc 1.345 -0 Td [(a)-265(V)]TJ -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 1.225 0 Td (ermont ne)Tj 0 Tw 3.944 0 Td (wspaper)Tj -0.0101 Tc 2.998 0 Td (,)Tj -0.01 Tc 0.025 Tw 0.505 0 Td (which ran its o)Tj 0 Tw 5.643 0 Td (wn)Tj 0.025 Tw -18.236 -1.087 Td (stor)Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 343.7119 96.14 Tm -2.495 -1.087 Td [(y)85(. I was inter)-18(vie)-6(w)6(ed, first b)6(y V)100(ermont radio and)]TJ -1.426 -1.087 Td [(TV stations and ne)-6(wspapers, then b)6(y )]TJ /T1_2 1 Tf 14.297 -0 Td [(The N)30(ew Y)84(or)5(k)]TJ 0 Tw -14.297 -1.087 Td (T)Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 463.0414 71.14 Tm -13.713 -1.087 Td (imes,)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 2.08 -0 Td (the )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 0.025 Tw 1.453 0 Td [(A)-6(sahi S)12(himbun )]TJ /T1_1 1 Tf 5.873 0 Td [(in T)120(oky)6(o, and b)5(y radio)]TJ -9.99 -1.087 Td (and TV stations in A)Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 413.5053 58.64 Tm -1.997 -1.087 Td [(ustralia and thr)6(oughout the)]TJ /T1_3 1 Tf 0.0231 Tc 0 Tw 0 6 -6 0 43.1942 46.5125 Tm [(LISA)-243(HANEY)]TJ 0.5 0.2 0 0.1 k /T1_4 1 Tf 0.055 Tc 28 0 0 28 51 672.6533 Tm [(Vie)15(wpoint)]TJ 0 0 0 1 k /GS2 gs 0 Tc 0.028 Tw 16 0 0 16 190.6243 673.14 Tm [(Neil L. W)60(aters )]TJ ET 0 0 0 1 K 0.25 w q 1 0 0 1 48.5 660.165 cm 0 0 m 488.624 0 l S Q q 1 0 0 1 186.3175 687.1589 cm 0 0 m 0 -26.5 l S Q q 1 0 0 1 48.6934 660.1274 cm 0 0 m 0 -612.75 l S Q q 1 0 0 1 537.2195 660.22 cm 0 0 m 0 -612.75 l S Q 0 0 0 0 k q 1 0 0 1 56.599 378.145 cm 0 0 m 2.828 99.201 l 75.372 93.701 l 77.119 77.701 l 82.206 48.94 l 78.372 31.69 l 92.686 14.453 l 94.535 8.72 l 89.729 1.69 l 84.372 -0.31 l 48.517 -0.483 l f* Q q 56.599 378.145 m 59.427 477.346 l 131.971 471.846 l 133.718 455.846 l 138.805 427.085 l 134.971 409.835 l 149.285 392.598 l 151.134 386.865 l 146.328 379.835 l 140.971 377.835 l 105.116 377.662 l W* n q /GS3 gs 96.6000061 0 0 97.3000031 55.5079956 376.4779968 cm /Im0 Do Q Q BT 0 0 0 1 k /GS1 gs /T1_4 1 Tf 36 0 0 36 53.3743 558.843 Tm [(Wh)35(y Y)140(ou Can\325)39(t Cite )]TJ 0 -0.861 TD (Wikipedia in My Class )Tj 16 0 0 16 55.3237 504.8533 Tm [(The online encyclopedia\325)80(s method of ad)9(ding inf)10(ormation )]TJ 0 -1 TD (risks conflating facts with popular opinion. )Tj /T1_5 1 Tf 0.001 Tc 6 0 0 6 327.139 18.1581 Tm [(COMMUNICATION)1(S)-242(OF THE AC)1(M)]TJ /T1_3 1 Tf 0 Tc 0.02 Tw 16.478 0 Td (September 2007/Vol. 50, No. 9)Tj /T1_5 1 Tf 0 Tw 9 0 0 9 517.9596 18.1581 Tm (15)Tj 1 g /T1_6 1 Tf -0.333 Tc 1 0 0 1 -1000 1782.64 Tm ( )Tj ET endstream endobj 55 0 obj <> endobj 56 0 obj <> endobj 57 0 obj <> endobj 40 0 obj <> endobj 39 0 obj <> endobj 37 0 obj <> endobj 38 0 obj <>stream BXCMSM+Meta-BoldAt1   .71991 Erik Spiekermann FontShop InternationalMeta-Bold8  ՠ  endstream endobj 6 0 obj [/Indexed/DeviceCMYK 68 5 0 R] endobj 5 0 obj <>stream """+++ UUUJ^^^[MMM9 <<<333DDD(3MM33f3f3333fff~ooo3f3f3f33MM3fM9ff33ffMM9M93MMfMM93fwwwMfwMf~M3ffMff3MMwԈwff~33333MM9M33M9f3fM endstream endobj 7 0 obj <>stream HWv==\gXB+Aɉ#+ZAi}ٜcZ؇on~_u~UkC8H6&[:&. QiT^""p&R^1ٍaw=Zy_2EaDe¸k!vFkSe1͕hCgaXШ0R)rcN[2&V:֍ [_k%e!X;F"4RdA}eETuHl2 DV !Fȉٔk`J5֚h?[ B[qYbvU2pZiDB&[uBгbÉ҂yI*N,9QUVbad㨮jMkf.HK֨ –sZ(LJ.TiȞKW^YzGJYF;TLTN-5N\cN×(yJ-pw2(I*S)u)YM (E׊J]mK&RZmu&J=O$ʵg/4T#@rG]3 uH/"&Ɠft ؏bʥu~Iwi]:lX{]Jh@L3zSc9,΢NwR!pnPVI }賆 Gw(KRC*Dp (c'wi)M-5ʢ[J[CIZuy;=v< X=Bҩ_8I)6Jys\:]7vu=SnY(0ķBJPx%rsSwq>iLuf 9[![RH<'SbW=QP2{q6x~":(+ } ,8.7Pk 2x0!!Pq1Vmώ$>M@ҶxE\ `XגG :=}ncD QJ^O蟡Po1`>*;ۋ%sضslcZ󟏢 EN s6+Gh^<R[sZ[4 -+Q(y><峿?XCm;o{4' Rk"~~9~nN6TsI"ݽD8Qb 2{x|^񧐔1(ٚB4C(:d+R`z2_1V/IªJi@ t^`oU4t'HF`[~]~xqS:Ml۸W [#P8Ɇ7uA:ɺ[uine>Ng.!~$ [ϹC@ <4ʂ7Ο^7q+l' : o.|e* mHQC'GjhΡy_^@ Рs3FnFA$j)w߇Òڊq֟iLCQz쟚e[omD>7ie.hE'I^~]\A}W.ba_-BNnD3' WC^!/GlCNzWa>j 5`"rBaar+F>{q/r>M])d10wq̦ sIcšFg=?+$0utb.1cH2+Ud}٪Vɖ="~[N@\^zZ k(0:Ės&dob}mrn<>Nvt}!<('1ׂ}~Yy˂2پkEl$8?$z]e끴ds:3@$BDa6 )M`YzxX1=`Qu+[4J6{P0oS?S S?tWv=xksO0mjӨ`jAZ@b> * Xɬ e-ӟL-a`U+xf@9-;2|%8BHMu-m;'C|^Z>k"2j[? sBv7L?(0R'}{r؂d ))`$629*d%M1Bh(Ȳ zKQ'>\.GC0]e"8`*Тd K_uA3࿔W o8 `؎MhuI#Ed[dfz;3Үh$Jg^z@@IʛSEAee ҠJ(pm"DC@}aFoۧò:R 9 듵p$ é:-p s\<%PI(ÀLhy&K}=\+' }BDd2<,ᘗyi hYˣ^Y;8ٜhi\6(OOi'-j·piG O\F"$H*6{I'- i$]+Xjb+ 'ypKNc H'J}:KU' hY@MFHGT/X$k{ShP%%XD9EejG씐 Su 5ːYZ|i!ZbNѻ_g8GrZSEQ Ӹ,4K)T`蟑9YBg~;C&koG֖RLQKcj'IU{z<8YgqN˝K@ p~즨}bu7 *5V3ґ;S M]쇝8i%['OYp]|E=t9 }iaYUGZHfb`Fy #H@C.2f-mvdH#Dg9SO%tҒ,  Hïd3AmaR*` z50t#is !!Y]1㐅?~3:r;`9&b dTaWzW_,p RhQxF.ў?[zrv.t-)ERZ%U'2&ڴ:J!<,u\:ؚ ""JpH `|{mE16(dKm.T/?GˣM 80.M̧il3AQ-@"ƣGuY`Ȃ+*1oCK-|%,>E{D;0&pzV֋:=w.倱+1 "oIH°|Q*(\ B^wʤE{pBȥL7RuHtogj^zT*cl~KKut KAs : τFLB&ѧPPE*y0B]4mZvN8~$gkt(NL:tp~/k1 ?I0ZnVx@.Prd?E%=CeW"¹71Դ)̥"P9˙8େ<xE( O3k>z'g[ +=uT/}\(,M)v ; ̞o@C&I+6P*Z*Z ʼA6$T79wg Mn ×"\Ue+eǔUy 'c ;b58'yq'q Mڮ.K "ԁQTMKKJ<7:ld(`#Ή8}0͚mc^u!)~o>*ak,!a6Ix @S\3Yܹ/{)p6E )0^؋VOpPDOdsLbߐYi jw?@q:ToF7Sx2Y_t;ˠgm~ ’JAEI8 cݱWR:Bb~=m>g=2 v̡Wmpc;Tji԰˷orWeamvc#]v$оۤ2sL>*km A9D;ҶIٹ 7fm[[oPZ l/ql^X|F+K)[vߞ~vZϪۻ8^+g&eX=3m/B\s_NI!L \Sg ChuӮ JsGgǹLS5fJYeuhRgp@|}oʊL "7PY WV7YmPAdE[zn@mhg)Qn" qΓD0zUצCeJmO*!shٴ뮰s:!_Ihu;V]unᱻ(.&1ŖKfϨA?_3ugH G浍CwLO~OOݓUp>]hئ*..wnz2/q01M.:a1Йn/9Sa)pyDLWBQ^3 Se% ƻd!CRN »MnrfDrֽS8e%r&1ʒNW}T-N"Ad4dţms!Hr&GJi Yx2"/u)1!8Z_QE,EN`!z0xN}Z,ïpݸ`U0 }TmA/nf44KD|ߣwﵜ[x_,XW=s}>!%V H۞Ve1BWZ ߅w8<6F` } RwNB'4Eޗ4E0#Oӣr;%cTn(}LB?O.S\ ̛׿~`T/ endstream endobj 54 0 obj <> endobj xref 0 69 0000000002 65535 f 0000009357 00000 n 0000000003 00001 f 0000000004 00001 f 0000000008 00001 f 0000065348 00000 n 0000065302 00000 n 0000065673 00000 n 0000000009 00001 f 0000000010 00001 f 0000000011 00001 f 0000000058 00001 f 0000003818 00000 n 0000016694 00000 n 0000016782 00000 n 0000016487 00000 n 0000011697 00000 n 0000030803 00000 n 0000031235 00000 n 0000030592 00000 n 0000009621 00000 n 0000020145 00000 n 0000020395 00000 n 0000019931 00000 n 0000010646 00000 n 0000012723 00000 n 0000012953 00000 n 0000012521 00000 n 0000012158 00000 n 0000053113 00000 n 0000053318 00000 n 0000052911 00000 n 0000052342 00000 n 0000015023 00000 n 0000015177 00000 n 0000014816 00000 n 0000011875 00000 n 0000064927 00000 n 0000065014 00000 n 0000064720 00000 n 0000064574 00000 n 0000027577 00000 n 0000027740 00000 n 0000027359 00000 n 0000010289 00000 n 0000017416 00000 n 0000017606 00000 n 0000017209 00000 n 0000011242 00000 n 0000003751 00000 n 0000003861 00000 n 0000004194 00000 n 0000004431 00000 n 0000000016 00000 n 0000071963 00000 n 0000064351 00000 n 0000064428 00000 n 0000064500 00000 n 0000000066 00001 f 0000055691 00000 n 0000052193 00000 n 0000052270 00000 n 0000043110 00000 n 0000009398 00000 n 0000009475 00000 n 0000009547 00000 n 0000000000 00001 f 0000004703 00000 n 0000000097 00000 n trailer <<45128EAD8E6F492BAE59DCD65EE192AB>]>> startxref 72193 %%EOF